Matthew Carter
Matthew Carter, a Long Island resident for over three decades, offers unparalleled expertise to both buyers and sellers in the residential real estate market as a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker. He serves not only his hometown of Massapequa and surrounding areas, such as Massapequa Park, Wantagh, Seaford, Bethpage, and Farmingdale, but also all of Nassau and Suffolk Counties. The hallmark of Matthew's success lies not only in delivering the highest quality of service but also in executing a tailored, results-driven strategy based on individual circumstances of the client(s). This ensures that clients easily achieve their buying or selling objectives, and seamlessly transition into the next chapter of their lives.With a Master’s Degree in Industrial and Organizational Psychology from Hofstra University, Matthew leverages his expertise in human behavior, allowing him to integrate both business and psychological principles at the client level into real estate solutions. His grasp of human psychology, coupled with his training in research, statistical analysis, motivation, and negotiation, enhances his ability to provide effective real estate services. Matthew adopts an all-encompassing approach, combining his education with the Laffey Experience in order to deliver top-notch services to every client.Matthew is honored to say that he is recognized as one of the top 500 Real Estate Agents on Long Island, out of about 30,000 members, by Real Producers Magazine. His unwavering dedication to the success of each of his clients doesn’t go unnoticed.As a forward-thinking Realtor, Matthew embraces technology, staying at the forefront of the latest advancements in marketing, advertising, market statistics and data trends to give his clients a competitive edge in achieving their real estate goals. Matthew stands out as a Realtor armed with state-of-the-art tools and an innate understanding of the local real estate landscape. His tech-savvy approach, coupled with an unwavering dedication and strong work ethic, positions Matthew as a true professional.
26
Closed Sales
$12.5M
Total Value
$1.5K - $1.2M
Price Range
$482K
Average Price
Instantly unlock your home value, equity, and risk-free cash offer for your home.
SOLD/OFF MARKET LISTINGS
-
Port Jefferson NY Home for Sale
Young and stylish in Historic Port Jefferson Village! Spacious custom Colonial w/ 3 bdrms, 2.5 bths; w/ gorgeous yard situated on a tranquil cul-de-sac on the North Shore of Long Island. Close to a charming downtown with stores, live music, theater, and restaurants, 3 local hospitals, schools & minutes to public transportation and beaches. Beautiful wd flrs & natural light flow throughout the home's open, airy layout featuring elegant crown molding and trim. Large front porch welcomes you inside to the foyer opening to a large living rm centered by a fireplace and a formal dining rm w/ stunning wainscot wall paneling. The eat-in kitchen is equipped with granite counters, rich wood cabinetry, s/s appliances, and sliding glass drs to the two patios & private backyard w/ storage shed. A comfortable family rm, half bathrm, & access to the attached one-car garage complete the main level. The second flr encompasses a primary bedrm w/ vaulted ceiling, a fabulous round- topped window, two closets, and a lavish en suite bathrm w/ a tub and separate shower. Two additional bedrms share a full hall bathrm. The finished basement offers plentiful space for movie nights, an office & more, along w/ ample storage and laundry area. A paths leads thru the beautifully landscaped backyard offering private & serene seating areas that are perfect for entertaining, outdoor dining, or just relaxing. Fully UPDATED; Fencing; Closet Organizing systems; Custom Built in Bookcases; 2nd garage Refrigerator; Bsmnt Egress window; Cedar closet; 200 amp electric; Garage Dr Opener; PLUS 12 mo Choice HOME Warranty INCLUDED! ALSO included is adjoining addt'l lot: D: 206, Blk 6, Sec 9 Lot 2; (see it circled on attached survey). Tax Greivance has been PROFESSIONALLY filed w/ approx 20+% tax reduction expected-NEW tax estimate is shown on listing! (Town & Village current Tax BEFORE GRIEVANCE: $18,604.45) See it TODAY & call it HOME tomorrow!
❮❯Closed$729,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2000 sqft
3 James Way Way
Port Jefferson, NY
Listing by: Joan Beckham - Manzoni Real Estate -
Massapequa NY Home for Sale
Welcome to This Charming and Updated Home! Just Move In and Unpack Because This Has It ALL! Newer EIK w/ Granite Countertops/Stainless Appliances/Hi-Hats, New Bath, Sunken Living Room w/Beautiful White Washed Brick and Electric Fireplace (Can Be Converted to Gas)! Central AC, New 2019 Architectural Roof, New Gas Boiler and Hot Water Heater, 200 Amp Electric Service, Solar Panels with Battery Back-up, (Low Cost) & Deck in Private Yard!
❮❯Closed$629,990 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 0 sqft
204 N Walnut Street N
Massapequa, NY
Listing by: Patricia Yovino - Keller Williams Realty Elite -
Wantagh NY Home for Sale
Welcome to this beautiful expanded Colonial. This meticulously maintained home has 6 oversized bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms. Two of the bedrooms have ensuite bathrooms, one on the main level and one on the second level, giving you two different options to choose from to use as a primary suite and proving an extra place for guests to stay. Some of the features include gorgeous hardwood floors throughout, granite counter tops in the kitchen, updated Anderson and Marvin windows, glass sliding doors to the backyard, central A/C, a new pool liner, in-ground sprinklers and much much more! This home has ample amounts of storage space in its large closets, full attic, and detached garage. The full-size basement and gorgeous backyard full of pavers and a magnificent in-ground saltwater pool provide extra room to relax or entertain guests. Enjoy your summer-time fun here on Summer Drive!
❮❯Closed$899,000 Closed- 6 bds
- 4 ba
- 2576 sqft
3559 Summer Drive
Wantagh, NY
Listing by: Matthew Carter - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
East Meadow NY Home for Sale
Well maintained spacious 2nd floor 2bed/2 bath unit with a PRIVATE ELEVATOR, in 55+ Gated Luxury Community with 24 Hour security. Open layout, cathedral ceilings, large kitchen with peninsula, granite countertops, stainless steal appliances. Spacious loft, can be used for a den or office! Large closet, pantry, laundry room. Second bedroom has a sliders out to new Trex deck. Amenities in newly renovated 17,000 SQ Ft clubhouse include: indoor pool and jacuzzi, outdoor pool, exercise room, theater, card room, library, pool table. Community run activities, holiday parties, and other social events.
❮❯Closed$579,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1433 sqft
183 Spring Drive #183
East Meadow, NY
Listing by: Maryna Bolila - Coldwell Banker American Homes -
Bethpage NY Home for Sale
Welcome to this magnificent and beautifully maintained, oversized expanded ranch! This house features four bedrooms, one updated bathroom, an updated open concept eat-in kitchen, family room with exterior entrance, a tremendous amount of storage space in the laundry room and plentiful closets. The exterior features a fenced in front and back yard with meticulously maintained landscaping.
❮❯Closed$599,990 Closed- 4 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
8 E Millpage Drive
Bethpage, NY
Listing by: Matthew Carter - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Amityville NY for Rent
Granite Kitchen Countertops & Granite Kitchen Floor!Stainless Steel Appliances,Tuscany Cabinets. Ceiling Fans,2-Tone Paint Crn/Base Molding,Carpet.Bath W/Granite Vanity Top,Frameless Shower.Window AC Units,Terr. Laundry Center. *Prices/Policies Subject to change without notice.
❮❯Closed$1,995 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
100 Park Avenue #13
Amityville, NY
Listing by: Michelle Holmes - Fairfield Properties -
Bethpage NY Home for Sale
Welcome To This Stunning 5 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Updated And Beautifully Maintained Colonial Located On An Oversized Corner Lot Within Plainedge School District! This Spacious Colonial Has Endless Possibilities! The First Floor Features An Eat-In Kitchen With Updated Countertops And Newer Stainless Steel Appliances, Updated Bathroom, Living Room, Formal Dining Room, Laundry Room, A Large Den That Can Also Serve As A Bedroom, And A Home Office That Can Serve As A Bedroom As Well. Upstairs You'll Find An Oversized Master Bedroom With A Huge Closet, Two Additional Bedrooms, And Full Bathroom. This Home Is Perfect For Entertaining With It's Spacious Back Yard Filled With Pavers, Beautiful Pool, & More! Gas On The Street For Easy Conversion. Don't Miss Out On This One!
❮❯Closed$689,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 2 ba
- 0 sqft
21 Hoover Lane
Bethpage, NY
Listing by: Matthew Carter - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Hicksville NY Home for Sale
Welcome to your brand-new magnificent modern colonial home! This new construction home features 4 spacious bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, full-finished basement, and a 1-car detached garage. Inside you'll find 9-foot ceilings, high-hats throughout, 4-inch white oak hardwood floors, white marble tile, quartz countertops in the eat-in-kitchen & center island, custom white shaker cabinets, high-end stainless steel appliances, and a 2 zone central A/C and heating system. The spacious yard features an in-ground sprinkler system and 2 entrances into the home through sliding glass doors. Great mid-block location close to all the amenities Hicksville has to offer.
❮❯Closed$999,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 0 sqft
15 Robert Street
Hicksville, NY
Listing by: Christina A. Carter CBR - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Oyster Bay NY Home for Sale
Beautiful sun filled one bedroom first-floor unit in the Essex building. This unit features an open floor plan with gorgeous hardwood floors throughout, plenty of storage space, and a beautiful scenic view. Great location near the heart of town, LIRR, Teddy Roosevelt Park, the beach and more!
❮❯Closed$305,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
200 Lexington Avenue #9C
Oyster Bay, NY
Listing by: Matthew Carter - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Massapequa NY Home for Sale
8 Room Expanded Cape full rear dormer plus two large double front doggie dormers 2nd FL vaulted ceilings, 1,344 sq ft interior and 1.5 car attached garage 240 sq ft with unique interior access to the finished basement, FDR expanded by 3', sliders to deck/patio from FDR & Den, MBR on both levels flexible layout (current set-up as 3BR but can be 4BR) hardwood floors both levels except family room, partially freshly painted interior, basement & garage, 2 bay windows, 3 skylights, 18x36 In-ground Pool, 3 new stainless steel kitchen appliances including Gas Stove, and New (11/22) Burnham Gas HW Heater, Separate Gas Water Heater, Washer/Gas dryer, 200 AMP electric, New (11/22) Single-layer Roof, AC window Unit in basement, 70x100 lot located 2 houses away from Massapequa Preserve and 1 block to the entrance. Excellent cul-de-sac location! School District: Massapequa, Elementary School: Lockhart Elementary School, Jr High School: Berner Middle School, and High School: Massapequa High School.
❮❯Closed$600,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1344 sqft
111 N Manhattan Avenue
Massapequa, NY
Listing by: Kevin M. Leatherman ABR - Leatherman Homes -
Massapequa NY Home for Sale
Don't Miss the Chance to Own this Beautifully Maintained, Light and Bright Expanded Cape w/Private Yard. This Home Features an Added Foyer and 2 Coat Closets, Extended EIK w/Custom Cabinets and Gas Cooking, Open LR that Flows into the Formal DR, 5 Bedrooms and 2 FB. This Home also Boasts Large Closets (1 Cedar), Crawl Space and Oversized Built-ins (Tons of Storage), a 1.5 Car Garage w/New Door and Open Attic Storage, Large Basement w/High Ceilings, Steel Header and Utilities as Well as a Fenced in Private Yard w/Mature Shrubs/Trees. Updates include Siding, Windows, Roof and Heating System. Hardwood Floors Throughout! Close to parks!!!
❮❯Closed$579,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 2 ba
- 1380 sqft
358 N Wyoming Avenue
Massapequa, NY
Listing by: Jill C. Quelle - Coldwell Banker American Homes -
Oceanside NY Home for Sale
First Floor 2 Bedroom Garden Apartment in the Desirable Waterfront Cooperative, The Ocean Harbor Club. Featuring An Open Living/Dining Space, Renovated Kitchen W/ SS Appliances, Gorgeous Hardwood Floors Throughout, Tons of Natural Light & Water Views, Spacious Bedrooms W/ Ample Closet Space, Renovated Bath, & Assigned Parking. Amenities Include An In-Ground Pool, Full Gym, Dog Run (Pet-Friendly Co-op), Boat Slips Available As Shown In Photos & Bike Room For Additional Fees, Additional Storage Available, & Plenty of Guest Parking. Centrally Located To LIRR (Right Down the Block), Restaurants, Shops, and Many More!
❮❯Closed$338,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
4 Rose Street #1C1
Oceanside, NY
Listing by: Michael Nolan - Douglas Elliman Real Estate -
Bay Shore NY Home for Sale
GOOD BONES, GREAT POTENTIAL! Hurry and catch this star. Perfect for those just starting out or slowing down. Opportunity knocks with a little imagination you could create a beautiful home in a prime location. Well placed, it is a short distance to shopping, dining, beaches, and transportation. This ranch is future proof with an easy flowing floor plan, the possibilities are endless. A comfortable living room welcomes you into the house connecting to the cute eat in kitchen with dining space. A large master bedroom, 1 guest bedroom and full bath all can be found on the main level. The unfinished basement has plenty of storage. A 2-car detached garage is perfect for the car enthusiast or DIY. Good bones for big plans. A remarkable opportunity awaits, act quickly.
❮❯Closed$399,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 899 sqft
1378 Pine Drive
Bay Shore, NY
Listing by: Tracy L. Boucher CBR - Signature Premier Properties -
Levittown NY for Rent
FABULOUS 1 BEDROOM APARTMENT ON THE FIRST FLOOR FEATURING A LARGE LIVINGROOM/DININGROOM COMBO, EAT IN KITCHEN , FULL BATH, LARGE BEDROOM WITH DOUBLE CLOSET, HARDWOOD FLOORS, LAUNDRY IN COMMON AREA ON PREMISES, PLENTY OF PARKING (2 LOTS) TENANT PAYS ELECTRIC AND CABLE
❮❯Closed$2,000 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
269 N Newbridge Road
Levittown, NY
Listing by: Inglima, Karen J - Keller Williams Realty Greater -
Islip NY Home for Sale
Welcome To Forest Green! This Beautifully Maintained One Bedroom, One Bathroom 'Deluxe' Unit Is Located On The Ground Floor, Facing The Courtyard And Is The Largest One Bedroom One Bathroom Model Here. The Kitchen Has Beautiful Granite Countertops, Hardwood Floors Throughout The Unit, An Expansive Living Room, Dining Room, Many Closets For Storage, And Comes With Two Parking Spots! This Unit Is Centrally Located To The Mailboxes, Laundry Care Center, Saltwater Heated Inground Pool, And Clubhouse With A Full Gym And Kitchen. The Co-Op Is Also Pet-Friendly And Even Features A Dog Run! Co-Op Is Close To LIRR, Major Highways, Shopping, & Schools. Board & Management Company Require Minimum Of 10% Down And 700+ Credit Score.
❮❯Closed$219,900 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
2423 Union Boulevard #6A
Islip, NY
Listing by: Carter, Matthew - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Nesconset NY Home for Sale
Lovely 4 Bedroom, 2 1/2 Bath Colonial on Private, Quiet street in the Smithtown School District. Hardwood Floors thru-out. Laundry and Home Office on Main Floor. Living Rm, Formal Dining Rm, Eik, Family Rm w/Fireplace. Cac, Buderus Boiler. Full Basement, 2 Car Garage w/OSE to Yard. Large Flat Yard w/Inground Sprinklers. This home has lots of Potential, Great Opportunity to Make this Home Your Own!
❮❯Closed$549,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 0 sqft
6 Charlemagne Drive
Nesconset, NY
Listing by: Cook, Bridget M - Compass Greater NY LLC -
Oceanside NY Home for Sale
Beautiful private gated community, close to shopping and the beach. The Cove includes 3 pools, basketball court, tennis court, playground, clubhouse and more...This 2 story updated unit features 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths and a den with washer and dryer, located on the pond with a balcony and rear patio.
❮❯Closed$529,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 0 sqft
100 Daly Boulevard #2603
Oceanside, NY
Listing by: Carter, Matthew - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Wantagh NY Home for Sale
Welcome to this expanded beauty in the Seaford School District! So many possibilities exist in this custom-designed and rear dormered home. Ideal for an extended family, this home offers four bedrooms, two full baths and newly finished basement. Other features include a rear extension with a formal dining room and den with sliding glass doors which lead to a rear deck and backyard. This prime location is near the LIRR, highways, restaurants and shops. Only moments from Cedar Creek Park and a short drive to Jones Beach makes this centrally located home the one you have been waiting for!!!
❮❯Closed$579,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 0 sqft
2150 Maple Street
Wantagh, NY
Listing by: Carter, Matthew - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Medford NY Home for Sale
Sale may be subject to term & conditions of an offering plan. Subject to Bankruptcy court approval. Great deal with Living Room, Kitchen, 2 Bedrooms, & bath. Beautiful Blue Ridge Golf Course, Tennis, & Pool. Nice community, with countless amenities including a cafe. Near great shopping and restaurants. There is a cat. Masks must be worn.
❮❯Closed$259,990 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
97 Birchwood #97
Medford, NY
Listing by: Licitra, Michael P - Artist Cove Realty -
Bethpage NY Home for Sale
Welcome To This Stunning 5 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Updated And Beautifully Maintained Entertainers Dream! This Bright And Spacious Colonial Has Endless Possibilities! It Features An Eat-In Kitchen With Custom Cabinets, Updated Countertops, And Stainless Steel Appliances, Updated Bathrooms, Formal Dining Room, Den That Can Also Serve As A 5th Bedroom, Oversized Bedrooms With Abundant Closet Space, First-Floor Laundry Room, Above Ground Oil Tank, In-Ground Sprinkler System, Spectacular Back Yard With Pavers, Pool, Deck And Balcony, Perfect For Entertaining, & More!
❮❯Closed$679,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 2 ba
- 0 sqft
6 E Millpage Drive
Bethpage, NY
Listing by: Carter, Matthew - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
East Meadow NY Home for Sale
Welcome to this new designer showcase ! This beauty was fully renovated and reimagined in 2021! A Modern open floor plan layout offers so many possibilities. Oversized four bedroom, three and a half bathroom Colonial on 60 x 101 property. New designer kitchen with island and sliding glass doors to new rear platform and stairs to the back yard. Brand new stainless steel appliances ( Stove with pot filler, Microwave, refrigerator and dishwasher) Grand formal living room, Formal dining Room and Den. Three and a half brand new designer bathrooms. Master bedroom with vaulted ceiling and new designer bathroom. Full finished basement with a new full bathroom and laundry room/sink, Brand new washer and dryer and sink in the new second floor laundry room. All new 4 inch wide oak flooring on two floors. Pull down attic where you can stand. Detached garage. Prime mid block location, Two zone heat and two zone Central Air Conditioning. Call now for a private tour !
❮❯Closed$839,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 0 sqft
345 Starke Avenue
East Meadow, NY
Listing by: Laffey, Philip - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
Oyster Bay NY Home for Sale
Recently renovated ground floor corner 2 bedroom unit. Crown moldings , hardwood floors , new LED High Hats, freshly painted, MOVE RIGHT IN!!
❮❯Closed$369,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
200 Lexington #11B
Oyster Bay, NY
Listing by: Morrison, Mari J - Coach Real Estate Assoc Inc -
East Northport NY for Rent
Very Small one bedroom apartment. No Smoking, No Pets. Includes All Utilities!
❮❯Closed$1,500 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
31 Cherrywood Drive
East Northport, NY
Listing by: Cook, Bridget M - Signature Premier Properties -
Oyster Bay NY for Rent
❮❯Closed$2,200 Closed- 2 bds
- 1 ba
- 0 sqft
47 Pine Hollow #1F
Oyster Bay, NY
Listing by: Scala, Donna M - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE -
North Bellmore NY for Rent
Artistically crafted in the heart of N. Bellmore! Expanded 3 bedroom ranch with 2 full bathrooms; huge sundeck perfect for spring entertaining -- accessible by spiral staircase, it adds 500 square feet of usable outdoor space; main bedroom with en suite full bath, refinished eat-in-kitchen with stainless steel appliances; vaulted ceilings with loft/finished attic; gleaming hardwood floors; 3 skylights and lawn.
❮❯Closed$3,287 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 0 sqft
2518 Haff Avenue
North Bellmore, NY
Listing by: Flynn, Michael S - Keller Williams Realty Greater -
Hicksville NY Home for Sale
Welcome to your brand-new magnificent modern colonial home! This new construction home features 4 spacious bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, full-finished basement, and a 1-car detached garage. Inside you'll find 9-foot ceilings, high-hats throughout, 4-inch white oak hardwood floors, white marble tile, quartz countertops in the eat-in-kitchen & center island, custom white shaker cabinets, high-end stainless steel appliances, and a 2 zone central A/C and heating system. The spacious yard features an in-ground sprinkler system and 2 entrances into the home through sliding glass doors. Great mid-block location close to all the amenities Hicksville has to offer. Note: interior pictures are from a previous home from the same builder featuring similar finishes. This home has not been completed yet.
❮❯Closed$1,150,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 0 sqft
15 Robert Street
Hicksville, NY
Listing by: Carter, Christina A - LAFFEY REAL ESTATE