Realty.com
Buy

Start here

  • Homes for sale by state
  • Home buying tips
  • Before you start looking
  • The buying timeline

Afford it

  • Today's mortgage rates
  • Mortgage calculator
  • How much can I afford?
  • Get pre-approved

Make the deal

  • Writing a winning offer
  • Inspections & appraisals
  • Closing costs, itemized
  • Find a buyer's agent
Sell

Selling Options

  • What's my home worth?
  • Compare selling options
  • Get an instant cash offer
  • Buy before you sell

Resources

  • How selling works
  • When should I sell?
  • Home selling tips
  • Pricing your home
  • What's worth fixing first
  • Find a seller's agent
Home Loans
Find an Agent
Save searchAdvertiseSign In
Saved homesSaved searchesYour toursYour inquiriesRecently viewedAccount settings

Save search

Map layers

Safety

Safety & registry resources

Review official public-safety information for any area from these government sources:

  • U.S. Dept. of Justice National Sex Offender Public Website (NSOPW)
  • FBI: state sex-offender registry directory
Realty.com
Buy

Start here

  • Homes for sale by state
  • Home buying tips
  • Before you start looking
  • The buying timeline

Afford it

  • Today's mortgage rates
  • Mortgage calculator
  • How much can I afford?
  • Get pre-approved

Make the deal

  • Writing a winning offer
  • Inspections & appraisals
  • Closing costs, itemized
  • Find a buyer's agent
Save searchAdvertiseSign In
Saved homesSaved searchesYour toursYour inquiriesRecently viewedAccount settings
  • Rentals
  • Commercial

Sell

Selling Options

  • What's my home worth?
  • Compare selling options
  • Get an instant cash offer
  • Buy before you sell

Resources

  • How selling works
  • When should I sell?
  • Home selling tips
  • Pricing your home
  • What's worth fixing first
  • Find a seller's agent
Home Loans
Find an Agent
Save search
3 bedsWith a pool
Homes Under $2.5M in Sanibel, FL
426 listings

Homes Under $2.5M in Sanibel, FL

Homes Under $2.5M in Sanibel, FL

Hide Map
12 of 426 Listings
Map

Homes Under $2.5M in Sanibel, FL

12 of 426 Listings

  1. 1785 Middle Gulf Dr Unit B-203 — photoNew7

Your local brokerage

TO

Thomas O'Leary

Realty.com

Lic. #BK3453168

Call Thomas
Active

$1,498,000

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,348 sqft

1785 Middle Gulf Dr Unit B-203, Sanibel, FL

Dawn Marie Ramsey · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 2445 W Gulf Dr Unit 35B — photoNew30Active

    $980,000

    2 bd · 2 ba · 1,243 sqft

    2445 W Gulf Dr Unit 35B, Sanibel, FL

    David Schuldenfrei · Gopher Enterprises

  • 1919 Olde Middle Gulf Dr Unit 401 — photoNew41Active

    $850,000

    2 bd · 2 ba · 1,160 sqft

    1919 Olde Middle Gulf Dr Unit 401, Sanibel, FL

    Susan McCallion · McCallion and McCallion

  • 1625 Serenity Ln — photo34Active

    $767,000

    3 bd · 2 ba · 2,058 sqft

    1625 Serenity Ln, Sanibel, FL

    Kerri Maw · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 9436 Yucca Ct — photoNew46Active

    $875,000

    3 bd · 2 ba · 2,367 sqft

    9436 Yucca Ct, Sanibel, FL

    Kerri Maw · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 5663 Baltusrol Ct Unit 2B — photo47Active

    $1,050,000

    3 bd · 4 ba · 2,348 sqft

    5663 Baltusrol Ct Unit 2B, Sanibel, FL

    Phaidra McDermott · Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc.

  • 1785 Middle Gulf Dr Unit a103 — photo47Active

    $1,299,000

    3 bd · 2 ba · 1,348 sqft

    1785 Middle Gulf Dr Unit a103, Sanibel, FL

    Phaidra McDermott · Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc.

  • 5117 Sea Bell Rd Unit F111 — photo29Active

    $549,000

    2 bd · 2 ba · 1,207 sqft

    5117 Sea Bell Rd Unit F111, Sanibel, FL

    Karen Bell · Michael Saunders & Company

  • 760 Sextant Dr Unit 811 — photo37Active

    $475,000

    2 bd · 2 ba · 1,439 sqft

    760 Sextant Dr Unit 811, Sanibel, FL

    Kerri Maw · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 475 Las Tiendas Ln — photo50Active

    $1,390,000

    5 bd · 3 ba · 2,469 sqft

    475 Las Tiendas Ln, Sanibel, FL

    Wendy Kirschner · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 3312 Saint Kilda Rd — photo44Active

    $1,395,000

    4 bd · 3 ba · 1,786 sqft

    3312 Saint Kilda Rd, Sanibel, FL

    Eric Pfeifer · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 760 Sextant Dr Unit 622 — photo41Active

    $945,000

    2 bd · 3 ba · 1,608 sqft

    760 Sextant Dr Unit 622, Sanibel, FL

    Kerri Maw · Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 12…18

    Explore Sanibel homes

    By price

    • Homes Under $400K
    • Homes Under $500K
    • Homes Under $600K
    • Homes Under $700K
    • Homes Under $800K
    • Homes Under $900K
    • Homes Under $1M
    • Homes Under $1.25M
    • Homes Under $1.5M
    • Homes Under $1.75M
    • Homes Under $2M
    • Homes Under $2.25M
    • Homes Under $2.5M
    • Homes Over $3M
    • Luxury Homes

    By bedrooms

    • 2 Bedroom Homes
    • 3 Bedroom Homes
    • 4 Bedroom Homes

    By type

    • Single-Family Homes
    • Condos

    By feature

    • Homes with a Pool
    • Waterfront Homes
    Realty.com

    L. Custen Realty, Inc. d/b/a Realty.com/L. Custen Realty CT, LLC d/b/a Realty.com (Tom O’Leary-Broker)(CT properties only), 8323 Southwest Freeway, Suite 900, Houston, Texas 77074

    Equal Housing OpportunityEqual Housing Lender

    The information provided by this website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Listing data is derived from various Multiple Listing Services; each source MLS and its required disclaimer are shown with the listings on the applicable page. Realty.com is an independently owned and operated brokerage.

    © 2026 Realty.com. All rights reserved.·Privacy·Terms·California Privacy Rights·Accessibility·Licensing

    Your local brokerage

    TO

    Thomas O'Leary

    Realty.com

    Lic. #BK3453168

    Call Thomas

    Listing data & MLS disclosures

    Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service
    IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed.
    Florida Gulf Coast MLS/Royal Palm Coast Realtor Association(SWFLMLS)
    IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
    Listing information ©2026 Florida Gulf Coast MLS®, Inc®. All Rights Reserved. Last Updated: 2026-10-14 21:30:36 UTC

    Sanibel housing market

    September 2026 · This period is still settling

    Sanibel 12-month median sale price trend

    Selling at 92.5% of asking price

    Buyers here are paying below asking. MLS · 22 sales · as of Sep 25, 2026

    Homes that sold · County records, as of Sep 25, 2026

    Median sale price
    $1,000,000$635,000–$1,175,000 typical range
    Price per sq. ft.
    $381
    Sales
    21
    Paid in cash
    42.9%

    Homes on the market · MLS, as of Sep 27, 2026

    Median list price
    $984,250
    Homes for sale
    214

    Price trend · Assessor repeat sales, as of Sep 30, 2026

    Year-over-year
    6.4%

    Housing stock — every home in the area, not only the ones selling or listed · Assessor records, as of Sep 11, 2026

    Median home size
    2,223 sq. ft.

    Sanibel, FL community profile

    Population
    7,282
    Median income
    $119,835
    Housing units
    7,914
    People per sq. mi.
    209.3
    Area
    34.8 sq. mi.

    Source: HJN community data