Mark Shuster
This profile has not yet been claimed or personalized. If you are Mark, you can claim and unlock this agent profile to showcase your experience, specialties, and contact details for prospective buyers and sellers. Mark Shuster appears to specialize in selling homes in areas including: East Moriches, NY, Westhampton Beach, NY, Center Moriches, NY, Quogue, NY, Remsenburg, NY, Bellport, NY, Water Island, NY, Westhampton Dunes, NY. List prices for homes in these areas have ranged from $2,000 to $5,900,000.
26
Closed Sales
$37M
Total Value
$2K - $5.9M
Price Range
$1.4M
Average Price
Instantly unlock your home value, equity, and risk-free cash offer for your home.
SOLD/OFF MARKET LISTINGS
-
East Moriches NY Home for Sale
Waterfront delight on 1.3 acres offering panoramic water and scenic views from almost every room. Deep water docking for your boat and water toys too. With 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths and amazing open living, you'll feel that your always on vacation! Situated on Tuthill Cove, you're just a few minutes to Moriches Bay to enjoy ocean beaches, sand bars for relaxing and swimming, fishing and access to the ocean through Moriches Inlet for offshore fishing. This home offers so much to enjoy. Many recent cosmetic updates, and solar panels too, significantly cutting down on overhead.
❮❯Closed$1,150,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 4200 sqft
93 Adelaide Avenue
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: Mark D. Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Westhampton Beach NY Home for Sale
Westhampton Beach 1 bedroom, 1 bath co-op at The Buoy. On one level for easy living, this co-op offers a bright, open floor plan and a double patio. Amenities at The Buoy include a heated pool, tennis court and laundry facility. Centrally located in the heart of the Village near Main Street in a very private, lush setting.
❮❯Closed$450,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 800 sqft
221 Mill Road #4
Westhampton Beach, NY
Listing by: Albert Weinschenk - Brown Harris Stevens W Hampton -
East Moriches NY Home for Sale
Farmhouse delight on shy 1-acre lot. This late 1800s home and 1.5-car-garage offers all of the charm of yesteryear with the convenience of modern updates. Enjoy the expansive and mature perennial gardens while relaxing in your hot tub. Plenty of room for a pool, pool house, barns, etc. First floor offers 2 bedrooms, eat-in-kitchen, dining room, full bath, living room and large covered porch. Second floor offers 4 bedrooms and full bath, plus a huge standup attic. Mechanicals all recent, separate hot water heater, 200 amp service. Location, location, location! Only a minute to Main St. and Moriches Bay. Not to be missed!
❮❯Closed$599,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 2 ba
- 2500 sqft
76 Atlantic Avenue
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: Mark D. Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Center Moriches NY Home for Sale
Build your dream home of any size on this spectacular 5-acre property! Partially wooded and partially field, it's an ideal property for equestrians or those who desire open space and the opportunity to create an estate-like home. So much room for barns, garages, corrals, trails, etc. Included with the property is a fully COed and updated 1bed/1bath home with eat-in-kitchen and living room, 200 amp service and central AC. Also included is a 3-stall horse stable.
❮❯Closed$529,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
233 Railroad Avenue
Center Moriches, NY
Listing by: Mark D Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Center Moriches NY for Rent
Amazing opportunity to live on a creek and dock your boat in the back yard... Orchard Neck Creek! Separate outside entrance to the entire second-story apartment. Beautifully maintained and fantastic water views. Delivered unfurnished. Heat is included with rental and tenant is only responsible for electric and cable. Bonus huge attic for storage!
❮❯Closed$2,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 600 sqft
2 Orchard Neck Road
Center Moriches, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
East Moriches NY Home for Sale
Built in 2014, this 8-year-young home, offering 3 bedrooms and a large bath, is turn-key and ready for it's new owner! The house is beautifully situated on a 1/3 of a partially wooded acre. Schools, Main St., Kahler's Pond & Terrell River County Park are just around the corner. As per property's deed restriction, home must be owner-occupied and purchaser's current (2022) income shall not exceed $67,450/individual, $77,050/2-person family, $86,700/3-person family, $96,300/4-person family, 104,050/5-person family.
❮❯Closed$375,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 1000 sqft
14 Lincoln Boulevard
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Quogue NY for Rent
Views abound! This stunning Quogue waterfront home, situated on an estate-like full acre with 123 feet of waterfront, was meticulously reconstructed in 2017 to maximize views from indoors and out! Boasting expansive first and second floor decks overlooking Quogue Canal, this home captivates. Offering 6 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, living room with wood-burning fireplace, spacious kitchen, and open concept dining room. On the lower level, offer your guests their own separate living area and bedrooms. Need a change of view. Head on up to the rooftop deck and enjoy panoramic bay and ocean views and gentle breezes. Or, perhaps relax by your heated gunite pool with waterfall spa.
❮❯Closed$85,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 7 ba
- 0 sqft
115 Dune Road
Quogue, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
East Moriches NY Home for Sale
On serene Tuthill Point a beautiful, custom-crafted 2-story traditional home situated on a partially wooded 1.5 acres awaits you. Built in 2017, this 4 bedroom and 2.5 bath home has been finished with meticulous details, including coffered ceilings, paneled walls, crown molding and white oak wood floors. Enjoy entertaining your guests in the sun filled, open space design. The kitchen, with marble tile backsplash, granite countertops, stainless steel farm sink and Viking appliances, overlooks the living room with a marble tiled gas fireplace and custom mantle. Beautifully designed Visual Comfort chandeliers throughout the house accentuate the chic finishes. The master bedroom epitomizes care for design and level of construction, with cathedral ceilings and master bath with marble tile, porcelain herringbone floors and a cast iron clawfoot tub. Wind down evenings watching the sunset from your 2nd-story deck overlooking professionally landscaped grounds, backyard firepit and dining area.
❮❯Closed$925,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 0 sqft
22 Tuthill Point Road
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
East Moriches NY Land Lot for Sale
A few and far between opportunity to build on secluded and serene Tuthill Point. Offering a 205'x163' wooded lot (.84 acre) including remnant barns from the original Tuthill Farm, circa 1860. Build your dream home or summer retreat. Access to Tuthill Cove and Moriches Bay via access point across just across the street.
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 0 bds
- 0 ba
- 0 sqft
16 Tuthill Point Road
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Quogue NY Home for Sale
A serene bay-front retreat on a full acre with over 120 feet of exclusive waterfront in the elegant enclave of Quogue awaits. Featuring a distinct level of exclusivity, the private compound was meticulously reconstructed in 2017 to maximize both indoor and outdoor living, as well as optimize the magnificent natural light and waterfront views. Offering 6 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, a spacious living room with wood-burning fireplace, chef-style kitchen with large entertainment island, and open concept dining room. A lower level offers a private living area and bedrooms making this the ultimate home for hosting your out-of-town guests. A separate over-sized pool house/garage abuts the in-ground pool and its waterfall spa, both of which are perfect for relaxing on those extra lazy days of summer, and an inviting rooftop deck beckons at day's end to unwind with panoramic views of both the ocean and the bay. Located just over the historic Post Ln Bridge, the property is a short distance from the shops and restaurants of the village, and a stone's throw from the Quogue Village Beach that is accessible only to Quogue residents and their guests. The property comes fully furnished and boasts a stellar rental history making it a potential turnkey investment vehicle. Room to expand.
❮❯Closed$4,250,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 4 ba
- 3200 sqft
115 Dune Road
Quogue, NY
Listing by: Mark Shuster - Compass -
Remsenburg NY Land Lot for Sale
One-acre lot for sale, $1,050,000. Permits in place for new construction in the heart of Remsenburg. Curb appeal abounds! Situated on a full acre, a 4,400sf two-story traditional home with 5 ensuite bedrooms will be meticulously built for $2,800,000. This beautifully designed home offers a spacious and open concept with impeccable finishes. Main living area includes a two-story foyer, professional kitchen with expansive island, living room with vaulted ceilings, wood burning fireplace and family room, all of which open to a covered stone terrace and your backyard with a heated 20x40 swimming pool. There is also a first floor office or guest suite with its own bath, private covered porch and entrance. Envision too the finishes you can make to the 2,300 sf of basement with 9-foot ceilings and outside entrance and the 300 sf of bonus space above the garage.
❮❯Closed$1,050,000 Closed- 0 bds
- 0 ba
- 0 sqft
154 South Country Road
Remsenburg, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Quogue NY Home for Sale
A serene retreat on a full acre with over 120ft of private waterfront in elegant Quogue awaits. Featuring distinct exclusivity, the estate was meticulously reimagined in 2017 to maximize indoor/outdoor living, as well as the magnificent natural light & waterfront views. 6 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, a spacious living room with wood-burning fireplace, chef-style kitchen with large island, & open concept dining room. A lower level offers a private living area/bedrooms making this the ultimate home for hosting out-of-town guests. An oversized pool house/garage abuts an in-ground pool & waterfall spa, perfect for relaxing on those extra lazy days, & an inviting rooftop deck beckons with panoramic views of both the ocean and the bay. Located a short walk from the shops/restaurants of the village, & a stone's throw from Quogue Village Beach, accessible only to residents. With room to expand, the home comes fully furnished & boasts a stellar rental history, making it a potential turnkey investment.
❮❯Closed$4,250,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 4 ba
- 3200 sqft
115 Dune Road
Quogue, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Center Moriches NY Land Lot for Sale
Build your dream home of any size on this spectacular 5-acre property! Partially wooded and partially field, it's an ideal property for equestrians or those who desire open space and the opportunity to create an estate-like home. So much room for barns, garages, corrals, trails, etc. Included with the property is a fully COed and updated 1bed/1bath home with eat-in-kitchen and living room, 200 amp service and central AC. Also included is a 3-stall horse stable.
❮❯Closed$529,000 Closed- 0 bds
- 0 ba
- 0 sqft
Railroad Avenue
Center Moriches, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Remsenburg NY Home for Sale
New construction in the heart of Remsenburg. Lot also for sale for $1,050,000. Curb appeal abounds! Esteemed local builder, Coastal Management Construction, is designing and executing another head-turner. Situated on a full acre, a 4,400sf two-story traditional home with 5 ensuite bedrooms will be meticulously built. This beautifully designed home offers a spacious and open concept with impeccable finishes. Main living area includes a two-story foyer, professional kitchen with expansive island, living room with vaulted ceilings, wood burning fireplace and family room, all of which open to a covered stone terrace and your backyard with a heated 20x40 swimming pool. There is also a first floor office or guest suite with its own bath, private covered porch and entrance. Envision too the finishes you can make to the 2,300 sf of basement with 9-foot ceilings and outside entrance and the 300 sf of bonus space above the garage.
❮❯Closed$2,800,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 4400 sqft
154 South Country Road
Remsenburg, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Quogue NY for Rent
Available for 2-week July rental at 40k and 75k for all of July. Fully furnished bay-front estate for rent on a full acre of land with over 120ft of private waterfront frontage in elegant Quogue awaits. Available monthly or for the season. Bursting with natural light and a distinct level of privacy, the amenities abound in this exclusive retreat which includes 6 bedrooms; 3.5 baths; spacious and airy living room with wood-burning fireplace; chef-style kitchen with large island & open concept dining room. Visiting guests can be accommodated in a lower level offering private living area and bedrooms, and pets are warmly allowed. A separate pool house abuts a heated in-ground pool & waterfall spa -- perfect for relaxing on those extra lazy days of summer; and an inviting rooftop deck beckons you to unwind to panoramic vistas of both the ocean and the bay, and extraordinary views of both sunrises and sunsets. Located a distance from the shops/restaurants of the village.
❮❯Closed$40,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 7 ba
- 3200 sqft
115 Dune Road
Quogue, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Remsenburg NY Home for Sale
Curb appeal abounds! Esteemed local builder, Coastal Management Construction, is designing and executing another head-turner. Situated on a full acre, a 4,400sf two-story traditional home with 5 ensuite bedrooms will be meticulously built. This beautifully designed home offers a spacious and open concept with impeccable finishes. Main living area includes a two-story foyer, professional kitchen with expansive island, living room with vaulted ceilings, wood burning fireplace and family room, all of which open to a covered stone terrace and your backyard with a heated 20x40 swimming pool. There is also a first floor office or guest suite with its own bath, private covered porch and entrance. Envision too the finishes you can make to the 2,300 sf of basement with 9-foot ceilings and outside entrance and the 300 sf of bonus space above the garage.
❮❯Closed$2,800,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 4400 sqft
154 South Country Road
Remsenburg, NY
Listing by: Mark Shuster - Compass -
Bellport NY Home for Sale
The quintessential private estate and horse property can be found nestled on scenic South Country Rd. between Bellport Village and historic Brookhaven Hamlet. Once part of the colonial-era Hoyt Estate, it's been transformed over the course of its life and is now one of the most unique properties along this quiet, bucolic stretch of Long Island's south shore. The complex of historic buildings is situated on 3 building lots and encompasses over 11 acres of woods and pastures. The primary residence is a 4,000 square foot home converted from a 1800s barn and horse stable. The residence is a labor of love, with attention to detail and an authenticity worthy of the age of the building itself. Among other buildings is a 2-story barn that once stood on the Bourne Estate on the former property of the La Salle Military Academy. This structure has been partially converted, and would make a fabulous, historic guest house. Your dream estate, one of Long Island's best kept secrets, awaits you!
❮❯Closed$5,900,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 4000 sqft
241-247 South Country Rd.
Bellport, NY
Listing by: Mark Shuster - Compass -
Water Island NY Home for Sale
Beloved by the chosen few for its serenity & utmost privacy, Spatengaville is unlike any other beach community. An enclave so exclusive, few are aware of its existence within the Fire Island National Seashore; yet it's only a 15-min. walk from the Water Island Ferry. Beautifully maintained, 4 Spatenga Walk preserved its soul as a true beach house. Replete with spectacular sunsets & expansive views of the Great South Bay from its open concept design, enhanced by wrap-around sliding glass doors that envelop the living & dining room in natural light. The main level has 3 bedrooms & 2 baths & the lower level features a separate entrance to a private bed & bath, perfect as a primary suite or a respite for visiting guests. A large, beautiful deck encompasses the home & offers distinct nooks that are home to an outdoor tub & shower. Live where stars & royalty have played & enjoy access to private ocean & bay beaches & private dock. A rare opportunity awaits to own this breathtaking retreat!
❮❯Closed$1,650,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 1600 sqft
4 Spatenga Walk
Water Island, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Bellport NY Home for Sale
The quintessential private estate and horse property can be found nestled on scenic South Country Rd. between Bellport Village and historic Brookhaven Hamlet. Once part of the colonial-era Hoyt Estate, it's been transformed over the course of its life and is now one of the most unique properties along this quiet, bucolic stretch of Long Island's south shore. The complex of historic buildings is situated on 3 building lots and encompasses over 11 acres of woods and pastures. The primary residence is a 4,000 square foot home converted from a 1800s barn and horse stable. The residence is a labor of love, with attention to detail and an authenticity worthy of the age of the building itself. Among other buildings is a 2-story barn that once stood on the Bourne Estate on the former property of the La Salle Military Academy. This structure has been partially converted, and would make a fabulous, historic guest house. Your dream estate, one of Long Island's best kept secrets, awaits you!
❮❯Closed$5,900,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 4000 sqft
241-247 South Country Road
Bellport, NY
Listing by: Shuster, Mark D - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Center Moriches NY for Rent
Offering for rent (Aug-LD) this amazing and newly built waterfront contemporary situated on 4 serene and wooded acres on Moriches Bay/Forge River! This is a summer getaway not to miss. With an amazing floorplan that draws in nature and views from every room, this home's design pays flawless attention to detail and decor and has beautiful contemporary art throughout. It's indoor/outdoor living as it should be, with a grand living area, dining room and kitchen flowing to decks, screened in porch, shaded BBQ and living area which leads to the heated pool and ipe deck. It's a must that you work into your daily routine a stroll down to the water for a cocktail and take in the amazing sunsets. Paddle boards, kayaks and bikes are at your ready and for a small additional charge a 16-ft motor boat and/or 18-ft sailboat are available too. Close to great restaurants, boating, beaches and just an hour from the city.
❮❯Closed$30,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 4 ba
- 2500 sqft
34 Old Neck Road
Center Moriches, NY
Listing by: Mark D Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Westhampton Beach NY Home for Sale
Indulge in effortless coastal living at The Buoy in Westhampton Beach! This turn-key 1-bedroom, 1-bath co-op beckons with year-round comfort and the added perk of renting after just two years of ownership. Take full advantage of the on-site amenities, including a refreshing pool and tennis facilities. Embrace the convenience of being just a mile away from the beach and in close proximity to the vibrant offerings of the village. Your chic Westhampton retreat awaits - a perfect fusion of comfort and style in a coveted community.
❮❯Closed$495,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 800 sqft
221 Mill Road #4
Westhampton Beach, NY
Listing by: Mark D Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Westhampton Beach NY Home for Sale
Indulge in effortless coastal living at The Buoy in Westhampton Beach! This turn-key 1-bedroom, 1-bath co-op beckons with year-round comfort and the added perk of renting after just two years of ownership. Take full advantage of the on-site amenities, including a refreshing pool and tennis facilities. Embrace the convenience of being just a mile away from the beach and in close proximity to the vibrant offerings of the village. Your chic Westhampton retreat awaits - a perfect fusion of comfort and style in a coveted community.
❮❯Closed$495,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 800 sqft
221 Mill Road Unit 4
Westhampton Beach, NY
Listing by: Mark Shuster - Compass -
Center Moriches NY for Rent
Indulge in an unforgettable summer escape by renting this extraordinary and newly built waterfront contemporary residence, available from August through Labor Day. Situated on four acres of serene and wooded surroundings along Moriches Bay and Forge River, this property promises a tranquil retreat you won't want to miss. Step into a masterpiece of design where the floor plan seamlessly connects with nature, providing breathtaking views from every room. The home's meticulous attention to detail and flawless decor, adorned with beautiful contemporary art, sets it apart. Immerse yourself in the true essence of indoor/outdoor living with a spacious grand living area, dining room, and kitchen that effortlessly flow to decks, a screened-in porch, a shaded BBQ and living area, culminating in a heated pool, ipe deck and poolside kitchenette and changing room. Enhance your daily routine with a leisurely stroll down to the water, where you can savor a cocktail and witness the mesmerizing sunsets. The property comes equipped with paddle boards, kayaks, and bikes for your enjoyment. For those seeking extra adventure, an 18-ft sailboat are available for an additional charge. Perfectly located in close proximity to excellent restaurants, boating opportunities, and pristine beaches, this rental is just 90 minutes away from the city. Eight (8) parking spaces for you and your guests. Seize the opportunity to make this extraordinary summer getaway yours and create lasting memories in this idyllic coastal haven. Your summer retreat of a lifetime awaits!
❮❯Closed$35,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 4 ba
- 2500 sqft
34 Old Road
Center Moriches, NY
Listing by: Mark D Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC -
East Moriches NY Home for Sale
On serene Tuthill Point a beautiful, custom-crafted 2-story traditional home situated on a partially wooded 1.5 acres awaits you. Built in 2017, this 4 bedroom and 2.5 bath home has been finished with meticulous details, including coffered ceilings, paneled walls, crown molding and white oak wood floors. Enjoy entertaining your guests in the sun filled, open space design. The kitchen, with marble tile backsplash, granite countertops, stainless steel farm sink and Viking appliances, overlooks the living room with a marble tiled gas fireplace and custom mantle. Beautifully designed Visual Comfort chandeliers throughout the house accentuate the chic finishes. The master bedroom epitomizes care for design and level of construction, with cathedral ceilings and master bath with marble tile, porcelain herringbone floors and a cast iron clawfoot tub. Wind down your evenings watching the sunset from your 2nd-story deck that overlooks professionally landscaped grounds, backyard firepit and dining area.
❮❯Closed$925,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- sqft
22 Tuthill Point Road
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: -
Westhampton Dunes NY Residential Income for Sale
2 Cottages On 1/3 Of An Acre -- Mirror Image Cottages, Each 900 Sq Ft With 3 Bedrooms, Full Bath, Kitchen, Living Room & Individual South-Facing Decks. Over The 2-Car Garage Is Expansive 2nd-Story Decking & Wonderful Bay And Ocean Views. Tremendous New Construction Or Expansion Potential On This Expansive 140 X 100 Ft Lot.
❮❯Closed$899,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 2 ba
- 1800 sqft
888 Dune Road
Westhampton Dunes, NY
Listing by: Mark D. Shuster - Hampton Estates Realty LLC -
East Moriches NY Home for Sale
Farmhouse delight on shy 1-acre lot. This late 1800s home and 1.5-car-garage offers all of the charm of yesteryear with the convenience of modern updates. Enjoy the expansive and mature perennial gardens while relaxing in your hot tub. Plenty of room for a pool, pool house, barns, etc. First floor offers 2 bedrooms, eat-in-kitchen, dining room, full bath, living room and large covered porch. Second floor offers 4 bedrooms and full bath, plus a huge standup attic. Mechanicals all recent, separate hot water heater, 200 amp service. Location, location, location! Only a minute to Main St. and Moriches Bay. Not to be missed!, Additional information: Interior Features:Lr/Dr
❮❯Closed$599,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 2 ba
- 2500 sqft
76 Atlantic Avenue
East Moriches, NY
Listing by: Mark D. Shuster - Compass Greater NY LLC