Listings in 14138 - Cattaraugus County, New York

Page 1 of 1

Displaying 1 – 200 of 120 Real estate listings

37 S Main Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 28, 2020
Price: $15,600
Living Area: 2,444 Sq. Ft.

4 Cherry
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 03, 2016
Price: $62,900
Living Area: 1,344 Sq. Ft.

217 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 13, 2015
Price: $45,900
Living Area: 2,017 Sq. Ft.

224 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 30, 2016
Price: $65,000
Living Area: 1,863 Sq. Ft.

18 Prospect Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 07, 2017
Price: $98,500
Living Area: 1,894 Sq. Ft.

12902 Route 39
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 25, 2017
Price: $61,900
Living Area: 1,684 Sq. Ft.

8967 Buttermilk Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 01, 2017
Price: $22,500
Living Area: 1,596 Sq. Ft.

Picture of VL Route 322 (Dexters Corners)

VL Route 322 (Dexters Corners)
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 05, 2018
Price: $31,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

9114 Route 62
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Oct, 18, 2016
Price: $57,000
Living Area: 1,056 Sq. Ft.

12128 Ruckh Hill Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 14, 2016
Price: $84,900
Living Area: 1,456 Sq. Ft.

227 Oak Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 27, 2018
Price: $20,300
Living Area: 1,312 Sq. Ft.

421 Route 322
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 26, 2019
Price: $99,900
Living Area: 4,800 Sq. Ft.

12122 Ruckh Hill Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 17, 2016
Price: $169,000
Living Area: 3,808 Sq. Ft.

110 Maple Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 12, 2018
Price: $22,000
Living Area: 1,476 Sq. Ft.

00 Route 62
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 19, 2023
Price: $399,900
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

15 Cherry Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 25, 2024
Price: $165,000
Living Area: 1,268 Sq. Ft.

524 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 18, 2024
Price: $174,900
Living Area: 6,862 Sq. Ft.

VL Kellogg Hill Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 24, 2025
Price: $150,500
Living Area: 2,784 Sq. Ft.

209 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 20, 2019
Price: $109,900
Living Area: 6,660 Sq. Ft.

3 Third Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 07, 2019
Price: $12,500
Living Area: 1,792 Sq. Ft.

219 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 17, 2019
Price: $22,900
Living Area: 2,074 Sq. Ft.

3 3rd Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 06, 2022
Price: $154,900
Living Area: 1,792 Sq. Ft.

119 Maple Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 16, 2022
Price: $99,900
Living Area: 1,596 Sq. Ft.

601 Route 83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 05, 2022
Price: $174,900
Living Area: 1,584 Sq. Ft.

MILLER RD Miller Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 05, 2023
Price: $235,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

1247 Cassadaga Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 01, 2023
Price: $215,000
Living Area: 2,336 Sq. Ft.

8511 Balcom Cross Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 17, 2024
Price: $169,900
Living Area: 1,248 Sq. Ft.

431 Route 322
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 26, 2024
Price: $40,000
Living Area: 43,560 Sq. Ft.

216 Oak Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 29, 2025
Price: $189,900
Living Area: 1,092 Sq. Ft.

1098 Rt-83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 14, 2025
Price: $114,900
Living Area: 1,274 Sq. Ft.

0 N Hill Road
Villenova, NY | Pending
Listed: Aug, 31, 2024
Price: $50,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

222 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Active
Listed: Aug, 07, 2025
Price: $19,900
Living Area: 5,760 Sq. Ft.

Dredge Road
Dayton, NY | Active
Listed: May, 24, 2025
Price: $23,500
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

7396 Smith Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 30, 2020
Price: $93,000
Living Area: 2,016 Sq. Ft.

312 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Nov, 05, 2020
Price: $79,900
Living Area: 2,107 Sq. Ft.

9970 Cottage Nashville Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 13, 2021
Price: $149,900
Living Area: 1,372 Sq. Ft.

9315 N Hill Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 04, 2021
Price: $115,000
Living Area: 1,344 Sq. Ft.

8040 Oaks Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 13, 2022
Price: $39,900
Living Area: 1,624 Sq. Ft.

12951 Route 39
Perrysburg, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 14, 2021
Price: $424,900
Living Area: 3,454 Sq. Ft.

8907 Cottage Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 22, 2021
Price: $109,900
Living Area: 2,040 Sq. Ft.

9943 Cottage Nashville Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 02, 2021
Price: $184,900
Living Area: 1,944 Sq. Ft.

VL Us-62 Highway
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Oct, 01, 2025
Price: $75,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

312 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Active
Listed: Jan, 23, 2026
Price: $139,900
Living Area: 2,107 Sq. Ft.

1184 Cassadaga Road
Villenova, NY | Pending
Listed: Sep, 06, 2025
Price: $65,000
Living Area: 1,502 Sq. Ft.

1146 Cassadaga Road
Villenova, NY | Active
Listed: Aug, 21, 2025
Price: $89,900
Living Area: 2,090 Sq. Ft.

12011 US-62
Dayton, NY | Active
Listed: Aug, 13, 2025
Price: $315,000
Living Area: 1,639 Sq. Ft.

10439 Mosher Road
Perrysburg, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 07, 2021
Price: $159,000
Living Area: 950 Sq. Ft.

8 3rd Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 08, 2022
Price: $85,900
Living Area: 996 Sq. Ft.

1151 Route 83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 29, 2019
Price: $39,900
Living Area: 1,986 Sq. Ft.

28 1st Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 13, 2020
Price: $154,900
Living Area: 2,781 Sq. Ft.

113 Cherry Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 04, 2020
Price: $75,000
Living Area: 1,558 Sq. Ft.

8745 Dye Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 24, 2019
Price: $77,900
Living Area: 1,680 Sq. Ft.

38 Main Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 21, 2018
Price: $10,000
Living Area: 600 Sq. Ft.

12469 Cottage Markham Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 08, 2016
Price: $89,900
Living Area: 1,475 Sq. Ft.

9389 Merrill Drive
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 10, 2017
Price: $166,000
Living Area: 2,400 Sq. Ft.

216 Oak Street
, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 30, 2015
Price: $15,900
Living Area: 1,092 Sq. Ft.

73 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 03, 2017
Price: $79,900
Living Area: 1,758 Sq. Ft.

481 Route 83 N
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 26, 2017
Price: $110,000
Living Area: 2,317 Sq. Ft.

17 Mill Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 01, 2017
Price: $29,900
Living Area: 1,100 Sq. Ft.

8745 Dye Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Nov, 13, 2023
Price: $154,000
Living Area: 1,680 Sq. Ft.

Foe Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 21, 2025
Price: $250,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

12128 Ruckh Hill Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 08, 2025
Price: $179,900
Living Area: 1,440 Sq. Ft.

206 Mill Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 24, 2025
Price: $99,000
Living Area: 1,244 Sq. Ft.

7789 Mile Strip Road
Cherry Creek, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 11, 2025
Price: $210,000
Living Area: 1,963 Sq. Ft.

208 Oak Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 18, 2025
Price: $135,000
Living Area: 1,429 Sq. Ft.

12929 Kent Switch Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 07, 2022
Price: $325,000
Living Area: 5,044 Sq. Ft.

10180 Allegany Road
Hanover, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 16, 2019
Price: $85,000
Living Area: 1,040 Sq. Ft.

7985 Kellogg Hill Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 06, 2020
Price: $190,000
Living Area: 2,452 Sq. Ft.

9965 Mosher Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 25, 2020
Price: $149,900
Living Area: 1,710 Sq. Ft.

54 Main Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 01, 2020
Price: $27,000
Living Area: 2,134 Sq. Ft.

12580 Smith Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 10, 2021
Price: $69,900
Living Area: 1,552 Sq. Ft.

103 2nd Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 22, 2024
Price: $116,900
Living Area: 1,166 Sq. Ft.

1141 Cassadaga Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 27, 2022
Price: $119,000
Living Area: 1,600 Sq. Ft.

8637 Cottage Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 06, 2023
Price: $279,900
Living Area: 2,200 Sq. Ft.

8045 Wolf Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 14, 2022
Price: $44,500
Living Area: 1,573 Sq. Ft.

7839 Kellogg Hill Road
Leon, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 24, 2025
Price: $91,000
Living Area: 2,784 Sq. Ft.

217 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 29, 2024
Price: $10,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

127 Cherry Street
Dayton, NY | Active
Listed: Jan, 23, 2026
Price: $124,000
Living Area: 1,452 Sq. Ft.

8890 Cottage Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 24, 2023
Price: $239,900
Living Area: 2,520 Sq. Ft.

8782 Cottage Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 27, 2023
Price: $300,000
Living Area: 1,860 Sq. Ft.

669 Route 83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 21, 2024
Price: $169,000
Living Area: 988 Sq. Ft.

669 Route 83 Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 22, 2023
Price: $155,000
Living Area: 988 Sq. Ft.

127 Cherry Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Oct, 09, 2023
Price: $70,000
Living Area: 1,452 Sq. Ft.

8563 Route 62
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 06, 2024
Price: $39,000
Living Area: 1,938 Sq. Ft.

8790 Dye Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 29, 2024
Price: $209,900
Living Area: 1,872 Sq. Ft.

8772 Ball Hill Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Nov, 24, 2023
Price: $89,900
Living Area: 980 Sq. Ft.

274 Kent Switch Road
Cherry Creek, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 08, 2024
Price: $135,000
Living Area: 1,256 Sq. Ft.

421 Route 322
Villenova, NY | Pending
Listed: May, 28, 2025
Price: $99,900
Living Area: 4,800 Sq. Ft.

216 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 12, 2022
Price: $299,000
Living Area: 2,016 Sq. Ft.

24 Second Avenue
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 20, 2024
Price: $169,900
Living Area: 875 Sq. Ft.

00 Route 322
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 02, 2024
Price: $199,900
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

0 Dredge Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 23, 2021
Price: $29,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

11 3rd Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 29, 2019
Price: $92,500
Living Area: 1,772 Sq. Ft.

318 Pine Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 21, 2019
Price: $35,500
Living Area: 2,066 Sq. Ft.

9909 Mosher Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 05, 2019
Price: $179,900
Living Area: 1,560 Sq. Ft.

8428 Route 83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 01, 2020
Price: $112,500
Living Area: 2,100 Sq. Ft.

VL Kellogg Hill Road
Leon, NY | Pending
Listed: Mar, 24, 2025
Price: $220,000
Living Area: 2,784 Sq. Ft.

1141 Cassadaga-Hamlet Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Mar, 03, 2017
Price: $64,900
Living Area: 1,600 Sq. Ft.

9812 Cottage Nashville Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 09, 2015
Price: $99,400
Living Area: 2,024 Sq. Ft.

8395 Route 83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 15, 2017
Price: $49,500
Living Area: 1,794 Sq. Ft.

886 Bartlett Hill Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 20, 2017
Price: $87,000
Living Area: 2,340 Sq. Ft.

121 Oak Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Oct, 10, 2018
Price: $26,500
Living Area: 2,208 Sq. Ft.

7838 Route 83
Cherry Creek, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 25, 2015
Price: $64,900
Living Area: 1,152 Sq. Ft.

9271 Dye Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 07, 2015
Price: $67,900
Living Area: 1,200 Sq. Ft.

12902 Route 39
, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 29, 2017
Price: $61,900
Living Area: 1,684 Sq. Ft.

9389 Merrill Drive
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 12, 2017
Price: $166,000
Living Area: 2,400 Sq. Ft.

8745 Dye Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 08, 2016
Price: $78,900
Living Area: 1,680 Sq. Ft.

752 Route 83
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 28, 2018
Price: $139,900
Living Area: 1,696 Sq. Ft.

12154 Bentley Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 11, 2015
Price: $185,000
Living Area: 2,252 Sq. Ft.

Picture of 9753 Cottage-South Dayton Road

9753 Cottage-South Dayton Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: May, 12, 2016
Price: $35,000
Living Area: 1,451 Sq. Ft.

12469 Cottage Markham Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 08, 2016
Price: $89,900
Living Area: 1,070 Sq. Ft.

9812 Cottage-Nashville Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 31, 2015
Price: $99,400
Living Area: 2,024 Sq. Ft.

0 Route 62
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 26, 2017
Price: $99,900
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

10332 Allegany Road
Hanover, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 07, 2022
Price: $164,900
Living Area: 1,344 Sq. Ft.

54 Main Street
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 27, 2021
Price: $149,900
Living Area: 2,134 Sq. Ft.

Picture of 9120 Silver Creek So Dayton Road

9120 Silver Creek So Dayton Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 18, 2020
Price: $79,999
Living Area: 1,848 Sq. Ft.

9040 Buttermilk Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Jun, 14, 2021
Price: $159,900
Living Area: 1,540 Sq. Ft.

9858 Mosher Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Nov, 26, 2019
Price: $34,900
Living Area: 1,275 Sq. Ft.

8514 White Road
Dayton, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 17, 2019
Price: $18,000
Living Area: 156 Sq. Ft.

730 Bartlett Hill Road
Villenova, NY | Closed
Listed: Nov, 05, 2021
Price: $134,900
Living Area: 1,059 Sq. Ft.

Page 1 of 1