Matthew Caternolo
This profile has not yet been claimed or personalized. If you are Matthew, you can claim and unlock this agent profile to showcase your experience, specialties, and contact details for prospective buyers and sellers. Matthew Caternolo appears to specialize in selling homes in areas including: Irondequoit, NY, Rochester, NY, Webster, NY, Perinton, NY, Walworth, NY, Gates, NY, Greece, NY, Penfield, NY, Sweden, NY, Brighton, NY. List prices for homes in these areas have ranged from $6 to $479,900.
25
Closed Sales
$4.8M
Total Value
$6 - $479.9K
Price Range
$191.8K
Average Price
Instantly unlock your home value, equity, and risk-free cash offer for your home.
SOLD/OFF MARKET LISTINGS
-
Irondequoit NY Home for Sale
Welcome home to this beautiful and meticulously maintained Ranch in East Irondequoit! Great location on a neighborhood street just seconds away from shopping, dining and more. The pride in ownership is apparent as soon as you pull up. This picturesque home is equipped with a double-wide, concrete driveway and a well manicured lawn. Trex deck in the back with a newer Kohler awning is great for entertaining or just enjoying the breeze. The inside of the home is spotless, with newer white berber carpets and appliances. Partially finished basement provides great potential for an in-law suite or extra bedroom, and includes a kitchen and full bath. This cozy ranch has been wondefully maintained for years and is sure to impress! Most appliances, backup generator, awning, and heater in the garage are included. Delayed showings until Thursday 8/4, no delayed negotiations.
❮❯Closed$184,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1433 sqft
150 Angelus Drive
Irondequoit, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - eXp Realty, LLC -
Rochester NY Home for Sale
This 2- unit Boston is a fantastic investment or owner/occupied property! Upstairs has 2BD and a small office. Downstairs has 3 BD. Both units have n eat-in kitchen, dining room, original gumwood trim, butler's pantry, pocket doors and wood floors! There are 3 porches and a rear balcony. There is a 2- car garage, carport and shed. Plenty of parking. Separate utilities. Laundry in basement. Full walk-up attic. Group showings/Open house only on Thurs 6/23 5-7, Saturday and Sunday 6/25,26 from 12-2. Delayed negotiations to take place on Monday 6/27 @ 5PM
❮❯Closed$125,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- 2944 sqft
246-248 Flower City Park
Rochester, NY
Listing by: Patricia Sikula Thayer - Howard Hanna -
Webster NY Home for Sale
Don't miss out on this beautiful end unit at Hillsboro! 1st floor living convenience on Marina View! Gorgeous gleaming hardwood floors throughout living, dining & 1st floor bedroom. Skylight floods natural light! Cozy up to the gas fireplace and relax in the living room. Plenty of space for entertaining with the open dining room. You will love putting together your favorite meal in the chef friendly kitchen with all appliances and is open to the entertaining space. First floor primary bedroom with jacuzzi tub in the bathroom. First floor laundry . Private guest suite on 2nd floor with full bath. Partially finished basement with egress for safety. 2 car garage. HOA covers exterior maintenance. Amazing location with easy access to everything! Proof of financing with offers. Delayed negotiations Wednesday June 29th at 4pm. Parking spaces for guests.
❮❯Closed$275,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1941 sqft
310 Marina View Lane
Webster, NY
Listing by: Tiffany A. Hilbert - Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester -
Perinton NY Home for Sale
Wonderful 3 bedroom Home in a Quiet Neighborhood with a park like yard in Fairport School District!*Living Room has Fireplace that was never used!*Lovely Kitchen that opens onto a large deck overlooking a park like yard!*Dining Room is Open to the Living Room*3 Bedrooms upstairs and one bathroom*Family Room and Laundry Room on Lower Level which connects to the Garage!*Great Location to Shopping, Fairport, Pittsford and East Rochester Villages!*Easy Access to 490 thruway!
❮❯Closed$215,800 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 1414 sqft
103 Crescent Road
Perinton, NY
Listing by: Robert J. Ruhland - Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester -
Rochester NY Home for Sale
This two family home would be perfect for either owner occupancy or two unit investment. The lower unit has two bedrooms (one does not currently have a closet), 1full bath, a living room, a partially updated eat-in kitchen, and access to the basement. The upper unit has two bedrooms, 1 full bath, a living room, a kitchen, an enclosed porch and access to the attic. Windows are updated and both units are vacant. Utilities (electric and gas) are separated. Roof age is unknown. The lower level furnace is from 2008 as are both water heaters. The upper unit furnace (in the attic) is currently not in operation and is in as-is condition. The basement has glass block windows. Two car garage and lots of driveway parking. Very profitable as an investment. Extremely easy showings.Delayed negotiations until 4/4/23 at 11am.
❮❯Closed$77,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 1871 sqft
535 Clay Avenue
Rochester, NY
Listing by: Mary Wenderlich - Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester -
Walworth NY Home for Sale
Well maintained ONE Owner Spacious Raised Ranch,3 Bedrooms and 2.5 Baths built in 1999 on almost one acre, Parking for 4 in Oversized 3 Car attached Garage & 1.5 Story Pole Barn w/ Electric(24x16), Master Suite-Oversize Tub, Walk-in Closet, Master Bath & Kitchen Skylights, 8' Ceilings, Tankless Hot Water, Ceiling Fans, Roof on Back of House(2016),Inset Tile in Basement, Sellers Motivated!!
❮❯Closed$194,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2273 sqft
1844 Plank Road
Walworth, NY
Listing by: Tim A Reynolds - Cornerstone Realty Associates -
Webster NY Home for Sale
** OPEN SUNDAY 1-3 PM!! ** HARD TO FIND! Ranch End Unit Townhome! You will enjoy the ease of living in this fresh & ready home in the Village of Webster. Walk to parks, restaurants, gym, stores. Close to 104 for easy access to more! Living room offers vaulted ceilings, skylight & gas fireplace! Open to the Dining area of the Kitchen for a great flow. Kitchen appliances included. Walk out to your private patio from the sliding doors. Laundry Rm with storage very convenient. 2 generous sized Bedrooms & Full Bath finish the floor plan. Brand New Carpets in Bedrooms & Living room. Furnace cleaned/inspected 6/2019. New Roof and Skylight coming aprox 2020 by HOA. DON'T WAIT! Life Is Full of Memories ~ Here is a Wonderful Place to Keep Them!! DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS UNTIL SUNDAY 6/9 at 6PM
❮❯Closed$97,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 848 sqft
11 Reynolds Road
Webster, NY
Listing by: Susan P. Aser - RE/MAX Plus -
Gates NY for Rent
Located in Gates Business Park off of Buffalo Road in the Town of Gates. +/- 2,800 SF of Office and Warehouse with loading dock available for lease! Asking $6.00 PSF NNN. Call for more details!
❮❯Closed$6 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- 14960 sqft
25 Bermar Park
Gates, NY
Listing by: Richard Rock - RE/MAX Plus -
Webster NY Home for Sale
Beautiful Webster home on a lovely neighborhood street! Immaculately kept home is beautiful inside and out! Walk in through the 2 story foyer. Large and spacious open layout on the first floor, including a formal dining room (used as an office) and a large eat-in kitchen that opens up in to the 2 story great room and gas fireplace. Equipped with a 1st floor master suite and 1st floor laundry. Take a walk upstairs to an open loft (can be built out for an extra bedroom or used as an office/work area), two good-sized bedrooms and another full bath. You can also enjoy the nice weather out on the back patio! All mechanicals have been serviced regularly. Call for more details!
❮❯Closed$309,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1998 sqft
816 Houston Road
Webster, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - RE/MAX Plus -
Irondequoit NY Home for Sale
Price Reduced!!Gorgeous, large and updated colonial located on a beautiful much desired street...3 bedrooms (plus additional living space on finished 3rd floor not included in square footage), 3 full baths including master bath...1st floor powder room...Updates include kitchen, master bath, roof and heating system (and many more)...Central air has been added!! All the original charm incliding leaded glass and built ins ..Huge fireplaced living room with bordered hardwood flooring...This home is very special !!
❮❯Closed$182,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 4 ba
- 1830 sqft
55 Couchman Avenue
Irondequoit, NY
Listing by: Alan M. Kerstein - Howard Hanna -
Webster NY Home for Sale
SPECTACULAR 2344 SF 5 BDRM 3 FULL BATH COLONIAL NESTLED IN POPULAR CRANBERRY COVE. STUNNING 2 STORY FOYER W/ T STAIRCASE. FORMAL DIN RM FEATURING HWD FLOORS, TRAY CEILING AND BAY WINDOW. LIVING ROOM W/FRENCH DOORS LEADING TO OPEN FRONT PORCH, HWD FLOORS & POCKET DOORS TO FAMILY ROOM W/GAS FIREPLACE. KITCHEN BOASTS PANTRY, TILED BACK SPLASH AND ELEGANT DINING AREA W/FLOOR TO CEILING BAY WITH SLIDER TO PATIO OVERLOOKING TREED PRIVATE YARD. 1ST FLOOR BEDROOM/OFFICE WITH FULL BATH - (PERFECT FOR IN-LAW SITUATION) 1ST FLR LAUNDRY WITH AMPLE SPACE. 4 SIZABLE BEDROOMS UP , MSTR W/LOVELY ON SUITE & LARGE WALK IN CLOSET. UNFINISHED BONUS ROOM PERFECT FOR STORAGE. BASEMENT HAS WALK UP TO 3 CAR GARAGE. ROOF DONE 5 YEARS AGO - HURRY THIS IS A HONEY!DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS UNTIL 6/29/2020 AT 5PM
❮❯Closed$319,900 Closed- 5 bds
- 3 ba
- 2344 sqft
1241 Thistleberry Lane
Webster, NY
Listing by: Joy A. Sherry - Howard Hanna -
Rochester NY Home for Sale
Welcome home to this beautiful 3 bedroom 1 and a half bathroom city home! Enjoy the maintenance free life of a newer home that features vinyl siding, windows, central A/C a newer hot water tank and many more updates. You will love huge fully fenced in back yard. you will love having a nice cup of coffee on the beautiful front porch. SHOWINGS START FRIDAY JULY 17 AT 12PM NO SHOWINGS AFTER SUNDAY JULY 19 AT 7PM. OFFERS REVIEWED MONDAY July 20 11 AMSHOWINGS START SATURDAY JUNE 27TH AT 11AM NO SHOWINGS AFTER MONDAY JUNE 29TH AT 7PM. OFFERS REVIEWED TUESDAY JUNE 30TH 6PM
❮❯Closed$119,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1736 sqft
433 Clay Avenue
Rochester, NY
Listing by: Anthony Gonzalez - NORCHAR, LLC -
Greece NY Home for Sale
Excellent waterfront living with a lovely view from every room, overlooking both Buck Pond & Lake Ontario! Renovated from top to bottom in 2013. Master suite features 10 ft ceilings, his & her closets, private 2nd story balcony, custom bath with natural slate tile & walk-in shower. Bedrooms feature newer Tuftex stain resistant carpets and double closets. Den/game room can be additional first floor bed. Built-in home audio system & 1-touch dim lights. 1st flr features an open layout with Brazilian Pecan hardwood flrs throughout, two-sided stone fireplace, and French Doors to four-season room. Entertainers' dream with outside deck and patio overlooking the water. Kitchen features granite countertops with white maple cabinets & stainless steel appliances. Luxurious lakefront living!
❮❯Closed$479,900 Closed- 5 bds
- 3 ba
- 2562 sqft
1306 Edgemere Drive
Greece, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - RE/MAX Plus -
Greece NY Home for Sale
Welcome home to this wonderfully maintained Ranch in the heart of Greece! True in-law suite in basement with private entrance, full kitchen and full bath. Updated bathrooms. Laundry hook-ups on 1st floor and in basement; WASHER & DRYER ON 1ST FLOOR NOT INCLUDED, all other appliances stay. Beautiful eat-in kitchen with sliders opening up to Trex deck and lovely view to your park-like private backyard. This home has a lot to offer, come see for yourself!
❮❯Closed$189,900 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2000 sqft
98 Mill Road
Greece, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - RE/MAX Plus -
Penfield NY Home for Sale
Turn-Key Ranch on a quiet street. Close to shopping, expressways, dining, and entertainment. Completely updated with beautiful finishes including granite countertops, stainless appliances, wood floors, new windows, natural gas generator, and more. Relax and enjoy the screened-in patio with a quiet scenic view. Don't miss out on this opportunity!! Delayed negotiations until Sunday 11/22 at 7 PM.
❮❯Closed$189,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 1124 sqft
53 White Village Drive
Penfield, NY
Listing by: Michael Conroy - RE/MAX Plus -
Irondequoit NY Home for Sale
Well maintained home ready for move-in! This charming ranch has spacious rooms and an open kitchen/dining area. Very convenient to expressways, shopping, medical, and more.
❮❯Closed$115,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 1104 sqft
68 Culverton Drive
Irondequoit, NY
Listing by: Michael Conroy - RE/MAX Plus -
Gates NY Home for Sale
UPDATES GALORE!! NEW FROM TOP TO BOTTOM. SITTING ON AN EXTRA LARGE CORNER LOT. OPEN AND SPACIOUS LIVING ROOM AND KITCHEN. 1ST FLOOR LAUNDRY. MASSIVE 1ST FLOOR BATHROOM. ROOF 2018, ALL NEW ELECTRICAL PANEL AND WIRING 2018, APPLIANCES 2018, WINDOWS 2018, ALL NEW FLOORING, NEW PLUMBING, GLASS BLOCK BASEMENT WINDOWS. GREENLIGHT INTERNET AVAILABLE. AVERAGE RG&E $155/ MONTH. DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS THURSDAY 4/8 9AM
❮❯Closed$119,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 1092 sqft
114 Ford Avenue
Gates, NY
Listing by: Colin Dombek - Keller Williams Realty Gateway -
Sweden NY Home for Sale
Roam freely through 4 acres of mostly wooded land, enjoy a firepit out back, and plenty of room to grow a garden...space to call your own! This property is close enough to Brockport and Bergen yet secluded enough to feel out in the country. This split level has beautiful hardwoods, 2 full bathrooms, room for a workshop in the garage and plenty of storage space. Spacious 2 car garage was added in 09 with a 100 amp sub panel. Roof is 2014. New pressure tank for the well was installed Oct 18. Start your summer in this beauty and make it your own!
❮❯Closed$159,900 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1452 sqft
1741 Reed Road
Sweden, NY
Listing by: David R Shewan - Coldwell Banker Custom Realty -
Penfield NY Home for Sale
Welcome home! Fantastic contemporary split in a sought-after neighborhood in the heart of Penfield. Bright and open layout with lots of updates. New roof [2014], hot water heater [2020], furnace with Isaac Gold Seal. Enter from the 2-car garage to a huge family room with electric fireplace and slider to back patio. Up a few steps is the living/dining room combo with loads of light, and a patio door to the two tier deck. Appliances stay in the updated eat-in kitchen. Upstairs find a large main bath and 3 bedrooms. Partially finished space in lower level. Washer/Dryer to stay. Private, partially fenced-in backyard has mature trees and a shed complete with drywall/carpet/electric perfect for a home office or teen hangout. Showings begin Thursday 6/3 at 10:30am, Delayed negotiations until Sunday, 6/6 at 12pm. Don't miss this one!
❮❯Closed$219,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1820 sqft
56 Hallmark Road
Penfield, NY
Listing by: Joe A Cassara - Cassara Realty Group -
Rochester NY Home for Sale
Great opportunity for a multi family in NWV with a 10% cap rate! 2-unit up and down. Upstairs unit needs some cosmetic work, but pays $500/mo, lease expires 6/22. Downstairs unit was recently redone, pays $745/month, lease expires 6/22. The downstairs dishwasher is inoperable. Garage is equipped with a furnace and potential to become a third rental unit, currently being rented out for storage at $200/month, agreement expires 11/21. All units are separately metered with tenants paying their own utilities. Additional income for owner through coin-operated laundry in basement. C of O expires 12/25. House needs some work, being sold as-is. Delayed negotiations until Sunday 6/19 at 12:00 PM.
❮❯Closed$144,900 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- 1267 sqft
228 Humboldt Street
Rochester, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - eXp Realty, LLC -
Brighton NY Home for Sale
Welcome home to this charming Cape Cod in the town of Brighton with Penfield Schools! Quiet neighborhood, this home offers lovely curb appeal that leads into an open concept living/dining room combo with refinished hardwood floors and new flooring in the kitchen. Private backyard looking into the woods makes it a great place to enjoy your morning coffee on your newly refinished deck, or can be enjoyed anytime with plenty of room for activities! 2 good-sized bedrooms on the lower level topped off by the large Master-Suite upstairs with recently updated bathroom. All appliances, window AC units, and dehumidifier stay. Partially finished basement creates more space for entertaining. This home is a gem you won't want to miss!
❮❯Closed$184,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1360 sqft
70 Cloverland Drive
Brighton, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - eXp Realty, LLC -
Penfield NY Home for Sale
Delayed showings Thursday 9/9 FROM NOON - 8 PM, Friday from noon-8 PM. Please use showing time for any open 30 minute block. Wear mask if not vaccinated. Public Open House Saturday 9/11 from 11 - 1230 PM. Sunday GO BILLS. Offers due by Tuesday 9/14 at 11 AM. Please allow 24 hours to respond. Thank you. True 4 Bedroom Colonial in mature Penfield neighborhood. Current owner had 10 large trees removed to open up back and front yards. All new flooring off first floor including W/W/C in Living room. Bright open Cherry Kitchen, Corian counter-tops with all new appliances included. Sky light off addition done years ago by previous owners. Huge BRAND NEW stamped concrete patio off Family Room with space for plenty of company. Large Lot in popular neighborhood! Great location within 5 minutes to Eastside Y, Wegmans/Target Plaza and Scribner Rd School. Updated Master and double vanity floor to ceiling tiled main Bath, gas fireplace insert in Family Room. Updated hardwoods throughout second floor.
❮❯Closed$249,900 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 1983 sqft
63 Brougham Drive
Penfield, NY
Listing by: Tim Kayes - RE/MAX Realty Group -
Penfield NY Home for Sale
Beautiful and bright contemporary split level home with 3 bed/1.5 bath located on a neighborhood street in Penfield. Open layout with recent updates; roof 2014, hw tank 2020, recently refinished hardwoods, and new laminate on most of the first floor. Newer eat-in kitchen and bathrooms. Large backyard equipped with a two-tier deck, partially fenced-in patio, shed, and plenty of trees for privacy. Partially finished basement has potential for home office/rec room/man cave/etc. This one is a MUST SEE!
❮❯Closed$275,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1820 sqft
56 Hallmark Road
Penfield, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - eXp Realty, LLC -
Webster NY Home for Sale
Meticulously maintained 2 bed/2.5 bath Ranch home located in Webster Commons! Walk in to an open layout leading to the living room equipped with cathedral ceilings. The Sun Room (added 2007) provides a great space to enjoy any leisure time. An example of "pride of ownership" at it's finest, this turn-key home has been updated almost completely from top to bottom. Updated kitchen with soft-close cabinets/drawers and underglow lighting 2020; updated master bath 2020; new AC 2020; resealed driveway 2021; newer roof, garbage disposal, furnace, hot water tank and more! Full, partially finished basement, equipped with half bath, provides a great space for additional office/rec room/etc. Second refrigerator in the garage is included with the rest of the appliances. Great location on a neighborhood street situated near the heart of Webster, only walking distance to various stores, shops, restaurants and more. This house is a MUST-SEE!Delayed showings until Thursday 10/21 at 9:00 AM; delayed negotiations until Monday 10/25 at 2:00 PM.
❮❯Closed$244,900 Closed- 2 bds
- 3 ba
- 1212 sqft
177 Cranbrook Terrace
Webster, NY
Listing by: Matthew W Caternolo - eXp Realty, LLC -
Greece NY Home for Sale
Lovely cape cod in Greece situated on a private lot! Updated landscaping! Walk in and fall in love. Large well-lit living room! Formal dining room opens to the kitchen. All appliances included! First floor offers an immaculate full bathroom! On the second floor, you will find two bedrooms and an updated second full bathroom! Loads of closet space! Relax on the front porch and enjoy the private fenced-in backyard! Furnace and A/C 2019! Hot Water Tank 2017! Newer vinyl windows and custom blinds! Two-car garage with electric and additional storage space! Large dry basement with glass block windows! Dont miss this well-maintained home that has been cared for by its owners. All offers are due by Monday, December 13th, 10 am.
❮❯Closed$119,900 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1056 sqft
91 Worcester Road
Greece, NY
Listing by: Danielle R. Johnson - Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester