Amy Stack
This profile has not yet been claimed or personalized. If you are Amy, you can claim and unlock this agent profile to showcase your experience, specialties, and contact details for prospective buyers and sellers. Amy Stack appears to specialize in selling homes in areas including: Fly Creek, NY, Cooperstown, NY, Cherry Valley, NY, Otsego, NY, Middlefield, NY, Roseboom, NY, Garrattsville, NY, Westford, NY, Springfield, NY, Exeter, NY. List prices for homes in these areas have ranged from $350 to $1,500,000.
94
Closed Sales
$34.5M
Total Value
$350 - $1.5M
Price Range
$367.2K
Average Price
Instantly unlock your home value, equity, and risk-free cash offer for your home.
FEATURED MARKETS
SOLD/OFF MARKET LISTINGS
-
Fly Creek NY Home for Sale
Mill Pond Cottage is located in the hamlet of Fly Creek within easy walking distance of the Fly Creek General Store and Post Office. The first floor of this charming home includes a living room, dining room, eat-in kitchen, a small bedroom or office, and a half bath with laundry. Upstairs is a large landing, a walk-in closet, and a primary bedroom with an attached full bath. Recent improvements include a completely rebuilt back porch including new footings, a new concrete front walkway, new carpet on the stairs and second floor, and new baseboard heat, flooring and exhaust fan in the full bath. The stove and washing machine are also new. The yard is fenced in and borders the cider mill duck pond. The property includes a two-car garage with electric. Seller is a NYS Licensed Real Estate Broker.
❮❯Closed$259,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1080 sqft
940 County Highway 26
Fly Creek, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Walk to everything the village of Cooperstown has to offer from this centrally located c.1830 4-bed, 3-bath home. Enjoy the large backyard with hot tub, raised bed gardens, and patio for al fresco meals. Landscaping updates in the front yard opened up the charming front porch making it a focal point and a fun place to relax. A 2-car garage and large sunroom/mudroom help keep things organized. Recent improvements on the interior of the home include a renovated kitchen/dining room with a large island and heat pump heating/cooling system. New engineered hardwood floors were added in this room, as well as the staircase and 2nd floor floor hallway to match the adjoining rooms giving the space an airy, cohesive feel. Guest space on the first floor includes a bedroom, office/sitting room, and full bath is located on one side of the house and can be closed off for privacy. Upstairs are three bedrooms and two additional full baths. The primary bedroom with double closets and attached bath is on the back of the house overlooking the yard. The house has a great layout that offers privacy when needed, and generous living spaces when socializing. This home is truly move-in ready.
❮❯Closed$639,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2521 sqft
104 Pioneer Street
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cherry Valley NY Home for Sale
Circa 1860 stone house. This 2-bedroom 2- bathroom home is a great gem within the Roseboom hamlet area. Cross the threshold into a warm welcome; each room is graced with bright natural light from pocket windows. This home radiates old-world charm, with interior exposed stone walls, wide plank floors, gas fireplaces, and radiant heat on the first floor. The spacious kitchen has been updated with stainless steel appliances and bluestone counters. The second-floor landing offers a large bright space, perfect for an office or quiet sitting area. There is a 3/4 bathroom in the primary bedroom and two closets, with two small closets in the hall for the second large bedroom During the warmer months, take advantage of the large fenced-in yard. Your outdoor furniture will transform the flagstone patio into an open-air lounge. Bonus; Barn with a loft/solar panels. Standing on a quiet, low-traffic street, only minutes to Cherry Valley's unique shops, restaurants, and brewery & 12 miles to the Historical Village of Cooperstown.
❮❯Closed$225,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 2630 sqft
107 County Highway 57
Cherry Valley, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Close to everything! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom example of contemporary architecture was built in 2008 by a locally-based master craftsman. Situated in the vicinity of the Baseball Hall of Fame, this example of his timeless work is less than an outfield throw from Main Street! In addition to the town center and the HOF, unique shops, Cooperstown Schools and Otsego Lake.Across the threshold, nice touches embrace you, with cherry hardwoods in the kitchen and living spaces, an open layout, natural light and stylish fixtures both, neutral dcor,10-feet high ceilings, and gas fireplaces in the living room. In the stylish kitchen natural light beams off of the premium appliances and cherry cabinetry, and a convenient island for food prep - ensures that this center of culinary achievement is as practical as it is elegant.More than simply calm, the primary bedroom includes a custom-built walk-in closet & wardrobe, sitting area, and private bath with an air-jetted soaking tub and heated tile floors. There's also a gas fireplace(of course!). The other two bedrooms, located on the 2nd floor, are designed with plenty of closet space. Also: A large bonus room above the two-car garage.
❮❯Closed$729,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2852 sqft
12 Chestnut Street
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Here is a "must-see" opportunity to bring your style and taste to an unbeatable location in the heart of the Village. Displaying the welcoming symmetry and sight lines of traditional architecture, this high-potential home is perfectly situated within the pedestrian range of restaurants, unique shops, Cooperstown schools, and Otsego Lake/Clarks Sport Center. This home offers a treasure they say money can't buy: more hours in the day because of the easy commute to Bassett Medical Center. The expansive yard contributes to an "open space" feel. Facing the street, a breezy porch greets you home. In the rear, a four-season back porch is a nice spot for relaxing with morning coffee or a twilight nightcap. Across the threshold, you'll find plenty of natural light throughout the home. The spacious kitchen brims with potential. The 3 bedrooms above the ground floor for privacy are ready for your decorative touch. The unfinished basement is perfect for storage or conversion. Detached one-car garage with a loft. The location of this home will increase the value of your personal vision. This one is a blank canvas for your lifestyle and memories!
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1655 sqft
13 Eagle Street
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Fly Creek NY Home for Sale
Looking for an Investment Opportunity? This 3,600+ square foot property, once a popular hotel, is located in the Fly Creek Hamlet Business District. The property was recently used for short-term rentals but would also make a spacious single-family home. Convert it into a multi-family income producer or professional offices with a special use permit. The propertys rooms are all generous in size with nice wood floors and high ceilings. The first floor has a large eat-in kitchen, living/dining room, and toward the back is a 600 sq. ft. room that has a separate entrance, 3/4 bath and a small kitchen. This room could be used as a grand living room or a rental/guest space. The second floor has three spacious bedrooms, 3/4 bath, laundry room, and a 600 sq. ft. bedroom with an ensuite. A small 2-car carriage barn, plenty of parking space, and a nice yard complete the property. Cooperstown Schools. This property is price below tax assessment.
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3632 sqft
6234 St Hwy 28
Fly Creek, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Fly Creek NY Home for Sale
Beautifully restored 1820 Federal Farmhouse in the quaint Hamlet of Fly creek. You will immediately appreciate the historical character of this home as you enter the post and beam seasonal room from the driveway. There are many updates throughout, with retained original woodwork and hardwood floors. A large kitchen welcomes you upon entering the house, with an island for seating, and woodburning stove next to the dining area. The open floorplan then leads to a family room, formal living room with fireplace, a study/office with built-ins and a wet bar, and a full bath. The living room could be converted to a bedroom if one floor living is needed. The second floor has 3 sizeable bedrooms and another full bath with laundry. The large barn has ample space to park vehicles, a workshop area, second floor for loads of storage, and a bonus finished room with electric, water, and a propane stove for heat. Ideal for a workout room or convert to a studio apartment for guests! The 2.82 acres consists of land on both sides of the road, with a field across from the house that leads to Fly Creek. The stone patio and seasonal room with woodstove create exceptional spaces for entertaining.
❮❯Closed$539,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2168 sqft
871 County Highway 26
Fly Creek, NY
Listing by: Michael Burns - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
On a street of lovely homes in the desirable Village of Cooperstown. From the outside, you'd never guess what awaits you within this classic 1950 Cape Cod. This darling home features a large living room with a wood-burning fireplace, perfect for winter comfort; French doors that open onto a four-season sun porch with large windows framing the view of the backyard; central AC; and beautiful hardwood floors throughout. The dining room with corner built-in china cabinets opens into the kitchen and also leads to the sun porch, perfect for candlelight dinners and entertaining. There is a first-floor bedroom with a large closet and an attached full bath; this room is currently used as a family room. Upstairs are two generous bedrooms, with abundant closet space, and a full bathroom. The home also features a pretty breezeway that leads from the kitchen to the garage. Only steps from the Otesaga Resort Hotel, Otsego Lake, and the Leatherstocking Golf Course. One block to Main Street's restaurants, shops, and Farmers' Market.
❮❯Closed$535,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1872 sqft
65 Lake Street
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Beautiful 4 Bedroom Craftsman on a desirable street in the Village of Cooperstown, only half a block to Main Street and Otsego Lake. The house sits on a pleasant 1/3 acre lot with mature trees, a fenced back yard, and multiple outdoor spots for relaxing including a back porch, a large deck and a wonderful screened porch.The interior has been updated in recent years but still retains much of its original woodwork, lead glass windows, and nice hardwood floors. The large, welcoming kitchen/dining room spans the whole south side of the house and is bathed in light all day. Off the kitchen is a handy pantry, powder room, and a newly insulated and heated back mudroom. A new pellet stove makes this space hard to leave. A spacious living room on the other side of the first floor has nice built-in bookcases, another pellet stove and French doors leading out to the attached screened porch. A small room between the living room and kitchen is currently used as a playroom but would make a nice office space. The large central entry hall leads to a beautiful stairwell that takes you up to four bedrooms and full bath on the second floor and the fully finished third floor. This floor has a large 30
❮❯Closed$665,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3225 sqft
35 Nelson Avenue
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Cute cottage in the Village of Cooperstown. Only two blocks to Bassett Medical Center, the schools, and the Clark Sports Center. With two bedrooms and 1.5 baths, the house would make a great starter home or getaway house. Work locally and want to save money on rent and commuting, this house would be perfect. The home has an open living/dining room, two bedrooms with a jack-and-jill bath, and a bright, cheerful kitchen that overlooks the new back deck and yard. In the front of the house is a charming enclosed sunporch. A detached one car garage has a covered storage area in the rear for gardening tools. The yard has plenty of space for a garden.
❮❯Closed$154,500 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 780 sqft
74 Susquehanna Avenue
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
This much loved Otsego Lake camp is on the market for the first time in 80 years! Originally the dance hall for the Hickory Grove Inn, the building was converted into two 2-bedroom seasonal cottages with a barn space in between in the 1930's. Both cottages include a kitchen, living room, two bedrooms, and a bath with updated shower. The south cottage has a charming front screened porch that has a view of the lake and enjoys the sounds of the creek and waterfall that run along Badger Lane. The north cottage has a spacious wrap-around screened porch perfect for relaxing and dining. The barn space between the cottages houses the laundry and the water system. Open the barn doors on either side and enjoy this space as a game or party room. Through the rear barn doors is a nice open, large yard. Other improvements include a new drilled well, an updated septic system, and a new metal roof. The camp sits on a .78 acre parcel that runs all the way over to Lakeshore Drive and includes the stream and approximately 185' of road frontage on St Hwy 80. This property has shared lake access at Hickory Grove Point - a quick 200' walk away. The property is being sold fully furnished. In the Cooperst
❮❯Closed$325,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1184 sqft
103 Badger Lane
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Close to everything! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom example of contemporary architecture was built in 2008 by a locally-based master craftsman. Situated in the vicinity of the Baseball Hall of Fame, this example of his timeless work is less than an outfield throw from Main Street! In addition to the town center and the HOF, unique shops, Cooperstown Schools and Otsego Lake.Across the threshold, nice touches embrace you, with cherry hardwoods in the kitchen and living spaces, an open layout, natural light and stylish fixtures both, neutral dcor,10-feet high ceilings, and gas fireplaces in the living room. In the stylish kitchen natural light beams off of the premium appliances and cherry cabinetry, and a convenient island for food prep - ensures that this center of culinary achievement is as practical as it is elegant.More than simply calm, the primary bedroom includes a custom-built walk-in closet & wardrobe, sitting area, and private bath with an air-jetted soaking tub and heated tile floors. There's also a gas fireplace(of course!). The other two bedrooms, located on the 2nd floor, are designed with plenty of closet space. Also: A large bonus room above the two-car garage.
❮❯Closed$729,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2852 sqft
12 Chestnut Street
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Middlefield NY Home for Sale
On a street of lovely homes in the desirable Village of Cooperstown. From the outside, you'd never guess what awaits you within this classic 1950 Cape Cod. This darling home features a large living room with a wood-burning fireplace, perfect for winter comfort; French doors that open onto a four-season sun porch with large windows framing the view of the backyard; central AC; and beautiful hardwood floors throughout. The dining room with corner built-in china cabinets opens into the kitchen and also leads to the sun porch, perfect for candlelight dinners and entertaining. There is a first-floor bedroom with a large closet and an attached full bath; this room is currently used as a family room. Upstairs are two generous bedrooms, with abundant closet space, and a full bathroom. The home also features a pretty breezeway that leads from the kitchen to the garage. Only steps from the Otesaga Resort Hotel, Otsego Lake, and the Leatherstocking Golf Course. One block to Main Street's restaurants, shops, and Farmers' Market.
❮❯Closed$535,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1872 sqft
65 Lake Street
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Middlefield NY Home for Sale
Beautiful 4 Bedroom Craftsman on a desirable street in the Village of Cooperstown, only half a block to Main Street and Otsego Lake. The house sits on a pleasant 1/3 acre lot with mature trees, a fenced back yard, and multiple outdoor spots for relaxing including a back porch, a large deck and a wonderful screened porch.The interior has been updated in recent years but still retains much of its original woodwork, lead glass windows, and nice hardwood floors. The large, welcoming kitchen/dining room spans the whole south side of the house and is bathed in light all day. Off the kitchen is a handy pantry, powder room, and a newly insulated and heated back mudroom. A new pellet stove makes this space hard to leave. A spacious living room on the other side of the first floor has nice built-in bookcases, another pellet stove and French doors leading out to the attached screened porch. A small room between the living room and kitchen is currently used as a playroom but would make a nice office space. The large central entry hall leads to a beautiful stairwell that takes you up to four bedrooms and full bath on the second floor and the fully finished third floor. This floor has a large 30
❮❯Closed$665,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3225 sqft
35 Nelson Avenue
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Looking for an Investment Opportunity? This 3,600+ square foot property, once a popular hotel, is located in the Fly Creek Hamlet Business District. The property was recently used for short-term rentals but would also make a spacious single-family home. Convert it into a multi-family income producer or professional offices with a special use permit. The propertys rooms are all generous in size with nice wood floors and high ceilings. The first floor has a large eat-in kitchen, living/dining room, and toward the back is a 600 sq. ft. room that has a separate entrance, 3/4 bath and a small kitchen. This room could be used as a grand living room or a rental/guest space. The second floor has three spacious bedrooms, 3/4 bath, laundry room, and a 600 sq. ft. bedroom with an ensuite. A small 2-car carriage barn, plenty of parking space, and a nice yard complete the property. Cooperstown Schools. This property is price below tax assessment.
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3632 sqft
6234 St Hwy 28
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
This much loved Otsego Lake camp is on the market for the first time in 80 years! Originally the dance hall for the Hickory Grove Inn, the building was converted into two 2-bedroom seasonal cottages with a barn space in between in the 1930's. Both cottages include a kitchen, living room, two bedrooms, and a bath with updated shower. The south cottage has a charming front screened porch that has a view of the lake and enjoys the sounds of the creek and waterfall that run along Badger Lane. The north cottage has a spacious wrap-around screened porch perfect for relaxing and dining. The barn space between the cottages houses the laundry and the water system. Open the barn doors on either side and enjoy this space as a game or party room. Through the rear barn doors is a nice open, large yard. Other improvements include a new drilled well, an updated septic system, and a new metal roof. The camp sits on a .78 acre parcel that runs all the way over to Lakeshore Drive and includes the stream and approximately 185' of road frontage on St Hwy 80. This property has shared lake access at Hickory Grove Point - a quick 200' walk away. The property is being sold fully furnished. In the Cooperst
❮❯Closed$325,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1184 sqft
103 Badger Lane
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Here is a "must-see" opportunity to bring your style and taste to an unbeatable location in the heart of the Village. Displaying the welcoming symmetry and sight lines of traditional architecture, this high-potential home is perfectly situated within the pedestrian range of restaurants, unique shops, Cooperstown schools, and Otsego Lake/Clarks Sport Center. This home offers a treasure they say money can't buy: more hours in the day because of the easy commute to Bassett Medical Center. The expansive yard contributes to an "open space" feel. Facing the street, a breezy porch greets you home. In the rear, a four-season back porch is a nice spot for relaxing with morning coffee or a twilight nightcap. Across the threshold, you'll find plenty of natural light throughout the home. The spacious kitchen brims with potential. The 3 bedrooms above the ground floor for privacy are ready for your decorative touch. The unfinished basement is perfect for storage or conversion. Detached one-car garage with a loft. The location of this home will increase the value of your personal vision. This one is a blank canvas for your lifestyle and memories!
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1655 sqft
13 Eagle Street
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Cute cottage in the Village of Cooperstown. Only two blocks to Bassett Medical Center, the schools, and the Clark Sports Center. With two bedrooms and 1.5 baths, the house would make a great starter home or getaway house. Work locally and want to save money on rent and commuting, this house would be perfect. The home has an open living/dining room, two bedrooms with a jack-and-jill bath, and a bright, cheerful kitchen that overlooks the new back deck and yard. In the front of the house is a charming enclosed sunporch. A detached one car garage has a covered storage area in the rear for gardening tools. The yard has plenty of space for a garden.
❮❯Closed$154,500 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 780 sqft
74 Susquehanna Avenue
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Beautifully restored 1820 Federal Farmhouse in the quaint Hamlet of Fly creek. You will immediately appreciate the historical character of this home as you enter the post and beam seasonal room from the driveway. There are many updates throughout, with retained original woodwork and hardwood floors. A large kitchen welcomes you upon entering the house, with an island for seating, and woodburning stove next to the dining area. The open floorplan then leads to a family room, formal living room with fireplace, a study/office with built-ins and a wet bar, and a full bath. The living room could be converted to a bedroom if one floor living is needed. The second floor has 3 sizeable bedrooms and another full bath with laundry. The large barn has ample space to park vehicles, a workshop area, second floor for loads of storage, and a bonus finished room with electric, water, and a propane stove for heat. Ideal for a workout room or convert to a studio apartment for guests! The 2.82 acres consists of land on both sides of the road, with a field across from the house that leads to Fly Creek. The stone patio and seasonal room with woodstove create exceptional spaces for entertaining.
❮❯Closed$539,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2168 sqft
871 County Highway 26
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Michael Burns - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Land Lot for Sale
Looking to build on a land parcel that will give you breathtaking views of Otsego County? Then Sunset Ridge is where you will want to design and build your dream homelocated on a quiet country road in Pierstown. 4.08 acres of open land, this parcel is only 5 miles from the historic Village of Cooperstown, Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital, Fenimore art museum, and Leatherstocking golf course. Cooperstown school district. Electrical Power and High-Speed Fiber Optics are available at the road.
❮❯Closed$126,500 Closed- 0 bds
- 0 ba
- 0 sqft
0 Sunset Ridge Road
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Roseboom NY Home for Sale
Circa 1860 stone house. This 2-bedroom 2- bathroom home is a great gem within the Roseboom hamlet area. Cross the threshold into a warm welcome; each room is graced with bright natural light from pocket windows. This home radiates old-world charm, with interior exposed stone walls, wide plank floors, gas fireplaces, and radiant heat on the first floor. The spacious kitchen has been updated with stainless steel appliances and bluestone counters. The second-floor landing offers a large bright space, perfect for an office or quiet sitting area. There is a 3/4 bathroom in the primary bedroom and two closets, with two small closets in the hall for the second large bedroom During the warmer months, take advantage of the large fenced-in yard. Your outdoor furniture will transform the flagstone patio into an open-air lounge. Bonus; Barn with a loft/solar panels. Standing on a quiet, low-traffic street, only minutes to Cherry Valley's unique shops, restaurants, and brewery & 12 miles to the Historical Village of Cooperstown.
❮❯Closed$225,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 2630 sqft
107 County Highway 57
Roseboom, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Once a stagecoach stop that supported a nearby mill, this c.1816 home has been owned & loved by the same family for over 60 yrs and is now ready for its next chapter. The layout of the property lends itself to many different possibilities. If one floor living is needed, there is a large bedroom with its own entrance & attached bath on the first floor. This level also has an eat-in kitchen with a wood stove, a large living room, sunroom, 3/4 bath, laundry/mudroom, powder room, and a room that could be used as another bedroom or office. The bright, south facing sunroom is the perfect spot for a dining room. Upstairs are 2 bedrooms & 650 sq ft of unheated space that could easily be transformed into more bedrooms/living space. With multiple entrances, it's easy to envision turning the home into a 2-3 unit investment property. The 2-car garage, 250' of road frontage & .86 acres allows plenty of space for parking. The location is directly on the local bus route & is convenient to the village of Cooperstown, as well as businesses along the Rt. 28 corridor. The basement is clean & dry with high ceilings. Electrical system, hot water heater, boiler & oil tank have all been recently updated.
❮❯Closed$399,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2156 sqft
5005 State Highway 28
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Once a stagecoach stop that supported a nearby mill, this c.1816 home has been owned & loved by the same family for over 60 yrs and is now ready for its next chapter. The layout of the property lends itself to many different possibilities. If one floor living is needed, there is a large bedroom with its own entrance & attached bath on the first floor. This level also has an eat-in kitchen with a wood stove, a large living room, sunroom, 3/4 bath, laundry/mudroom, powder room, and a room that could be used as another bedroom or office. The bright, south facing sunroom is the perfect spot for a dining room. Upstairs are 2 bedrooms & 650 sq ft of unheated space that could easily be transformed into more bedrooms/living space. With multiple entrances, it's easy to envision turning the home into a 2-3 unit investment property. The 2-car garage, 250' of road frontage & .86 acres allows plenty of space for parking. The location is directly on the local bus route & is convenient to the village of Cooperstown, as well as businesses along the Rt. 28 corridor. The basement is clean & dry with high ceilings. Electrical system, hot water heater, boiler & oil tank have all been recently updated.
❮❯Closed$399,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2156 sqft
5005 State Highway 28
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cherry Valley NY Home for Sale
Walk to Cherry Valley's restaurants and shops from this 4+ bedroom village home or sit on the front porch and watch the world pass by. Located close to the edge of the village, the house sits on .40 acres and is bordered on two sides by the historic Cherry Valley Cemetery. At the rear of the large, flat yard is a 2,400+/- sq. ft. 2-story barn with electric. The front porch entrance of the house leads into a center hallway. To the right is a large, sunny dining room featuring a stunning two panel mural painted by M. Stiles depicting the Cherry Valley Massacre of 1778. To the left, glass French doors lead into the living room. Another entrance in the back of the house enters into a mudroom, laundry room, and spacious country kitchen. A room currently used as an office could be a first floor bedroom as there is a full bath on this floor. Upstairs there are four bedrooms, another full bath, a large landing and hallway linen closet. A walk-in attic has been insulated and is used for storage. The basement is dry and has a new heating system. Only 15 minutes to the The Glimmerglass Festival, 20 minutes to Cooperstown and one hour to Albany.
❮❯Closed$229,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2400 sqft
38 Alden Street
Cherry Valley, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Mill Pond Cottage is located in the hamlet of Fly Creek within easy walking distance of the Fly Creek General Store and Post Office. The first floor of this charming home includes a living room, dining room, eat-in kitchen, a small bedroom or office, and a half bath with laundry. Upstairs is a large landing, a walk-in closet, and a primary bedroom with an attached full bath. Recent improvements include a completely rebuilt back porch including new footings, a new concrete front walkway, new carpet on the stairs and second floor, and new baseboard heat, flooring and exhaust fan in the full bath. The stove and washing machine are also new. The yard is fenced in and borders the cider mill duck pond. The property includes a two-car garage with electric. Seller is a NYS Licensed Real Estate Broker.
❮❯Closed$259,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1080 sqft
940 County Highway 26
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Walk to everything the village of Cooperstown has to offer from this centrally located c.1830 4-bed, 3-bath home. Enjoy the large backyard with hot tub, raised bed gardens, and patio for al fresco meals. Landscaping updates in the front yard opened up the charming front porch making it a focal point and a fun place to relax. A 2-car garage and large sunroom/mudroom help keep things organized. Recent improvements on the interior of the home include a renovated kitchen/dining room with a large island and heat pump heating/cooling system. New engineered hardwood floors were added in this room, as well as the staircase and 2nd floor floor hallway to match the adjoining rooms giving the space an airy, cohesive feel. Guest space on the first floor includes a bedroom, office/sitting room, and full bath is located on one side of the house and can be closed off for privacy. Upstairs are three bedrooms and two additional full baths. The primary bedroom with double closets and attached bath is on the back of the house overlooking the yard. The house has a great layout that offers privacy when needed, and generous living spaces when socializing. This home is truly move-in ready.
❮❯Closed$639,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2521 sqft
104 Pioneer Street
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Cooperstown NY Home for Sale
Classic American Foursquare in Cooperstown. Step into this meticulously maintained 5-bedroom, 2.5-bath home boasting over 3,200 sq ft of living space on a spacious 0.27-acre lot. The inviting front porch welcomes you into the home where you will find sun-filled rooms, beautiful woodwork, and original pocket doors. The first floor offers: a large family room with a gas fireplace, ideal for cozy gatherings during cooler months; a formal living room; a sitting room with built-in bookshelves, currently used as a breakfast room; a spacious formal dining room with a large picture window; an efficient, charming kitchen with double sinks and an original built-in cupboard; a large mudroom off the back of the house with laundry; a half bath; and a bonus room with a large window overlooking the back yard. This room is currently being used as an office, but would also make an excellent first floor bedroom or playroom. Upstairs, the second floor offers 4 large bedrooms with good closet space. The primary bedroom is at the back of the home and features a full bathroom with a large walk-in closet, ensuring comfort and convenience. Natural light floods the house throughout the day, enhancing its inviting atmosphere. In 2005, a significant two-story addition was added, which included the family room, office, mudroom, additional bedrooms, and back staircase, expanding the home's functionality and charm. Other highlights include an insulated walk-up attic, a newer Buderus furnace, two newer 240-gallon oil tanks, high-speed internet, a back patio, a deep yard for play, and a 2-car garage completing this move-in-ready home. Conveniently located, it is an easy walk to Bassett Medical Center, Cooperstown Central Schools, and the Clarks Sports Center. Main Street is just two blocks away where you will find the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, the village library, wonderful unique shops, art galleries, and restaurants. Just beyond Main Street is beautiful Otsego Lake where you can paddleboard, kayak, and boat. An easy drive to the Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, and Glimmerglass Opera Festival.
❮❯Closed$549,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 3 ba
- sqft
107 Pioneer Street
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: -
Cooperstown NY Land for Sale
6+/- acre building lot less than 10 minutes to the village of Cooperstown, Leatherstocking Golf Course, and beautiful Otsego Lake. Mostly level and open with 410 feet of road frontage and a drilled well. There are nice open views and a small creek that runs through the parcel. The adjacent 4+ acre lot is also available. In the Cooperstown School District.
❮❯Closed$37,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
0 Keys Rd Lot 2
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: -
Cooperstown NY Land for Sale
4+ acre building lot less than 10 minutes to the village of Cooperstown, Leatherstocking Golf Course, and beautiful Otsego Lake. Mostly open with 530 feet of road frontage, a drilled well, and nice open views. The adjacent 6+/- acre lot is also available. In the Cooperstown School District.
❮❯Closed$33,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
0 Keys Rd Lot 1
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: -
Cooperstown NY Land for Sale
Commercial .47 acre parcel within the Village of Cooperstown. This property is open and level with 100' of road frontage. Located just off State Highway 28 and within two blocks of the schools, grocery store, restaurants, gas stations, and pharmacies.
❮❯Closed$135,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
53 Walnut St
Cooperstown, NY
Listing by: -
Garrattsville NY Home for Sale
1880 home located in the hamlet of Garrattsville on nearly 3.5 acres land. Turning onto the driveway you will first notice a charming front porch overlooking the yard. The driveway continues to the back acreage where a workshop/garage and three sided barn are located. The land is gently sloped, open and sunny and could easily be used for animals or gardens. Trees on the property include Butternut, Larch, Spruce, Apple, and Lilac. The house was freshly painted and the side deck was rebuilt this past summer. Inside, the majority of the first floor has new engineered hardwood floors and there is new carpeting on the second floor landing. The house has a nice floor plan with a bedroom and full bath on the first floor, a double-sized living room, a dining room off the kitchen with French doors that open to the deck, and two additional bedrooms and full bath on the second floor. A room off the living room could be used as an office or den, or a 4th bedroom if needed. Upstairs, a partially finished room with exposed beams and two large storage closets, could be completed to add an additional 250 sq. ft. to the home. A one-car attached garage leads conveniently into the dining room and kitchen area. A room off the garage with a separate outside entrance would make a great mudroom or cold storage room. Morris School District.
❮❯Closed$245,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1878 sqft
4450 State Highway 51
Garrattsville, NY
Listing by: -
Cherry Valley NY Home for Sale
Walk to Cherry Valley's restaurants and shops from this 4+ bedroom village home or sit on the front porch and watch the world pass by. Located close to the edge of the village, the house sits on .40 acres and is bordered on two sides by the historic Cherry Valley Cemetery. At the rear of the large, flat yard is a 2,400+/- sq. ft. 2-story barn with electric. The front porch entrance of the house leads into a center hallway. To the right is a large, sunny dining room featuring a stunning two panel mural painted by M. Stiles depicting the Cherry Valley Massacre of 1778. To the left, glass French doors lead into the living room. Another entrance in the back of the house enters into a mudroom, laundry room, and spacious country kitchen. A room currently used as an office could be a first floor bedroom as there is a full bath on this floor. Upstairs there are four bedrooms, another full bath, a large landing and hallway linen closet. A walk-in attic has been insulated and is used for storage. The basement is dry and has a new heating system. Only 15 minutes to the The Glimmerglass Festival, 20 minutes to Cooperstown and one hour to Albany.
❮❯Closed$229,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2400 sqft
38 Alden St
Cherry Valley, NY
Listing by: -
Westford NY Home for Sale
You will fall in love with this charming three bedroom farmhouse with large party barn/artist studio set on 48 acres of meadows, woods, and swimming pond. Only 5 mins to I-88 and 3.5 hours to NYC. The house is filled with great light, beautiful hardwood floors, and an inviting kitchen. Off the kitchen is a side deck with hot tub overlooking a private yard with perennial flower gardens. The barn is perfect for entertaining or use it for work, the possibilities are endless. Updates to the barn include new supports, cables, painted in 2016, and the metal roof was treated. Two thirds of the main barn is open for entertaining with a large overhead door that can be opened to the yard. One third of the barn has been converted into an art gallery with insulated walls and electric heat. This space opens to a new deck off the back of the barn, A loft space above this room was also converted into finished space and is currently used as an art studio. The lower level of the barn is good for parking cars or storing gardening equipment. A new 3-bay pole barn was built in 2017 and is perfect for storing boats, RVs/trailers, or anything you need. This property is a wonderful place to relax, take w
❮❯Closed$299,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1576 sqft
930 County Highway 36
Westford, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
CHARMING, AFFORDABLE Cooperstown Village home one block from Main Street and an easy walk to the schools, Bassett Medical Center, and stores. Nice wood floors and original woodwork throughout. Electric has been updated. Roof, furnace, and hot water heater have all been replaced recently. Front porch has been rebuilt and a new back porch added in 2015. House was most recently used as a rental home bringing in $1,200/month. PRICED TO SELL - list price is $34k below assessment.
❮❯Closed$169,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1482 sqft
26 Leatherstocking Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
CENTRALLY LOCATED 4 BEDROOM, 3.5 BATH VILLAGE HOME just steps from Main Street and an easy walk to the schools and Bassett Medical Center. Features include a two car garage, new roof, fresh paint job, new landscaping and patio with firepit, a side sitting porch, nice hardwood floors, and a first floor master suite. The house offers plenty of space to spread out with three additional bedrooms and two full baths on the second floor and both a living room and family room with a fireplace on the first floor. Back yard borders Willow Creek.
❮❯Closed$299,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2371 sqft
52 Chestnut Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
This sun-filled centrally located home is only 3 miles to Cooperstown and an easy commute to Brewery Ommegang, Oneonta, and the Cooperstown Dreams Park. Set on 3 acres with nice views in all directions, the owners have planted many evergreens, fruit trees, and perennials on the property. The main floor has a living room with cathedral ceiling, propane fireplace and picture window that flows nicely into a dining room, kitchen, 3-season sun porch & outside deck. Three bedrooms, including a master suite, complete this floor. The lower level is perfect for quests or kids with another bedroom suite and den currently set up as a theater room. A large 400+sf family room also located on the lower level has it's own entrance through a mudroom making it an ideal space for a home office or additional living space. Outside enjoy a two-car garage with storage, a garden shed, patio, and fenced vegetable garden. This is an efficient, well-maintained home that's ready for a quick move in.
❮❯Closed$339,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2610 sqft
254 Beaver Meadow Road
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Springfield NY Home for Sale
COUNTRY LIVING AT ITS BEST! This beautiful property located in Springfield with Otsego Lake rights, puts one just minutes to Glimmerglass Opera, multiple golf courses, the Fenimore Art Museum, and Cooperstown, the home of the Baseball Hall of Fame. Custom built in 2004 with 5 bedrooms & 5 1/2 bathrooms, approximately 4,000 sq. ft. of living space and numerous porches and decks to enjoy the outdoor space. Enter into a gracious, two-story entry hall. On the first floor a large master suite with full bathroom, his and her walk-in closets, and fireplace opens to a private wrap-around deck. The open concept living room, dining room and kitchen are perfect for entertaining. Slider doors off the dining room lead to a beautiful deck with awning overlooking the rolling hills. Another door off the dining area leads to a charming four season porch. The kitchen offers lots of cabinets, double ovens, large island, and desk area. In a wing off the kitchen is an oversized pantry, craft/art room, office, laundry room, and mudroom. Upstairs are 2 large, private suites each with their own attached bathrooms. The lower level has 2 bedrooms, a full bath, play space and a small kitchenette. This level
❮❯Closed$629,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 3885 sqft
346 County Highway 27
Springfield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
YANKEE BARN POST & BEAM home designed and sited with every small detail taken into consideration. The house and barn with three bedroom guest apartment are set beautifully on 85 acres of farmland, overlooking a stocked swimming pond & backed by trees & Fly Creek. Enjoy hunting or hiking on two trails in the upper fields & woods, or relax & enjoy the spectacular view on the large deck or screened porch. Upon entering the home one is immediately drawn in by the floor to ceiling windows, soaring 3-story open ceiling, & abundant natural light. Perfectly sited to take advantage of passive-solar energy, the house feels spacious, yet warm & cozy at the same time. A 3-story fireplace made from local fieldstone sits graciously in the living room & is a focal point from all points in the house. The home blends private areas - like a first floor master suite - with wonderful entertaining spaces. Includes 2 tax parcels 53.00-1-22.04 & .05.
❮❯Closed$750,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 3042 sqft
175 Donlon Road
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Move into this comfortable home & enjoy privacy & lake rights, and still be within walking distance of everything in the village. The home is part of the Lakeland Shores Assoc. entitling the owners to shared lake rights which include .33 acres of direct lake frontage w/ picnic area, kayak storage, a boat dock, & wonderful views across the lake to Lakefront marina & the Otesaga Hotel & Leatherstocking Golf Course. Nicely sited and surrounded by trees, the home has multiple areas to enjoy the outdoors - two separate stone terraces, a deck, & a small balcony. Inside is a stone & slate full height entry staircase that leads to two different living levels. On the upper floor is the kitchen, dining room, 400sf living room w/ vaulted beamed ceilings, & 3-season room w/ wood stove. Down a few stairs is a wonderful family room w/ a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace & sliders to a small balcony. A large master suite is off this room & two additional bedrooms & bath are on the first floor.
❮❯Closed$449,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2750 sqft
128 County Highway 31
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Springfield NY Home for Sale
One of the area's finest GENTLEMAN FARMS available in Otsego County.This beautiful century home sits on 20.32 acres with a large spring fed pond on a quiet country road lined with majestic Maple trees. Renovated 1850's three bedroom,2 1/2 bath. Renovations in 2007 added modern amenities throughout, while keeping all the original charm. A bonus to this property is the three-bay garage and a Morton building with storage and a renovated two bedroom guest house. Glimmerglass Festival and the quaint village of Cooperstown, home of the Baseball Hall of Fame, are only minutes away making the guest cottage perfect for extra rental income. The property also has Otsego Lake rights for swimming, boating, and picnicking at Springfield Public Landing.
❮❯Closed$339,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1719 sqft
149 Koenig Road
Springfield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
Beautifully situated on 1+ acres of land with a park-like setting just south of Cooperstown, this well preserved 4-5 bedroom house has been meticulously maintained. It has been a great family home for the current owners for nearly 39 years. Over the past 17 years the home has served as a productive Dreams Park rental during the summer months. Inside the 3,000 square foot home you will find a large country kitchen, two bathrooms, dining room with original cherry built in cabinets, a family room, and formal living room. Only minutes to Dreams Park, the Village of Cooperstown, and Ommegang Brewery. On the OPT Bus line. Cooperstown Schools.
❮❯Closed$285,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 2 ba
- 2988 sqft
4897 State Highway 28
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
This stately 1860 Federal style home is perfect for anyone who wants the convenience of living close to the village of Cooperstown but prefers a country lifestyle with 46 acres of green pastures, mature plantings and lush perennial gardens. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home offers a large bedroom and full bath on the first floor, original wide plank floors, six over six windows with deep pocket sills, and built in bookcases. A large addition to the west end of the house,with floor to ceiling windows that open the way for afternoon sunshine and views of the westward hills and sunset. This room is the heart of the home with an open concept kitchen/family room with vaulted ceiling and fireplace. Tucked away from the main house in a private setting with its own driveway, sits a charming cottage with 2 bedrooms, a living room/kitchen with open beamed ceiling, and a full bathroom with stacked washer & dryer. It would make a great full time or seasonal rental. The owners currently rent the cottage to Glimmerglass Opera for several weeks in the summer. A quick 2.5 mile drive to the village of Cooperstown, Leatherstocking Golf Course, Baseball Hall of Fame, and Otsego Lake.
❮❯Closed$575,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2728 sqft
287 County Highway 28
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
Fantastic location on a desirable street in the center of Cooperstown. Beautiful C. 1830's historic home with all modern updates. This home has many ownership options - great family home, perfect senior home, and could even have short term rental or in-law apartment possibilities. Convenient to everything! Walk to schools, Bassett Medical Center, the village and the Clark Sports Center. This four bedroom, three bath home has a large 1980's addition off the back and features an open kitchen/family room with a pellet stove and lots of light. The rest of the first floor has ample living space including a dining room, living room with Vermont Castings wood stove, den/5th bedroom, library/office with built-ins, a full bath with laundry, a bedroom with separate outside entrance and a large side sun porch. Much of the first floor has original wide 19th century pine floors. Upstairs are three bedrooms and a full bath with laundry chute and a large master suite with full en suite bath, and his and hers custom walk-in closets. The basement has a large children's playroom/family room and storage shelving. This beautiful home has mature landscaping and a deep lush backyard with a patio and two
❮❯Closed$420,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2521 sqft
104 Pioneer Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Middlefield NY Home for Sale
A CHEERY FARMHOUSE WITH MUCH OUTDOOR SPACE TO ENJOY - located only 10 minutes door to door to the Village of Cooperstown. This welcoming home is well laid out with a front porch and rear mudroom entry with a half bath, a large dining room with wood stove and pass through window to the sunny kitchen (with pantry). Off the living room is a nice office/study. Upstairs are three well sized bedrooms and a full bath. If you love gardening, you will appreciate the many vegetable beds (fenced), perennial herb and flower beds, fruit and nut trees and bushes, woods and meadows filled with flowers and birds. Enjoy dining under the arbor and a pleasant stream. There is a small potting shed for storage and garden tools. Listing includes tax map #164.00-1-16.31 2.95 additional acres across the street with one fenced acre and a large barn. Barn includes 2 horse stalls, sheep pen, water, heated tack room with wood stove, and a workshop.
❮❯Closed$250,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1288 sqft
1251 State Highway 166
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
The Phoenix Inn, a former tavern, is an owner occupied income property on 11+ acres, with 4 full suites on 2 floors, each with private bath, including a 2-story 1,500sf owner's apt. with large living area, private entrance, office space, walk-in closets, bathroom, and huge 3rd fl. loft bedroom. The inn's kitchen has a gas range with hood, commercial sink and dishwasher, plus 2 refrigerators. Property sale to include common area furniture and wood stove, antique bar in the dining room, furnishings, beds, dressers, tables/chairs, outdoor furniture and linens for the suites. Parking for 12 cars, hi-speed internet and WiFi, separate electric meter for apt unit. This is a great opportunity to own and occupy a Turn-Key business in a large well maintained home and tavern. Convenient location to Dreams Park, Ommegang, Glimmerglass Opera and Cooperstown village amenities. Or can be returned to a single family, multi-family, or apartment rentals.
❮❯Closed$350,000 Closed- 7 bds
- 7 ba
- 4200 sqft
1270 County Highway 33
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
METICULOUSLY RENOVATED 1840's VILLAGE HOME WITH AN OVERSIZED ADDITION COMPLETED IN 2009. This well maintained 5 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home has much to offer. An inviting front entry hall leads into the formal living room of the original home with hardwood floors and cozy fireplace. From this room the home opens into the new rear addition featuring a gracious grand room with a state of the art custom kitchen boasting granite counters, a 6-burner Wolf range, wall oven and warming drawer, Subzero refrigerator, and a nice sized pantry. The kitchen is open to a dining area with a full wall of built-in cabinets and the spacious family room with wood burning fireplace surrounded by custom bookcases. A wall of French doors lead out to a wonderful back deck perfect for entertaining. An attached garage enters into a large mudroom with built-in cubbies. Off the mudroom is a half bath and a sunny laundry room with sink and laundry shoot. Upstairs you will find 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, an office, and a spacious master suite overlooking the backyard. This 800sf suite features custom built-ins and a beautiful marble fireplace, a huge walk in closet, and a generous master bath with ample cabinets
❮❯Closed$749,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 4 ba
- 4052 sqft
74 Fair Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
BEAUTIFUL WELL MAINTAINED COLONIAL ON OVER AN ACRE OF LAND AT THE END OF A CUL-DE-SAC IN THE VILLAGE IS A RARE FIND! The family-friendly home is well suited for entertaining as well as quiet enjoyment. On the first level is large living room with fireplace, an open kitchen with cathedral ceiling and dining area, a formal dining room, family room with built-ins, office, den, and an oversized mudroom with 3/4 bath. The second floor boasts four comfortable bedrooms including a large master suite. Outside enjoy the 700+ sq. ft. deck overlooking a very private 1.37 acre yard. An attached one-car garage and a detached two-car garage complete the property. Easy walk to the school, grocery story, Bassett Medical Center, Clark Sports Center, and Main Street.
❮❯Closed$529,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3018 sqft
15 South Avenue
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
1910 classic turn-of-the-century foursquare home in the heart of the Village of Cooperstown on a desirable street. This 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home with ample closet space has been thoroughly updated while retaining many of the original Craftsman features. Meticulously maintained with an open airy feel, the many improvements include central air conditioning, custom cellular blinds throughout, new recessed lighting fixtures and stainless-steel kitchen appliances. A freshly landscaped garden surrounds the newly rebuilt front porch and offers a quiet outdoor sitting area. One of this property's most endearing features, unique to only a handful of village properties, is the deep back lawn, which features a newly fenced in area for children and pets. This home is nestled in one of Cooperstown's most coveted neighborhoods and has been beautifully renovated to the highest standards. Welcome home to a quiet private refuge in the middle of town.
❮❯Closed$285,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1579 sqft
21 Pine Boulevard
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
BEAUTIFUL 1810 COUNTRY HOME ON 12.77 ACRES WITH BUCOLIC VIEWS. This home would make a wonderful summer or weekend home or a relaxing year-round home. Enjoy the simple life with lots of privacy and quiet but just a short drive to the village of Cooperstown with it's many museums, newly expanded state of the art sports center, Otsego Lake, Brewery Ommegang and the Glimmerglass Festival. This house has been perfectly rebuilt from the foundation up, paying close attention to every detail and is in impeccable shape. Original chestnut beams and rough cut pine floors throughout. Upon entering the home one immediately notices the wonderful natural light and beautiful calming feel of the home. The first floor features a nice open floor plan with a kitchen/keeping room on one side and a nice large living room/dining room on the other. At the back of the house off the kitchen is an efficient mudroom/laundry room and powder room. Upstairs are two nice sized bedrooms with attached baths and a third room that can be used as a guest room or office. Every system in the house is new and has been built to the highest standard. New high density foam insulation and Andersen windows help make this home
❮❯Closed$264,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1512 sqft
261 Panther Mountain Road
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
Fully Renovated Farmhouse on 3+ Acres Only Minutes to Cooperstown. Move right into this 4 bed/2 bath home & begin enjoying all this property has to offer. Completely reframed, rewired, newly plumbed & sided there is nothing more to do but add your personal touches. The heart of the home is the bright kitchen with center island, window seat, inset cabinets, PaperStone, granite & butcher block counter tops, and a walk-in pantry. Hardwood floors & chestnut woodwork throughout help make the house warm & inviting. A newly fenced yard off the kitchen & side porch is great for pets or kids. Outside enjoy two ponds, a large storage barn with electric, fenced vegetable garden with gardening shed, herb garden, tree house with swing set, fruit trees, a babbling brook & Red Creek frontage. A detached garage has been used as a workshop but could be turned into a two-bay garage for cars.
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1992 sqft
2848 County Highway 33
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
PRIVATE FOUR BEDROOM HOME WITH HORSE BARN AND WORKSHOP ON 80+/- ACRES IN THE COOPERSTOWN SCHOOL DISTRICT. Built and owned by a master builder, the home has been meticulously maintained and improved over the years. Features include radiant floor heat, central air conditioning, acid washed concrete floors, new Marvin windows in the front & back of house, new stone facing on the chimney, and fresh paint on the interior. The home boasts an open floor plan on the first floor with high ceilings and exposed beams. The kitchen is spacious with plenty of room for entertaining. An addition off the first floor includes a bedroom and bath that could be used as a master or guest space/office. The second floor has three bedrooms including a large master suite, a nice office with built-ins, large laundry room, and a 16x30 bonus room. This room is currently used as an office & family room but could be easily converted into a studio apartment as there is a separate staircase & entrance. The 12x60 attic was designed to be finished off as a room in the future if someone desires. A separate two-story workshop is well equipped with radiant floor heat, water, and separate electric meter. A 5-stall barn
❮❯Closed$695,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3424 sqft
1961 County Highway 26
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
A large family-friendly farmhouse is what you will find behind the lovely stone wall and gated entry. The property sits on 1.53 private acres with Oaks Creek running at the edge of the yard, giving you a park like feel. Inside the home are 5 bedrooms, a large kitchen/dining/keeping room with vaulted ceiling and sliding glass doors that lead to a wrap around deck. This home has many updates, yet lots of original features. The front entrance with fanlight window was recently rebuilt. A ten year old addition added a first floor master suite or guest room. A perfect home to spread out. Enjoy family gatherings in the flat, expansive yard highlighted by a beautiful perennial garden just off the back deck. Less than five miles to the village of Cooperstown. In the Cooperstown School district.
❮❯Closed$309,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 3 ba
- 3488 sqft
166 Cattown Road
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
Sitting on 1/3 of an acre of direct Otsego Lake frontage, this charming cottage was completely rebuilt in 2002. Would make a wonderful vacation home or take advantage of it's solid rental history for extra income. The home currently rents for $1,800/week during the 13-week summer period. Being sold turn-key, everything you need is here. Three bedrooms, a living room with fireplace & picture window overlooking the lake, kitchen/dining room, and an oversized deck for entertaining. Stairs lead down to 101' feet of private, direct lake frontage and a 2 year old dock. Plenty of parking in a semi-circular driveway. Located a half mile off the main road on the east side of the lake only one mile from Glimmerglass State Park and five miles to the Village of Cooperstown.
❮❯Closed$390,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 798 sqft
185 Lippitt Development Road
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Exeter NY Commercial Sale for Sale
TWO COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS for sale along State Highway 28 close to Cooperstown. THE POSSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS - The Schuyler Lake Hotel and adjoining retail/restaurant building are just waiting for their next owner. A popular establishment since the 1800's, the 5,000+ sq. ft. hotel building used to house a restaurant/bar on the first floor and offered hotel rooms upstairs. The 2,300+ sq. ft. building next door was at one point a dry goods store before being incorporated into the hotel. Current owners have once again separated this space making it a self contained building. Renovations to this building include new electrical wiring, plumbing, spray foam and blown-in insulation, new 1,500 gallon septic with 700 gallon grease trap, UV water system, and a handicap bathroom. This space is ready for a business - just move your equipment in. The larger hotel building is in need of renovation. The space has been gutted and is ready for the next phase of its history. Turn it back into a restaurant and bar or hotel. Take advantage of the local beverage trail and the New York State farm brewery laws to open a brewery, winery or distillery. This space can easily be adapted for a new owner's bus
❮❯Closed$110,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- 7446 sqft
7361 State Highway 28
Exeter, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
EXCEPTIONAL 3 BED, 2 BATH 1820 FEDERAL FARMHOUSE & BARN IN THE LOVELY HAMLET of FLY CREEK on 2.82 +- ACRES BOTH SIDES of ROAD and BORDERING the CREEK! Wonderful Open Kitchen, Dining & Family Rm Layout with Vaulted Beam Ceiling, Skylights, Extensive Breakfast Island, Built-ins & Wood Stove, Formal Living Room, Fireplace, Library/Den w/Built-ins & Wet Bar and First Floor Bathroom with Double Shower. Second Floor has 3 Spacious Bedrooms, and Full Bath with Laundry. Endless Entertainment Opportunities appreciating Spectacular Post & Beam Structure in the 3 Season Back Room with Wood Stove and Fantastic 2 Story Barn, along with Private Stone Patio From the Kitchen and Lovely Landscaped Yard. Nearly 2 Acres along the The Creek For Private Camping, Cookouts & All Around Enjoyment! Cooperstown is just a 5 Minute Drive and all your necessities are a Short Walk to Local Store, Post Office and even the Fly Creek Cider Mill! $365,000.
❮❯Closed$365,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2200 sqft
871 County Highway 26
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Katherine Fistrowicz - Howard Hanna -
NY Home for Sale
Great family home in the village of Cooperstown only one block from Main Street. Features three bedrooms with hardwood floors, 2.5 baths, large open kitchen/dining room has newer appliances, new granite counters and kitchen peninsula. French doors open up to a deck and deep back yard. Plenty of room for entertaining and for kids to play. Off the kitchen is an inviting family room with vaulted, open beam ceiling, wood burning fireplace, and cherry floors. Conveniently located - easy walk to Bassett Medical Center, schools, stores, and Otsego Lake.
❮❯Closed$299,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2827 sqft
50 Chestnut Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Well maintained home in the center of Cooperstown, one block from Bassett Medical Center and a quick walk to the Clark Sports Center. Roof new in 2008, some replacement windows, attached garage, nice back yard. Would make a great family home.
❮❯Closed$255,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2039 sqft
44 Beaver Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
CENTRALLY LOCATED, FULLY RENOVATED 3 BEDROOM 1800's VILLAGE HOME with separate one bedroom apartment perfect for extra income or guest space. Completely gutted and renovated in 2004 including new wiring, plumbing, heating system, sheetrock and insulation. The main part of the house has a charming front sitting porch, an entry hall with track lighting & gallery wall for art, living room, dining room, and a comfortable kitchen with oversized island. Off the kitchen is a half bath and a pantry/mudroom. Upstairs is a master suite with an attached full bath and another room to use as a nice closet or office. Two additional bedrooms and full bath complete this floor. A separate 400+ sq. ft. one bedroom apartment on the first floor has it's own front and back entrances. The apartment includes a kitchen, full bath with shower, bedroom, living room, and a private back deck. Take advantage of this rental income or easily open it up to incorporate the space into the main house. This house is perfect for for a buyer looking for a family home or a home with rental income OR purchase as an investment property and rent out both sides long-term. Two blocks to Main Street and three blocks to Basset
❮❯Closed$299,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2280 sqft
36 Elm Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Springfield NY Home for Sale
Beautiful log cabin totally remodeled with new plumbing, electric, new heaters, Marvin windows, new interior staircase and Southern yellow pine floors. All renovations done by master carpenter. Full blown-in foam insulation. New front and rear pressure treated porches. Great barn with garage and workshop, workshop has a woodstove. Nestled on 1 acre in a prime location. This lovely property features three bedrooms, two full baths, open concept floor plan, beautiful stone faced fireplace, and full basement with lots of storage. Quiet location less than two miles to Otsego Lake and the Glimmerglass Festival. Lake access at Springfield Public Landing.
❮❯Closed$189,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1500 sqft
109 Willsey Road
Springfield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Heathcote is one of Cooperstown's most historic & gracious estates. Built in 1886, the home sits on 4+ private acres and features a garden designed in the 1920's by American landscape architect, Ellen Biddle Shipman. A circular drive leads to an impressive front door with side lights & fan window that opens into a 350 sq ft foyer with fireplace, beautiful wood paneling, & a historic mural painted in 1928 by Agnes Tait & recently restored by a local art historian. The current owners have cared for the home & added to its value by updating the heating & electrical systems, replacing the roof, replastering many of the walls, restoring woodwork & floors, fixing chimneys to ensure all 9 fireplaces are in working order, and adding a mudroom. On the 3rd floor the owners renovated 1,000+ sq ft of former servants rooms into a two bed/two bath guest space complete with living room & 250 sq ft of finished attic space. Please contact listing agent for more details or to schedule a private showing.
❮❯Closed$899,000 Closed- 7 bds
- 9 ba
- 6573 sqft
67 Estli Avenue
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Hartwick NY Home for Sale
PICTURE PERFECT 1870 HISTORICAL 3 BEDROOM HOME in the hamlet of HARTWICK. This beautifully landscaped home with inviting front porch is a head turner. Meticulously maintained by the current owners for nearly 35 years, their care and love is evident in every detail of the house and property. Upon entering the house, one is immediately struck by the lovely high ceilings and natural light. The front porch leads into a nice entry hall with a large living room on one side and a family room on the other. The big, inviting kitchen was redone in 2006 and includes a breakfast area, a large peninsula with stools, and a woodstove. A large picture window looks out over a charming side porch. Off the kitchen is an original pantry with loads of storage. A dining room, 3/4 bath, and bonus room that could be used as an office, craft room or mudroom complete this floor. Upstairs are three bedrooms, laundry, and a full bath. Off the side kitchen porch is a 400sf Brazilian Ipe wood deck with hot tub and privacy wall - perfect for entertaining or relaxing. A detached over-sized garage is tucked nicely in the back corner of the lot. This flat, family-friendly, corner lot is tastefully landscaped with p
❮❯Closed$239,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2119 sqft
3141 County Highway 11
Hartwick, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
This charming 4 bedroom village home has been updated with a new full bath, new moldings and wood work in the dining room & living room, and new ceilings with recessed lighting. Original oak floors have been completely redone. A deep back yard is perfect for kids and gardening. The charming living room with fireplace has French doors that open onto a wonderful front porch, making it great for entertaining or relaxing. Located in the heart of the village two blocks from Main Street and walking distance to Bassett Medical Center, the Clark Sports Center, and schools.
❮❯Closed$385,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 1844 sqft
95 Pioneer Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Middlefield NY Home for Sale
Are you looking for a B&B, Dreams Park rental or a large home for a primary residence? This 6 bedroom 5 bath home has 48.61 acres in the Cooperstown School district! On the first floor you will find a family room with wood stove, formal dining room with built ins, large living room with wood burning fireplace, kitchen over looking the back yard and a first floor bedroom with private bath. As you ascend up the upstairs to the landing you will see built in book shelves and 4+ bedrooms all with their own private bathrooms. What more could you ask for? Acreage? Yes that too - there is 48+ acres of land to wander. There are also 2 barns for storage/garage space and animals. The rocking chair front porch is inviting for all guests and the back yard has a nice area for gatherings and BBQ's. If you are looking for that older home character that new homes can't recreate and a great location - make your appointment today! Currently rented for Dreams Park at $2400/week.
❮❯Closed$259,900 Closed- 6 bds
- 5 ba
- 2396 sqft
712 County Highway33
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Stacey L. Camilleri - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
FOUR BEDROOM VILLAGE HOME JUST STEPS FROM MAIN STREET. Well built and maintained over the years, the home features a nice front sitting porch, original woodwork and hardwood floors through out. A welcoming front entry hall leads into an oversized living room with a wood burning fireplace. A full bath on the first floor allows for first floor living if needed. Upstairs are four bedrooms, another full bath, laundry area, and back staircase leading to the kitchen. A walk up full attic could be converted for additional living space. The property includes a desirable two story barn with parking and second floor storage space.
❮❯Closed$279,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2152 sqft
48 Chestnut Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
This house MUST BE SEEN in person to be truly appreciated - you will be pleasantly surprised! Well maintained, move-in ready ranch home only two miles to Cooperstown. Enjoy country living in a small neighborhood of approximately 12 homes but still be just 5 minutes from the schools, stores, and Main Street. In addition to the three bedrooms and two full baths on the main floor, the owner has renovated the basement into a studio apartment with kitchenette and bathroom. Currently a seasonal rental, this space could easily be turned into a year-round apartment, guest space, or family/rec room. The main floor of the home is perfectly laid out with a welcoming enclosed front porch/mudroom, living room, dining room, a bright kitchen, and a sunroom with gas stove off the back of the house. The sunroom leads to a nice 250sf deck with eastern views of the hills and the back yard. The bedrooms are well thought out for privacy with the master suite (with walk-in closet) on one side of home and the other two bedrooms and full bath on the opposite side of the home. Other features include ceiling fans, oak floors, skylights, spray foam insulation, a 5-year old roof, and a two-car garage. This ho
❮❯Closed$272,500 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1344 sqft
105 Haggerty Road
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Westford NY Home for Sale
Priced to Sell! This affordable home is perfect for the first time home buyer or someone looking to downsize. Located in the hamlet of Westville, the home is in the Milford School District and close to Cooperstown and Brewery Ommegang. Updates include a newer furnace, hot water heater, and rewired electrical system. Nice pine floors throughout help make this charming home warm & inviting. There is plenty of space to enjoy yourself outside in the large, half acre yard. A nice carriage barn is perfect for a workshop or storage. This property is being sold AS-IS.
❮❯Closed$85,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 1632 sqft
2660 County Highway 35
Westford, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Middlefield NY Residential Income for Sale
Excellent opportunity for a first-time home buyer or investor. Only minutes from the Village of Cooperstown. This two-family home has a ground floor one bedroom apartment and a three bedroom duplex all in move in condition. Updates include new kitchen appliances, replacement windows, updated mechanicals, a new entryway and front porch. The roof was just replaced in August 2019. The listing includes two parcels totaling 5.5 acres and includes a barn which can be used for parking, storage or small animals. Cooperstown Schools.
❮❯Closed$159,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2298 sqft
3128 County Hwy 33
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Hartwick NY Home for Sale
HOME SWEET HOME SWEET PRICE! Just a mile from Fly Creek in the Cooperstown School District this Affordable Home on 4+/-Acres offers Four Bedrooms, one is 1st Floor across from the Full Bath, 1st Floor Laundry, Spacious Kitchen & Living w/Wood Stove, 3 Bedrooms 2nd Floor Plus 16'x16' Unfinished Room, Large Back Deck to Terrific Yard accented with Split Rail Fence and an Oversized Attached 2 Car Garage with Paved Driveway! $207,500.
❮❯Closed$207,500 Closed- 4 bds
- 1 ba
- 1800 sqft
316 Jones Road
Hartwick, NY
Listing by: Katherine Fistrowicz - Howard Hanna -
NY Land for Sale
This unique 947 acre property comprises an entire secluded secret valley, characterized by exceptional beauty and tranquility, with stunning Otsego Lake views and magnificent internal landscapes. Ten minutes from Cooperstown and approximately seven minutes from Cherry Valley, the surrounding area offers wonderful cultural opportunities, an outstanding health care center, fine restaurants, and a thriving community. Of the 900+ acres, approximately one third is useable fields and the remainder in forest, transected by several streams. The land is populated by wonderful wildlife including large populations of deer, partridge and wild turkey, which have been sparingly managed for 15 years, making the property appealing to both conservationist and hunter. In addition, the hiking, running and cross country skiing trails are exceptional. There is valuable timber on the property that is periodically cut and thinned according to a forest management plan formulated a decade ago. There is 4,000+ feet of road frontage on two roads at either end of the valley, allowing for multiple uses and privacy. The offering includes nine parcels, a charmingly sited farm house in need of renovation, and se
❮❯Closed$1,500,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
390 Porath Road
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Middlefield NY Home for Sale
An oasis of calm and tranquility. Discreetly setback from the road, beautiful and spacious both inside and out. This 1972 contemporary ranch features 4 bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths, and a 600+/- sq ft studio. A spacious open floor plan features a well-designed kitchen with custom maple cabinets and newer stainless-steel appliances. There is an uninterrupted flow between the living, dining area, and kitchen. A pellet stove keeps the dining room and kitchen cozy. While in the living room or family room the focus is on the fireplace during winter months, and the gentle breeze from the garden is enjoyed in summer. Slider doors off the family room lead to an inviting deck which provides a screened-in room, hot tub, and patio. Separate wings, each with two bedrooms and a full bathroom, are at opposite ends of the home allowing privacy for family members and guests. The North wing provides 2 bedrooms and a bathroom with soaking tub. On the South wing, you will find 2 bedrooms, bathroom, laundry, and a sitting area/office. All the bedrooms have ample closet space. There is a finished 22x24 room on the lower level which would make a great family room, playroom, exercise room, craft room, or guest
❮❯Closed$570,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3090 sqft
347 County Hwy 52
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Springfield NY Home for Sale
GRACIOUS LIVING WITH SPECTACULAR VIEWS OVERLOOKING OTSEGO LAKE. This well appointed home was doubled in size in 2010 with the addition of a second story, library and carriage house. Extraordinary lake views can be enjoyed from the added first and second story 10' wide porches that span the full length of the house. Entering the first floor, you will find a formal living room, modern kitchen with breakfast room, a large library/dining room with fireplace - perfect spaces for entertaining. A first floor bedroom and full bath make one floor living possible. The second story has a master suite and a large guest room each with its own private luxury bath and access to the upper veranda. A shared sitting room is connected to a laundry room and wet bar. A large two-car detached carriage house has second floor storage and a guest apartment. This special space has a living room area, four bunk beds, kitchen, 3/4 bath, washer & dryer, split system air-conditioner/heat pump, and a backup electric boiler radiant floor heat. The grounds have been beautifully landscaped with perennials, birch trees and open spaces for entertaining. Approximately 1.5 acres of the property are wooded and border a
❮❯Closed$549,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2554 sqft
170 County Highway 27
Springfield, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Land for Sale
8+ ACRES of picturesque open rolling land with a two-silo 3,600 square foot dairy barn with milk house. Also on the property is a 3-bay 26x42 garage and 4-bay 32x56 pole barn. Buildings are in need of some repair.
❮❯Closed$55,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
4689 State Highway 51
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Middlefield NY Home for Sale
In a Private setting, just Steps from the Cooperstown Village Line. Walkable to the Clark Sports Center, Bassett Medical Center, and Main Street but in a wonderful hidden spot not visible from the road. With nearly 4,000 square feet of living space, this 5 bedroom, 5 bath home features an inviting kitchen with custom cherry and maple cabinets, large island, double ovens, and cozy fireplace. Off the kitchen is a 3/4 bath, family room and laundry area. On the other side, the kitchen leads into a grand living room/dining room that was originally part of a historic house next door. This section of the house was moved to the current location in 1950 and features a fireplace, cherry floors, built-in bookshelves with window seats, and an original corner china cabinet. Upstairs are three bedrooms, two full baths, and a master suite with attached full bath. In 2013 the owners added an oversized, heated 3-car garage that connects to the home through a large mudroom with radiant floor heat. On the second floor of the garage is a great space with a bedroom, bathroom, and a large living area with french doors leading to a private back deck. This area is plumbed for a kitchen and washer/dryer ho
❮❯Closed$625,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 5 ba
- 3693 sqft
214 County Hwy 52
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
This charming cottage won't last long. Located conveniently within walking distance of the hamlet of Fly Creek and only a four mile drive to Cooperstown, the house is perfect for a small family or investment income. The home has been well maintained and cared for by the current owners. Recent updates include new appliances, carpeting on the second floor, and a new water system. The first floor includes a living room, dining room, eat-in kitchen, bedroom, and a half bath with stacked washer & dryer. Upstairs is a large landing currently used as an office area, a walk-in closet, and master bedroom with attached bath. Hardwood floors and nice woodwork details throughout the first floor. A comfortable sitting porch overlooks the back yard and cider mill ponds. Property includes a two-car detached garage.
❮❯Closed$139,000 Closed- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1080 sqft
940 County Highway 26
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Middlefield NY Residential Lease
Charming, renovated cottage for rent only a few miles from the Village of Cooperstown and Bassett Hospital. Enjoy nature & complete privacy. House is efficiently laid out with an entry porch, mudroom, living/dining room, kitchen, large bedroom, full bath and sleeping/reading loft. Available fully-furnished or bring your own furniture. Tenant responsible for utilities. Heat is propane fired hot air plus wood stove. No pets & No smoking. Available immediately. Landlord open to short-term leases.
❮❯Closed$850 Closed- 1 bds
- 1 ba
- 905 sqft
279 Blacks Road
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Middlefield NY Commercial Lease
PROFESSIONAL OFFICE SPACE available on the second floor of this well-maintained, centrally located building in the Village of Cooperstown. One block from Main Street, this building is situated in the revitalized Railroad Avenue district which includes other offices & retail businesses. Rent includes utilities, bathroom access, and basic cleaning service. Parking spot subject to availability. Tenant responsible for their own internet/WIFI. Security deposit, references, and electronic transfer of monthly rent is required. In addition to the available office space, the landlord is also offering VIRTUAL OFFICE PACKAGES available for $150 per month. The package includes a commercial business MAILING ADDRESS in the Village of Cooperstown; CONFERENCE ROOM SPACE available by reservation for Virtual Office Clients starting at $30 per day. Please contact agent for more information.
❮❯Closed$350 Closed- bds
- 1 ba
- 143 sqft
25 Railroad Avenue
Middlefield, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
LOVELY NEWER HOME IN DESIRABLE COOPERSTOWN VILLAGE LOCATION. Come sit and relax on the deep inviting front porch and enjoy views of Otsego Lake and the golfers on Leatherstocking Golf Course. Upon entering the home one is immediately struck by the wonderful natural light and welcoming open floor plan. A large living room with gas fireplace and custom built-ins flows directly into the dining area and kitchen. A door and many windows lead from the dining room to a private flagstone patio off the side of the house. The open floor plan and outdoor space on this floor are perfect for entertaining. A large master suite, powder room with laundry, and two-car attached garage complete this floor. Upstairs are two bedrooms and another full bath. Take advantage of over 400sf of unfinished space on the second floor and a dry basement with 8 ft. ceilings. This well built home is fully insulated and heated and cooled by a high efficiency propane system. In pristine condition and freshly painted this home is ready for a quick move-in. Walking distance to Main Street, Bassett Medical Center, and the museums.
❮❯Closed$439,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1940 sqft
105 Lake Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Beautiful, well-maintained Victorian home three blocks from Main Street. Located conveniently in the center of town - easy walking distance to schools, stores, and Bassett Medical Center. All original woodwork, parquet floors, and fixtures. The welcoming front porch leads to an entry hall with a beautiful staircase and French doors that lead into double parlors with a propane fireplace. A large dining room with original double-sided china cabinet and bay window is perfect for entertaining. Off the dining room is a charming kitchen with double ovens, lots of cabinet space, and original tin ceiling. A side enclosed porch leads out to a pleasant fenced backyard and patio with perennials. Second floor boasts a nice wide landing, a sleep porch/office, four bedrooms, full bath, and back staircase. A large attic with full size windows that bring in tons of light would be a wonderful space to renovate into a family room or play space. Winner of the village's 2010 Historical Preservation award.
❮❯Closed$385,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2638 sqft
81 Chestnut Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Idyllic Setting & Views! This property is located on nearly 105 acres just on the edge of the hamlet of Fly Creek and only four miles to Cooperstown. Set well off the road with 3,000' of road frontage, the house includes 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a nice family room addition with fireplace, and an attached 3-car garage. If a first floor bedroom is needed, a large den with two closets off the living room could easily be used as a 4th bedroom. The home has been well cared for over the years and was just painted in 2018. The views from the home are beautiful. French doors at the end of the living room open to a spectacular wide southern valley view and off the back of the house is a peaceful view of the large pond and woods. Across the pond is a small rustic cabin that sits nestled on the edge of the woods. A babbling stream flows from the pond down along side a large barn. With a separate entrance and driveway, this barn is perfect for a new owner who needs space for a business, equipment, or even horses. One end of the barn is currently used for cold storage accessed by 2 large sliding doors. The center of the building has 2 oversized bays with concrete heated floors and an office. A
❮❯Closed$415,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 2074 sqft
1043 County Highway 26
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
COMPLETE RENOVATION! Built in 1900, completely redone in 2018, top to bottom!! High-end kitchen complete with granite counter-tops, stainless steel appliances, under mount double sink, wood cabinets, a huge island, ceramic tile floors and plenty of lighting & storage! Solid hardwood hickory floors and an open floor plan perfect for entertaining on the 1st floor. The bonus sunroom is fully insulated and could be anything you wish from a killer mudroom to a 2nd living room. Frist floor living is possible, large 1st floor bedroom with en-suite bathroom. The 2nd floor has 2 bedrooms each with huge walk-in closets and lots of natural light. All bathrooms have tile floors and marble counter-tops. Everything is new in this home from the windows to the can lights in the ceiling and everything in between. Located in the hamlet of Toddsville 5 minutes to Cooperstown. A large yard, separate new 2 car garage and a brand new blacktop driveway. This house is MOVE-IN ready!! Opportunities like this don't come around often!
❮❯Closed$342,500 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1987 sqft
197 County Highway 26
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Natasha L. Selover - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
Fly Creek Victorian, 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 2 Car/2 Story Garage/Barn on Large Village Lot. This lovely home is open & spacious with eat-in kitchen/newer LG appliances, dining room, living room/Harmon pellet stove, den/office, bathroom & first floor laundry. Second floor bath with walk-in tiled shower, along with three exceptionally good sized bedrooms and beautiful wood floors. The insulated walkout basement has workshop & great storage space. Metal roofing, updated utilities and a Generac generator for those unexpected power outages! Convenient barbequing & meals on the covered side patio with durable Trex decking. This home and property has been respectfully maintained since 1885 and is located just a few steps away from the Fly Creek General Store & Post Office in Cooperstown Schools. $219,900.
❮❯Closed$219,900 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1860 sqft
217 Cemetery Road
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Katherine Fistrowicz - Howard Hanna -
NY Home for Sale
Custom designed home only two miles from the Village of Cooperstown. Many fine details throughout including oversized Marvin windows, 9-zone radiant floor heat, custom built kitchen cabinets, soapstone & granite counters, cherry wood floors, glass panel french doors, and much more. Two master suites - one on the first floor and one on the second - allows flexibility if a first floor bedroom is preferred or use as an in-law suite or guest space. The comfortable kitchen flows directly into a large living room with cathedral ceiling and propane stove. Glass doors lead from this room into a heated four-season sunporch. Tons of natural light throughout. A full size basement with high ceilings could easily be turned into a great play space or media room. A wonderful flat yard is perfect for outdoor play or relax on the deck in the hot tub. The property consists of approximately 4 acres of open space and 6 acres of light woods with plenty of hard wood. Red Creek runs across the rear of the property on the west side. Enjoy privacy and space in a desirable and convenient location.
❮❯Closed$465,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2590 sqft
287 Pink Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Move right in to this SPACIOUS village home centrally located only two blocks from the school, Bassett Medical Center, and the Clark Sports Center. RECENT RENOVATIONS include a NEW KITCHEN with beautiful cabinets, Quartz counters, two pantries and stainless steel appliances, and THREE COMPLETELY NEW BATHROOMS. The home is perfect for a family with five well sized bedrooms, two full baths, and a laundry room on the second floor. On the first floor is a mudroom, kitchen/dining room, living room, and den. A charming front porch and large patio in the back are nice spots to relax and entertain. A deep private sunny yard tucked away behind the large barn is perfect for play or gardening. A separate rear entrance on the first floor leads to a wonderful THREE ROOM RENTAL UNIT with two bedrooms, a full bath and kitchenette area. This unit is licensed for SHORT TERM (or long term) RENTALS which makes it easy for the new owner who wants to live in the home but also take advantage of the rental income. If someone chooses not to continue renting, this unit can be used as guest space or easily combined with the rest of the first floor to make an even more spacious single family home. THIS WELL-
❮❯Closed$369,000 Closed- 5 bds
- 3 ba
- 2320 sqft
66 Susquehanna Avenue
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Redesigned home on 3.2 acres offers total privacy! This efficient and updated home has contemporary touches and three bedrooms including a master suite with recently added master bath. Kitchen has an eat-in dining area and living room has hardwood floors and sliding doors to an oversized deck for outdoor entertaining. The spacious deck faces southwest and has wonderful views. The walk out first floor (ground) level has plenty of open space, dry storage, laundry area and can be finished for a family room or additional bedrooms. New roof and furnace in 2007. Driveway is completely paved. This well maintained and secluded property is only 5 miles to the village of Cooperstown.
❮❯Closed$189,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1220 sqft
172 Fish Road
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
THREE BEDROOM VILLAGE HOME - EASY WALK TO STORES AND SCHOOL. Located on a corner lot with a two car garage. House features a nice covered side patio, front sun porch, large living room with pellet stove, eat-in kitchen, and three bedrooms. The back entrance opens into an oversized mudroom/laundry room. Two blocks to Main Street.
❮❯Closed$175,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1397 sqft
56 Grove Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
FOUR BEDROOM VILLAGE COLONIAL - $100K BELOW ASSESSED VALUE. This centrally located home in need of renovation has great bones and hardwood floors throughout. Charming original features include the front fanlight window, French doors, built-in corner china cabinet, and fireplace. Two car detached garage with a nice yard. Walking distance to Bassett Medical Center, Clark Sports Center, Baseball Hall of Fame, Cooperstown schools and restaurants. PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD AS-IS.
❮❯Closed$175,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1924 sqft
22 Beaver Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Rare opportunity to own a 60 acre homestead only one mile from the Village of Cooperstown. Property is secluded and includes a wonderfully sited location with a 2,000sf ranch style house, a large equipment storage barn, workshop with wood stove and 2nd floor storage, and a beautiful meadow with apple trees, a view over the hills and a peaceful pond. The remaining 50+ acres are wooded and perfect for hikers and hunters. There is a deeded Conservation Easement on the property which protects the land from future development. A two acre envelope around the house and outbuildings is free from building restrictions. A copy of the Conservation Easement is available upon request. PLEASE NOTE: the house is in need of renovation. Property is being sold AS-IS and is priced below Fair Market Value. The owners are in the process of sub-dividing off a four acre parcel along Cornish Hill Road that will be sold separately.
❮❯Closed$259,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 1 ba
- 1804 sqft
374 County Highway 52
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
Otsego NY Home for Sale
FOUR BEDROOM COUNTRY HOME WITH GUEST HOUSE IN A PRIVATE, BUCOLIC 15+/- ACRE SETTING ONLY FIVE MILES TO COOPERSTOWN. The original home was built circa 1875 and has been added on to over the years. A lovely living room with fir beams was added in 1895 and in 1995 the house was expanded to include a formal dining room and conservatory. Both the living room and conservatory have great south facing windows that let in lots of light. Upstairs are four bedrooms, a full bath with laundry, and custom hallway closets. Outside is a nice front sitting porch and back deck off the living room. Sit on the deck and enjoy the intimate view of the hills, apple trees, stream and fenced pastures complete with a run-in shelter once used for horses. A detached two car garage with second floor storage also houses a 1,000sf guest house. A separate side entrance leads into a large living room with full bath. Upstairs is a two-sided sleeping loft with lots of under the eaves storage and views over the pastures and lawn. The space is perfect for guests or rent out for extra income. The list price includes a contiguous .61 acre lot to the east of the garage. Would make a nice spot for a barn or another outbui
❮❯Closed$365,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 1900 sqft
192 Tripp Hill Road
Otsego, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
This Queen Anne Victorian home has been meticulously restored and renovated over the past two years. Located on over half an acre in the center of the village of Cooperstown, within sight of Doubleday Field, this historic home is within easy walking distance of Main Street, Otsego Lake, and the schools. Be the first to live in this warm and inviting home since it's renovation was complete. Enjoy all the comforts of a modern house including a new kitchen and new bathrooms (one with a steam shower) while still be able to appreciate all the restored original details. These include beautiful hardwood floors, original bullseye molding throughout, French doors, stained glass windows, original hardware, a grand front staircase with wood paneling, a back staircase, four fireplaces with original mantels, and an original floor-to-ceiling kitchen cupboard. On the exterior, the home has been freshly painted, the cedar shake roof repaired, and all the porches have been rebuilt including a wonderful double side porch. The property includes a carriage barn with original horse stalls and 1,000sf of usable space on the second floor. Behind the barn is .3 acres of land just waiting for someone's ima
❮❯Closed$635,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2880 sqft
17 Elm Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Home for Sale
Custom built home by the owner and meticulously maintained over 49 years, this lovely home sits on 1.90 acres with majestic pine trees, black walnut tree grove and a stocked pond. Two car garage with storage. There is an additional garage 24x24 feet fully insulated with electric and great potential for studio or workshop space. This 4 bedroom house has much to offer: extensive renovations undertaken in 2002 include kitchen renovation, 2 1/2 bath updates, installation of central air conditioning, new propane heating system and new windows. Large deck with an electric retractable awning. Cooperstown schools. Convenient location and only minutes to the village.
❮❯Closed$295,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2748 sqft
959 County Highway 33
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
CIRCA 1830 GREEK REVIVAL HISTORIC VILLAGE HOME located half a block from Main Street and less than half a block from Otsego Lake. Many of the home's original features remain intact, including wide plank floors throughout, original doors, woodwork, and a built-in ceiling height glass front china cabinet. A large welcoming front porch with stately columns leads into a lovely front entry hall with twin living rooms on either side. This wonderfully preserved home offers modern comforts while providing a charming glimpse into the past with three bedrooms, including a first floor master suite, three baths, an office or den with built-in bookshelves, and a large eat-in kitchen with sunny breakfast area and gas fireplace. The house sits on a very nice, flat 1/3 acre lot that was recently tastefully fenced in and landscaped. All in the heart of Cooperstown village!
❮❯Closed$375,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 2304 sqft
6 Chestnut Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties -
NY Home for Sale
Delightful family home in the Village of Cooperstown. This three-bedroom two-bathroom home features a welcoming kitchen with a large picture window overlooking an inviting and private backyard. New appliances have been added to the updated kitchen which leads into a large pantry and laundry. A bathroom with a walk-in shower has been added to the first floor. French doors connect the living room and den/office. The dining room has a lovely built in china cabinet. Morning coffee or breakfast can be taken on the three-season screened-in porch which sits just off the kitchen. Upstairs is a full bathroom, three good size bedrooms with closets, the master bedroom has a large walk-in closet plus a walk-up attic. This home is situated in a convenient 'walk to everything' location.
❮❯Closed$249,000 Closed- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1702 sqft
53 Susquehanna Ave
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Denise Page-LaCava - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Commercial Sale for Sale
THE 1819 HOUSE with additional 4+ acre parcel. This historical Greek Revival features 6 bedrooms in the main house ranging from 300-400sf each and a charming rustic basement tavern with fireplace, pub booths, and an inviting bar. A spacious living room with original fireplace is a lovely spot for entertaining with doors leading to a large covered blue stone patio and nice flat yard. Another feature of the property is the lovely 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath carriage house cottage that sits across the driveway from the main building. Inside is a large living room, kitchen, dining room with wood stove, and an inviting private back porch. Upstairs is a generous sitting room and 3 large bedrooms, 2 with attached baths. There are two garages on the property, one fully enclosed with two bays and one open with 3 bays. A greenhouse with a small stone shed attached would make a great smoke house. This property has housed many successful businesses in the past including a hops farm, doctor's office, and a restaurant. For the past 15 years, the entire property has been rented on a weekly basis during the summer months grossing over $100k during the 13 week Dreams Park season. Before that, the property
❮❯Closed$599,000 Closed- bds
- 0 ba
- sqft
207 Greenough Road
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC -
NY Residential Income for Sale
Main Street building for sale in the heart of historic Cooperstown, just steps from the Baseball Hall of Fame and Otsego Lake. The property has housed many successful businesses over the years including restaurants, offices, a furniture/home goods store, and most recently a popular restaurant and cocktail bar. Restaurant/Retail Space: 2,700 sq. ft. The street level includes a fully equipped commercial kitchen, a dining room and bar area, 2 handicap accessible guest bathrooms, a private 2nd floor dining room and lounge, and a small rear patio. The basement, accessed from the kitchen, is used for storage, extra refrigerators, and a wine cellar. Residential Space (2nd & 3rd floors): 2,548 sq. ft. Recent improvements to the upper two floors of the building created two full floor 1,200+ sq. ft. apartments. Each apartment includes two bedrooms, kitchen, bath, laundry, and plenty of living space. Additionally, the top floor apartment has a large private 600 sq. ft. roof terrace. This is a prime opportunity for someone looking to open a restaurant, wine/cocktail bar, or other eatery and who wants to live on the premises and still bring in rental income from the other apartment. Or purchase
❮❯Closed$675,000 Closed- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 5254 sqft
149 Main Street
Unknown, NY
Listing by: Amy Stack - Stack-Page Properties LLC
SERVICE AREAS
Popular Search Types in Middlefield
- Single Family Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 12 listings
- Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 10 listings
- Homes with Acreage for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 10 listings
- Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 8 listings
- Luxury Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 7 listings
- Historic Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 5 listings
- 3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY - 5 listings
Neighborhoods & Subdivisions in Otsego
Popular Search Types in Otsego
- Single Family Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY - 11 listings
- Luxury Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY - 8 listings
- 3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY - 7 listings
- Historic Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY - 6 listings
- Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Otsego, NY - 5 listings
- Homes with Acreage for Sale in Otsego, NY - 4 listings
- Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Otsego, NY - 4 listings
Nearby Locations
Communities
Nearby Zips
- 13491 Homes For Sale
- 13439 Homes For Sale
- 13357 Homes For Sale
- 13326 Homes For Sale
- 13340 Homes For Sale
- 13350 Homes For Sale
- 13501 Homes For Sale
- 13413 Homes For Sale
- 13820 Homes For Sale
- 12155 Homes For Sale
- 13502 Homes For Sale
- 13320 Homes For Sale
- 13825 Homes For Sale
- 13323 Homes For Sale
- 13460 Homes For Sale
- 13365 Homes For Sale
- 13492 Homes For Sale
- 12197 Homes For Sale
- 13346 Homes For Sale
- 13339 Homes For Sale
Nearby Cities
- German Flatts, NY Homes for Sale
- New Hartford, NY Homes for Sale
- Utica, NY Homes for Sale
- Oneonta, NY Homes for Sale
- Kirkland, NY Homes for Sale
- Whitestown, NY Homes for Sale
- Rome, NY Homes for Sale
- Oneida, NY Homes for Sale
- Gloversville, NY Homes for Sale
- Sullivan, NY Homes for Sale
- Manlius, NY Homes for Sale
- Amsterdam, NY Homes for Sale
- De Witt, NY Homes for Sale
- Cicero, NY Homes for Sale
- Binghamton, NY Homes for Sale