Realty.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Advertise
  • Referral
  1. Home
  2. NY
  3. Old Forge
  4. Benn Realty

Benn Realty

5946 State Rt 28 Po Box 188

Old Forge, NY

Team Members

Maryann Nelson

David Bradt

Audrey Strutynski

James Foley

William Morris

Elaine Nelson

Audrey Strutynski

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Listings & Recent Sales (116)

Active Rental Sold

For Sale (7)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 0 Deer Meadows
0 Deer Meadows Webb, NY
-, 0 Baths
$170,000
Picture of 145 Hollywood Road
145 Hollywood Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 830 Sqft.
3 Beds, 1 Bath
$359,000
Picture of 4044 Norton Road
4044 Norton Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1084 Sqft.
4 Beds, 1 Bath
$294,700
Picture of 8875 Wheelock Drive
8875 Wheelock Drive Boonville, NY
Living Area: 1064 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$405,000
Picture of 177 S Shore Acres Road
177 S Shore Acres Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 5679 Sqft.
5 Beds, 4 Baths
$1,600,000
Picture of Moehs Road
Moehs Road Webb, NY
-, 0 Baths
$190,000
Picture of 103 Pawnee Drive
103 Pawnee Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: 1216 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$735,000

Sold (109)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of 000 Fletcher Road
000 Fletcher Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $210,000 Selling
Picture of 343 Petrie Road
343 Petrie Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 3053 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $845,000 Listing
Picture of 468 Okara Road E
468 Okara Road E Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $60,000 Selling
Picture of 2175 Big Moose Rd. Road
2175 Big Moose Rd. Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1066 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $210,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Tamarack Drive
0 Tamarack Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $285,000 Selling
Picture of 236 Moose River Trail
236 Moose River Trail Webb, NY
Living Area: 744 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $129,900 Selling
Picture of 525 State Route 28
525 State Route 28 Inlet, NY
Living Area: 2064 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $799,000 Listing
Picture of 373 Hollywood Road
373 Hollywood Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 800 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $525,000 Selling
Picture of 4018 Lakeview Road
4018 Lakeview Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1104 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $249,000 Selling
Picture of 3015 Lighthouse Loop
3015 Lighthouse Loop Forestport, NY
Living Area: 968 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $129,900 Listing
Picture of 129 Riverside Drive
129 Riverside Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: 1484 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $379,000 Selling
Picture of 108 Watson Road
108 Watson Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1616 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $310,000 Listing
Picture of 236 S Shore Road
236 S Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1120 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $325,000 Listing
Picture of 167 Eagle Point Rd
167 Eagle Point Rd Webb, NY
Living Area: 2271 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $924,500 Listing
Picture of 122 Deer Meadows Road
122 Deer Meadows Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 2100 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $655,000 Listing
Picture of 2005 Totem Trail West W
2005 Totem Trail West W Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1765 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $297,000 Selling
Picture of 108 Wintergreen Point Road
108 Wintergreen Point Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1584 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $825,900 Selling
Picture of 246 Petrie Road
246 Petrie Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 609 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $150,000 Selling
Picture of 11352 Meyers Hill Road
11352 Meyers Hill Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1344 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $379,000 Selling
Picture of 186 Tuttle Road
186 Tuttle Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 2270 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $499,000 Listing
Picture of 00 S Shore Road
00 S Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $99,000 Listing
Picture of 2910 State Route 28
2910 State Route 28 Webb, NY
Living Area: 9394 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $799,000 Listing
Picture of 154 Gull Rock Bay Road
154 Gull Rock Bay Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1776 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,300,000 Colisting
Picture of 5521 State Route 28
5521 State Route 28 Webb, NY
Living Area: 4264 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $249,900 Listing
Picture of 6034 Schieferstine Rd.
6034 Schieferstine Rd. Westmoreland, NY
Living Area: 1643 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $229,000 Listing
Picture of 185 Spruce Drive
185 Spruce Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: 720 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $369,000 Listing
Picture of 00 Spruce Drive
00 Spruce Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $129,000 Listing
Picture of 8671 Effley Dam Rd.
8671 Effley Dam Rd. Lewis, NY
Living Area: 1706 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $524,900 Listing
Picture of 8088 Capron
8088 Capron Forestport, NY
Living Area: 952 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $465,000 Selling
Picture of 10887 Richardson Road
10887 Richardson Road Remsen, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $895,000 Selling
Picture of 142 Mallard Bay
142 Mallard Bay Webb, NY
Living Area: 2096 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,100,000 Selling
Picture of 00 Nys Rt 233 Highway
00 Nys Rt 233 Highway Westmoreland, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $179,900 Listing
Picture of 124 Eagle Creek Road
124 Eagle Creek Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 2981 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,100,000 Listing
Picture of 000 Cohasset Point Road
000 Cohasset Point Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $79,000 Listing
Picture of 0 S South Shore Rd. Road
0 S South Shore Rd. Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $49,000 Selling
Picture of 165 Taxi Way
165 Taxi Way Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $172,500 Selling
Picture of 00000 Highland Terrace W
00000 Highland Terrace W Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $79,000 Selling
Picture of 640 NYS Route 28
640 NYS Route 28 Inlet, NY
Living Area: 1423 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $189,000 Selling
Picture of 2158 Big Moose Road
2158 Big Moose Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1038 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $135,000 Listing
Picture of 656 Hollywood Road
656 Hollywood Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1458 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $415,000 Listing
Picture of 1112 Bear Creek Road
1112 Bear Creek Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 609 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $85,000 Selling
Picture of 101 Twitchell Inn Road
101 Twitchell Inn Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 794 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $229,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Iroquois Road
0 Iroquois Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $35,000 Selling
Picture of 212 S South Shore Rd. Road
212 S South Shore Rd. Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 596 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $89,900 Listing
Picture of 28 Wilbur Road
28 Wilbur Road New Hartford, NY
Living Area: 1920 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $149,900 Listing
Picture of 7387 Wildcat Rd
7387 Wildcat Rd Lyonsdale, NY
Living Area: 1123 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $369,000 Listing
Picture of 335 Petrie Road
335 Petrie Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 852 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $745,000 Listing
Picture of 4 Ealy Avenue
4 Ealy Avenue New Hartford, NY
Living Area: 1155 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $169,900 Listing
Picture of 9 Uncas Road
9 Uncas Road Inlet, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $225,000 Selling
Picture of 122 Fern Avenue
122 Fern Avenue Webb, NY
Living Area: 1860 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $440,000 Listing
Picture of 8798 Kiwanis Road
8798 Kiwanis Road Lee, NY
Living Area: 1300 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $59,900 Selling
Picture of 116 West Avenue
116 West Avenue Webb, NY
Living Area: 1462 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $525,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Moose River Road
0 Moose River Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $75,000 Listing
Picture of 141 Erwin Street
141 Erwin Street Boonville, NY
Living Area: 1480 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $125,000 Selling
Picture of 8554 Rome Westernville Rd #1 Road
8554 Rome Westernville Rd #1 Road Rome, NY
Living Area: 2135 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $299,900 Selling
Picture of 423 Hollywood Road
423 Hollywood Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 600 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $450,000 Selling
Picture of 596 S Shore Road
596 S Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1125 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $669,000 Selling
Picture of 159 Newell Road
159 Newell Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1300 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $789,000 Selling
Picture of 1946 Harmony Lane
1946 Harmony Lane Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1828 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $289,000 Selling
Picture of 10807 Prospect Depot Road
10807 Prospect Depot Road Trenton, NY
Living Area: 2690 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $256,000 Selling
Picture of 149 Martin Road
149 Martin Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 320 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $259,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Judson Road
0 Judson Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1100 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $4,900,000 Selling
Picture of 112 Riverview Terrace
112 Riverview Terrace Webb, NY
Living Area: 2552 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $715,000 Listing
Picture of 9488 Christmas Drive
9488 Christmas Drive Croghan, NY
Living Area: 1800 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $559,900 Selling
Picture of 3125 Canal Street
3125 Canal Street Leyden, NY
Living Area: 2160 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $149,000 Selling
Picture of 2761 State Route 28
2761 State Route 28 Webb, NY
Living Area: 8160 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $700,000 Selling
Picture of 00 Andover Avenue
00 Andover Avenue New Hartford, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $20,000 Listing
Picture of 8875 Wheelock Drive
8875 Wheelock Drive Boonville, NY
Living Area: 1064 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $374,900 Selling
Picture of 139 Forest Lane
139 Forest Lane Webb, NY
Living Area: 1476 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $520,000 Selling
Picture of 322 Long Lake Road
322 Long Lake Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1167 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $499,500 Selling
Picture of 3020 Wall Street
3020 Wall Street Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1596 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $67,500 Selling
Picture of 135 Cedarnoll Drive
135 Cedarnoll Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: 1678 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $750,000 Selling
Picture of 373 Mohawk Drive East
373 Mohawk Drive East Webb, NY
Living Area: 1032 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $259,000 Selling
Picture of 123 S Shore Road
123 S Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 8354 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,275,000 Selling
Picture of 251 Petrie Road
251 Petrie Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 5217 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,050,000 Colisting
Picture of 331 S Shore Road
331 S Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1568 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $364,500 Listing
Picture of 2973 State Route 28
2973 State Route 28 Webb, NY
Living Area: 4352 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $545,000 Selling
Picture of 137 Bayside Drive
137 Bayside Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: 2230 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $785,000 Listing
Picture of 171 Fletcher Road
171 Fletcher Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1050 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $599,000 Selling
Picture of 5510 State Route 28
5510 State Route 28 Webb, NY
Living Area: 2060 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $209,000 Selling
Picture of 411 S Shore Acres Road
411 S Shore Acres Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1913 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,260,000 Selling
Picture of 213 Summit Street
213 Summit Street Boonville, NY
Living Area: 1762 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $99,900 Selling
Picture of 102 Gray Lake Road
102 Gray Lake Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1316 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $219,000 Listing
Picture of 656 Hollywood Road Unit #1
656 Hollywood Road Unit #1 Webb, NY
Living Area: 1080 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $329,000 Listing
Picture of 141 Garmon Avenue
141 Garmon Avenue Webb, NY
Living Area: 3282 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $299,900 Listing
Picture of 32 South Shore Road
32 South Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $58,900 Selling
Picture of 1593 Big Moose Road
1593 Big Moose Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 972 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $55,000 Listing
Picture of 122 Lake Trail
122 Lake Trail Webb, NY
Living Area: 787 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $119,000 Listing
Picture of 108 Covey Road
108 Covey Road Herkimer, NY
Living Area: 2567 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $319,000 Selling
Picture of 184 Lone Pine Road N
184 Lone Pine Road N Webb, NY
Living Area: 1706 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $424,600 Selling
Picture of 165 Pine Acres Road
165 Pine Acres Road Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $275,000 Selling
Picture of 227 Tuttle Road
227 Tuttle Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 3228 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $2,250,000 Selling
Picture of 17 Frog Pond Lane
17 Frog Pond Lane Forestport, NY
Living Area: 468 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $149,000 Selling
Picture of 2979 State Rt. 28
2979 State Rt. 28 Webb, NY
Living Area: 1530 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $289,000 Listing
Picture of 110 Browns Tract Road
110 Browns Tract Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 840 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $169,000 Selling
Picture of 140 Forest Trail
140 Forest Trail Webb, NY
Living Area: 1552 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $189,000 Selling
Picture of 1118 Moose River Tract
1118 Moose River Tract Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1260 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $350,000 Selling
Picture of 250 S Shore Road
250 S Shore Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 840 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $164,900 Selling
Picture of 00 Mallard Bay
00 Mallard Bay Webb, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $389,900 Selling
Picture of 15 Uncas Road
15 Uncas Road Inlet, NY
Living Area: 2700 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $439,900 Selling
Picture of 37 Deerwood Dr.
37 Deerwood Dr. Inlet, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
01/02/2026 $65,000 Selling
Picture of 233 Joy Tract Road
233 Joy Tract Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 420 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $80,000 Selling
Picture of 15 Uncas Rd.
15 Uncas Rd. Inlet, NY
Living Area: 2700 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $439,900 Selling
Picture of 103 Leanto Lane
103 Leanto Lane Webb, NY
Living Area: 470 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $140,000 Colisting
Picture of 105 Garmon Avenue
105 Garmon Avenue Webb, NY
Living Area: 2264 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $740,000 Listing
Picture of 182 Seneca Road
182 Seneca Road Webb, NY
Living Area: 1268 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $289,000 Selling
Picture of 2020 Tamarack Road
2020 Tamarack Road Forestport, NY
Living Area: 1152 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $325,000 Colisting
Picture of 110 Limekiln Lake Road
110 Limekiln Lake Road Inlet, NY
Living Area: 2534 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $335,000 Selling
Picture of 119 Woodland Drive
119 Woodland Drive Webb, NY
Living Area: 2444 Sqft.
01/02/2026 $1,150,000 Listing

Work together on Realty.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Webb, NY
Forestport, NY
Boonville, NY
Inlet, NY
Westmoreland, NY
Lewis, NY
Remsen, NY
New Hartford, NY
Lyonsdale, NY
Lee, NY
Rome, NY
Trenton, NY
Croghan, NY
Leyden, NY
Herkimer, NY

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Webb, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Webb, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Webb, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Webb, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Boonville, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Boonville, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Boonville, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Boonville, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Boonville, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Boonville, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Boonville, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Boonville, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Boonville, NY
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Boonville, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Westmoreland, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Remsen, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Remsen, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Remsen, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Remsen, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in New Hartford, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in New Hartford, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in New Hartford, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Lee, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Lee, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Lee, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Lee, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Lee, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Lee, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lee, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Lee, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lee, NY
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Lee, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Rome, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Rome, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Rome, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Rome, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rome, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Rome, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Rome, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Rome, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rome, NY
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Rome, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Herkimer, NY
Homes with Pools for Sale in Herkimer, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Herkimer, NY
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Herkimer, NY

  • Advertise
  • Affiliates
  • Property Records
  • Find an Agent
  • Careers
  • Blog

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Value
  • Commercial
  • Advertise
  • Referral

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing