Homes Under $500K in Bay Shore, NY

12 listings

Save search

3 beds New construction With a pool

Hide Map

12 Listings

Map

Homes Under $500K in Bay Shore, NY

12 Listings

Your local brokerage

Thomas O'Leary

Realty.com

Lic. #10311208632

Call Thomas

10Active
$305,000
1 bd · 1 ba · — sqft
157 Newbrook Lane 157, Bay Shore, NY
Jack Ramsay · Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
27Active
$469,000
2 bd · 1 ba · 980 sqft
35 Montauk Drive, Bay Shore, NY
Elisabeth Marino CBR · HomeSmart Premier Living Rlty
14Active
$499,999
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,127 sqft
263 N 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore, NY
Doris M. Kennedy · Kennedy L I Realty

Listing data & MLS disclosures

OneKey MLS: The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

Bay Shore housing market

August 2026 · This period is still settling

Selling at 104.1% of asking price

Buyers here are paying above asking. MLS · 28 sales · as of Aug 31, 2026

Homes that sold · County records, as of Aug 7, 2026

Median sale price: $643,500$606,750–$806,750 typical range
Sales: 10
Paid in cash: 10.0%

Homes on the market · MLS, as of Aug 24, 2026–Aug 31, 2026

Median list price: $665,000
Homes for sale: 75
Median days on market: 23 days

Housing stock — every home in the area, not only the ones selling or listed · Assessor records, as of Aug 20, 2026

Median home size: 1,618 sq. ft.

Bay Shore, NY community profile

Area: 14.9 sq. mi.

Source: HJN community data

Explore Bay Shore homes

Listing data & MLS disclosures

OneKey MLS: The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

Your local brokerage

Thomas O'Leary

Realty.com

Lic. #10311208632

Call Thomas

By feature

Your local brokerage

Thomas O'Leary

Realty.com

Lic. #10311208632

Call Thomas

Bay Shore, NY community profile

Area: 14.9 sq. mi.

Source: HJN community data

Bay Shore housing market

August 2026 · This period is still settling

Selling at 104.1% of asking price

Buyers here are paying above asking. MLS · 28 sales · as of Aug 31, 2026

Homes that sold · County records, as of Aug 7, 2026

Median sale price: $643,500$606,750–$806,750 typical range
Sales: 10
Paid in cash: 10.0%

Homes on the market · MLS, as of Aug 24, 2026–Aug 31, 2026

Median list price: $665,000
Homes for sale: 75
Median days on market: 23 days

Housing stock — every home in the area, not only the ones selling or listed · Assessor records, as of Aug 20, 2026

Median home size: 1,618 sq. ft.

Registered offenders on the map

Registered offenders on the map

Registered offenders on the map

Registered offenders on the map

Your local brokerage

Listing data & MLS disclosures

Bay Shore housing market

Homes that sold · County records, as of Aug 7, 2026

Homes on the market · MLS, as of Aug 24, 2026–Aug 31, 2026

Housing stock — every home in the area, not only the ones selling or listed · Assessor records, as of Aug 20, 2026

Bay Shore, NY community profile

Explore Bay Shore homes

Listing data & MLS disclosures

Your local brokerage

By feature

Your local brokerage

Bay Shore, NY community profile

Bay Shore housing market

Homes that sold · County records, as of Aug 7, 2026

Homes on the market · MLS, as of Aug 24, 2026–Aug 31, 2026

Housing stock — every home in the area, not only the ones selling or listed · Assessor records, as of Aug 20, 2026