Nathan Custer
This profile has not yet been claimed or personalized. If you are Nathan, you can claim and unlock this agent profile to showcase your experience, specialties, and contact details for prospective buyers and sellers. Nathan Custer appears to specialize in selling homes in areas including: Noblesville, IN, Arcadia, IN, Pendleton, IN, Indianapolis, IN, Carmel, IN, Westfield, IN. List prices for homes in these areas have ranged from $995 to $1,100,000.
23
Closed Sales
$5M
Total Value
$995 - $1.1M
Price Range
$215.4K
Average Price
Instantly unlock your home value, equity, and risk-free cash offer for your home.
SOLD/OFF MARKET LISTINGS
-
Noblesville IN Home for Sale
This stunning 3 Bdrm, 2 Bath "Ranch + Bonus" checks all the boxes. Enter through a welcoming covered porch to this charmer that showcases 9' ceilings and a well-executed layout that features open living/gathering spaces. Updated kitchen features plenty of cabinet and countertop space. The private Master Bdrm is located opposite of secondary bedrooms is spacious and features walk-in closet, pond view, and a luxurious Master Bath with tile floors, dual vanities, large soaking tub, and separate shower. Finished bonus room upstairs offers loads of possibilities! Finished garage with utility sink. Enjoy the serene setting of the fully-irrigated yard with views of the pond and wildlife from your vine-covered pergola and stamped rear patio.
$275,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1881 sqft
18961 Round Lake Road
Noblesville, IN
-
Noblesville IN Home for Sale
This 4 bdrm/4 bath historic home was reduced to studs, redesigned, and rebuilt in 2020. Best of both worlds: Historic charm with comfort, energy efficiency, and reliability of a new custom home. Enter from wrap-around front porch to stunning views of a wide-open 1st floor showcasing 10' ceilings, original woodwork, loads of windows, and exquisite finishes. Custom kitchen opens to side patio (ideal for summer grilling). Large master suite features a covered porch, walk-in shower & restored original clawfoot tub. Upstairs you'll find a Loft, 3 Bedrooms 2 more full baths. Walk-in attic (1,360sf) is perfect for extra storage OR turn it into a mancave! Attached Garage (24'deep). A must see: Flat ceilings, dual HVAC units, LED lighting, basement!
$479,990 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 4179 sqft
1506 Logan Street
Noblesville, IN
-
Arcadia IN Home for Sale
Great investment property. This is a 1.13 acre parcel with an amazing scenic landscape. Home is being sold as-is with tenants occupying the property.
$110,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1663 sqft
27145 Startsman Road
Arcadia, IN
-
Pendleton IN Home for Sale
Rural 2 Bedroom 1 Bath Bungalow sitting on almost 1 acre. 2 car detached garage, 24x55 Workshop. This rural setting is perfect if you are looking to be away from the city, but don't want to go to far for amenities. Just a short drive to downtown Pendleton. enjoy this country setting
$159,500 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 1200 sqft
8464 S 150 Road W
Pendleton, IN
-
Indianapolis IN for Rent
This STUNNING 3 Bdrm/2 Bath 1-story home has been fully-rennovated with high-end finishes. ALL NEW electric, plumbing, HVAC, flooring, cabinets, countertops, SS appliances, etc. Master Suite features walk-in closet, LED can lighting, and attached bath. High end finishes throughout including durable vinyl plank flooring, quartz tops, tile bathrooms, and LED lighting. Ideal location with immediate access to Keystone & 465. 1/2 acre yard with mature trees, rear deck and pergola. 2-Car attached Garage with Attic Storage.
$2,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1529 sqft
2711 E 96th Street
Indianapolis, IN
-
Indianapolis IN for Rent
This 2 bedroom / 2 bath 2-story 966sf condo with attached garage is recently remodeled and ready for immediate move-in. Fully updated throughout. Includes Washer & Dryer! 1st Floor features Great Room, Bathroom, Kitchen, Dining and opens to fenced-in 10x18' Deck. Upstairs features 2 Bedrooms (with large closets) and Full Bath. This is a beautiful, trouble-free home in a quiet community that offers pool, playground, and greenspace. RENT INCLUDES water, sewer, trash, and snow removal. Tenant pays only electric.
$995 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 966 sqft
2862 Punto Alto Court
Indianapolis, IN
-
Carmel IN for Rent
2 Bedroom "Double Master" townhome with 2.5 baths and 2-car attached garage. Main floor features Kitchen and combined Dining and Great Room with Gas Fireplace and Deck. Upstairs features two large Master Bedrooms, each with its own Private Bath Suite, large walk-in closets, raised ceilings, and ceiling fans. The larger master bedroom features separate soaking tub, shower, and double-vanity. 1st floor features bonus room (private office), Laundry, and storage. Washer & Dryer included. Available for move-in on 3/1.
$1,850 Closed- 2 bds
- 3 ba
- 2236 sqft
3540 Golden Gate Drive N
Carmel, IN
-
Carmel IN Home for Sale
POSSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS FOR THESE TWO HOMES WITH MATURE TREE LARGE ACREAGE LOTS IN THE HEART OF CARMEL. LOCATED LESS THAN FIVE MINUTES FROM THE "ARTS AND DESIGN DISTRICT", CITY CENTER AND RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE CARMEL HIGHT SCHOOL GREYHOUND SPORTS COMPLEX!! THESE TWO WOODED LOTS ARE BEAUTIFUL AND THE HOMES ARE READY FOR YOUR DESIGN INSPIRATION!! BRING YOUR IMAGINATION AND GET READY TO BE WOWED BY THE AMOUNT OF GREENSPACE RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF CARMEL!!! THE TWO HOMES ARE BEING SOLD TOGETHER, AND THE SMALLER HOME IS A PERFECT FOR VISITING GUESTS OR AS IN-LAW QUARTERS! DON'T WAIT THIS PROPERTY IS A RARE GEM!
$610,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2158 sqft
2519 and 2525 E Smoky Row
Carmel, IN
-
Carmel IN Home for Sale
Great investment opportunity! This 3 Bdrm / 1.5 Bath Ranch is on 2 ACRES in the heart of Carmel on Cool Creek! Home needs cosmetic updates and is ready for your design inspiration. New roof in 2020. Hardwood floors throughout (including under vinyl in Dining Rm). Amazing location with immediate access to Keystone Ave and within walking distance of 'Arts and Design District'. The flat rear yard holds loads of possibilities. Property extends approx 475 feet beyond the tree line to Cool Creek. Wooded portion of property is in Flood Zone. Get ready to be wowed by the amount of greenspace and privacy right in the middle of Carmel! This is a rare gem with loads of possibilities; fix & flip, buy and hold, or build your estate on 2 acres!
$315,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1228 sqft
2525 E Smoky Row
Carmel, IN
-
Carmel IN Home for Sale
Great investor opportunity! This 1 bedroom, 1 bath ranch is located on 1 acre in the heart of Carmel on Cool Creek! Garage space galore with a 3.5 car attached garage with attic storage above. There are loads of possibilities with this home: rennovate the existing layout or add loads of value by building on a 2nd story OR finish the 2-car section of garage into living space. Bring your imagination and get ready to be wowed by the amount of greenspace, privacy, and wildlife right in the middle of Carmel! Property extends approx 432 feet beyond the tree line to Cool Creek. Wooded portion of property is in Floodway, structure is in AE Floodzone and may require flood insurance. Located within walking distance of 'Arts and Design District'.
$185,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 930 sqft
2519 E Smoky Row
Carmel, IN
-
Indianapolis IN Home for Sale
Fall in love with this 2 BR, 1 BA historic Broad Ripple bungalow, the original neighborhood farmhouse! Loads of character and charm with a full front screened-in porch and original hardwood floors & woodwork. Upstairs you'll find 2 Bdrms and the Bathroom. Spend mornings relaxing on the front porch swing and evenings hosting BBQs on the deck in the large fenced-in backyard. This home is one of the best values in the area, and is ready for you to make it your own. Major updates are already complete (new windows August 2022, new sewer line with new sewer main tap in 2018, new sump pit & pump in 2018, New HVAC & water htr in 2017). The Study on 1st floor is a rare find, and ideal location for a future 1st floor bath, if desired. Full basement.
$270,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 1300 sqft
6033 Crittenden Avenue
Indianapolis, IN
-
Indianapolis IN Home for Sale
This 2 Bedroom / 1.5 Bath 2-Story 966sf Condo with ATTACHED GARAGE was fully rennovated with ALL NEW interior finishes (Flooring, Cabinets, Countertops, Appliances, Washer & Dryer, Toilets, HVAC, Lighting, Windows, Paint, etc) in 2020. 1st floor features large Great Room, Half-Bath, Kitchen & Dining Rm that opens to fenced in 10'x18' Deck. Upstairs features 2 Bedrooms, Large Closets, and Full Bath. Shared two-car garage with space for owner on the RH side includes secure garage storage unit. This quiet community offers pool and playground. HOA dues include Water & Sewer, Trash, Lawncare, Exterior Building Maintenance, Snow Removal, and more. The only utility you pay is Electric. True maintenance-free living. New water heater 2023.
$102,500 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 966 sqft
2862 Punto Alto Court
Indianapolis, IN
-
Westfield IN for Rent
This 1,816 END UNIT features 3 Bedrooms and 2 Baths. The 2-story entry welcomes you to this 2nd floor flat-style condo. End unit means side windows for a very bright kitchen, dining area, and great room. Very functional open kitchen to great room layout featuring a fireplace, vaulted ceilings, and deck overlooking community ponds. Large master features walk-in closet, vaulted ceilings, and a sitting room that could be used as an office. Nicely appointed with hard surface flooring, tile bathrooms, new windows, and window coverings. Loads of storage available in attached 2-car garage and storage room. RENT INCLUDES Water & Sewer, Washer & Dryer, Lawncare, and Snow Removal. Wide main staircase for easy move-in. Available for move-in on 6/15.
$1,700 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1816 sqft
16906 Mapleton Place
Westfield, IN
-
Westfield IN Home for Sale
This 1,816 END UNIT features 3 Bedrooms and 2 Baths. The 2-story entry welcomes you to this 2nd floor flat-style condo. End unit means side windows for a very bright kitchen, dining area, and great room. Functional open kitchen to great room layout features gas fireplace, vaulted ceilings, and deck. Large Primary Suite features walk-in closet, vaulted ceilings, and a sitting room that could be used as an office. Loads of storage available in attached 2-car garage and storage room. Ideal setting with stunning sunsets and private views overlooking community ponds. HOA dues include Water & Sewer, Lawncare, and Snow Removal. All appliances (including washer & dryer) included!
$270,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1816 sqft
16906 Mapleton Place
Westfield, IN
-
Indianapolis IN for Rent
This 2 bedroom / 2 bath 2-story 966sf condo with attached garage is recently remodeled and ready for immediate move-in. Fully updated in 2020. Includes Washer & Dryer! 1st Floor features Great Room, Bathroom, Kitchen, Dining and opens to fenced-in 10x18' Deck. Upstairs features 2 Bedrooms (with large closets) and Full Bath. This is a beautiful, trouble-free home in a quiet community that offers pool, playground, and greenspace. RENT INCLUDES water, sewer, trash, and snow removal. Tenant pays only electric.
$1,150 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 966 sqft
2862 Punto Alto Court
Indianapolis, IN
-
Carmel IN for Rent
Charming 2 bedroom / 2.5 bath townhome in Carmel. Carmel Clay Schools. Open main level with kitchen, dining and great room (featuring gas fireplace & deck). Lower level features bonus room/office, laundry (includes washer & dryer), and storage room. Two large bedroom suites upstairs each featuring full baths, walk-in closets, and vaulted ceilings. Primary suite features garden tub, separate shower, and double-sink vanity. 2-car attached garage. South orientation provides lots of light. Lawncare included in rent.
$2,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 3 ba
- 1856 sqft
3540 Golden Gate Drive N
Carmel, IN
-
Arcadia IN Land for Sale
Look no further for your ideal building site. This 1.13 acre property is ready for you to construct your dream home. This homesite is level and sits high in elevation relative to surrounding land, which provides for some exceptional views and great drainage. Private well already on-site. Septic required. Electric available. No HOA. See Hamilton County UDO for building standards. Setbacks per UDO: 50' Side Setback, 110' Front Setback from the center of the Road Right of Way, 80' from Rear property line. Attached aerial image notes allowable buildable area outlined in blue, which is approximately 60' wide by 126' deep.
$119,500 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
27145 Startsman Road
Arcadia, IN
-
Westfield IN for Rent
$1,625 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1816 sqft
16906 Mapleton Place
Westfield, IN
-
Indianapolis IN Home for Sale
True maintenance-free living awaits in this 2 Bedroom / 1.5 Bath 2-Story 966sf Condo. Features an open main floor with Kitchen, Half Bath, and free-flowing Great Room / Dining that opens to a 10' x 18' fenced-in Deck. Features an attached garage with direct access, a rare feature in this community. Upstairs features 2 Bedrooms, Large Closets, and Full Bath. Shared 2-car garage with space for owner on the RH side includes secure garage storage unit. Home has brand new countertops. Full rennovation with all new HVAC and interior finishes (cabinets, countertops, flooring, appliances) completed in 2020. New water heater in 2023. This quiet community offers pool and playground. HOA dues include Water & Sewer, Trash, Lawncare, Snow Removal, Exterior Building Maintenance (which includes the shared garage). The only utility you pay is Electric.
$105,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 966 sqft
2862 Punto Alto Court
Indianapolis, IN
-
Carmel IN Home for Sale
Welcome to 11461 N. College Avenue, a thoughtfully updated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in the heart of Carmel. Just steps from the Monon Center and Monon Trail, this 2,035 sq ft residence blends classic charm with modern upgrades for lasting comfort and value. Inside, refinished hardwood floors add warmth and sophistication throughout. The cabinets in the kitchen have been freshly painted, while all three bathrooms have been beautifully renovated, offering a clean, contemporary feel. Behind the scenes, major improvements ensure peace of mind, including a new roof (2022), water heater (2025), washer (2023), water softener (2021), and crawl space updates (2021). Step outside to a tree-lined backyard and enjoy your own private retreat, complete with a custom-built sauna-perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Situated on a generous 0.37-acre lot, this move-in ready home offers unbeatable access to parks, top-rated schools, shopping, and all the amenities Carmel has to offer. Don't miss your chance to own a turnkey home in one of Hamilton County's most desirable locations.
$389,995 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2035 sqft
11461 N College Avenue
Carmel, IN
-
Noblesville IN Home for Sale
The Californian at Lake Lochaven 4 bd | 4 bth | 2 Kitchens | 2 Gathering Rooms | 2 offices (or optional 5th bedroom) | Home Theater | Exercise/Play Room | 2 outdoor decks | Floating Dock + optional 18' pontoon Welcome to this stunning Newport Beach-inspired lakefront home - where modern design meets relaxed coastal living. Set on the peaceful shores of lake Lochaven, this 4-bedroom (optional 5-bedroom) residence is the perfect blend of sophisticated entertaining and intimate family comfort. At the heart of the home is a breathtaking nearly 11-foot kitchen island, ideal for gathering, hosting, or casual everyday living. The open-concept layout is accentuated by a curated, high-end lighting package and expansive windows that flood the space with natural light and offer serene vistas. Designed with intention and elegance, the home features clean architectural lines, a neutral palette, and organic textures that reflect the essence of mindful living. From the state-of-the-art home theater to the private exercise or play room, every space has been crafted for both luxury and livability. Whether you're enjoying quiet mornings on the lake, movie nights with the family, or entertaining a crowd, this home offers a rare combination of style, serenity, and functionality - all in
$1,100,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 5564 sqft
14682 Braemar Avenue E
Noblesville, IN
-
Noblesville IN Home for Sale
Welcome to this stunning 2,624 sq ft home that truly has it ALL: spacious living, modern finishes, 3-car garage, and a rare .44 acre homesite in the highly desireable Carlton Heights neighborhood, known for its large yards and generous spacing between homes. Built in 2021, this home feels better-than-new with thoughtful upgrades and custom built-in features throughout. The main level boasts 9' ceilings and durable LVP flooring, creating a bright and inviting open layout. You'll love the custom built-ins in Great Room, walk-in Pantry, and Mudroom, designed to blend beauty and functionality. The Kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring quartz countertops, a farmhouse sink, staggered cabinetry, gas range, and an abundance of prep space. A 4' wide staircase leads you to the 2nd floor where a spacious loft, upstairs laundry room, and all bedrooms await. The luxurious primary suite is a retreat with a double-vanity, soaking tub, separate shower, private water closet and plenty of closet storage. Each secondary bedroom also includes its own walk-in closet for ample storage. Step outside to enjoy the nearly half-acre homesite - perfect for family fun and entertaining. The expanded rear patio includes covered pergola, creating an ideal space for relaxing or entertaining. This one checks all the boxes!
$450,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2624 sqft
21521 Gisborne Drive
Noblesville, IN
-
Carmel IN for Rent
Charming 2 bedroom / 2.5 bath townhome in Carmel. Carmel Clay Schools. Open main level with kitchen, dining and great room (featuring gas fireplace & deck). Lower level features bonus room/office, laundry (includes washer & dryer), and storage room. Two large bedroom suites upstairs each featuring full baths, walk-in closets, and vaulted ceilings. Primary suite features garden tub, separate shower, and double-sink vanity. 2-car attached garage. South orientation provides lots of light. Lawncare and snow removal included in rent.
$2,175 Closed- 2 bds
- 3 ba
- 1160 sqft
3540 N Golden Gate Drive
Carmel, IN
