Realty.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Advertise
  • Referral
  1. Home
  2. OH
  3. Lancaster
  4. Key Realty

Key Realty

539 E Main St

Lancaster, OH

Team Members

Kendra Landis

Elizabeth Warthman

Kimberly Cumbo

Karen Rotkis

Jay Mattlin

Jody Jubach

Cindy Collins

Stacy Holland

Lori Allen

Mindy Moll

Andrew Reliford

Hannah Robinson

Melinda Gillespie

Monica Evans

Jay Mattlin

Nicole Barker

Cindy Collins

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Listings & Recent Sales (58)

Active Rental Sold

For Sale (17)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 02 Oh-159
02 Oh-159 Amanda, OH
-, 0 Baths
$194,510
Picture of 03 Oh-159
03 Oh-159 Amanda, OH
-, 0 Baths
$219,420
Picture of 9271 Roley Road
9271 Roley Road Sugar Grove, OH
Living Area: 1140 Sqft.
2 Beds, 2 Baths
$495,000
Picture of 15817 Nickel Plate Road
15817 Nickel Plate Road Logan, OH
Living Area: 1260 Sqft.
2 Beds, 2 Baths
$926,541
Picture of 844 E Wheeling Street
844 E Wheeling Street Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1750 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$272,222
Picture of 00 Cincinnati-Zanesville Road SW
00 Cincinnati-Zanesville Road SW Stoutsville, OH
-, 0 Baths
$505,000
Picture of 2445 Columbus Lancaster Road NW lot 274
2445 Columbus Lancaster Road NW lot 274 Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1120 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$40,000
Picture of 213 High Street
213 High Street Roseville, OH
Living Area: 1184 Sqft.
2 Beds, 1 Bath
$154,900
Picture of 1540 Adak Avenue
1540 Adak Avenue Lima, OH
Living Area: 1731 Sqft.
4 Beds, 2 Baths
$285,000
Picture of 22913 Goose Creek Road
22913 Goose Creek Road South Bloomingville, OH
Living Area: 1792 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$439,900
Picture of 0 Hamburg Road SW
0 Hamburg Road SW Lancaster, OH
-, 0 Baths
$209,900
Picture of 4911 Jacklin Drive
4911 Jacklin Drive Lancaster, OH
-, 0 Baths
$299,999
Picture of 0 Hillside Avenue
0 Hillside Avenue Lancaster, OH
-, 0 Baths
$85,000
Picture of 13591 Jake Tom Road
13591 Jake Tom Road Logan, OH
Living Area: 1296 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$145,000
Picture of 1466 Sheridan Drive
1466 Sheridan Drive Lancaster, OH
-, 0 Baths
$527,000
Picture of 0 Jake Tom Road
0 Jake Tom Road Logan, OH
-, 0 Baths
$185,000
Picture of 26743 Morris Salem Road
26743 Morris Salem Road Circleville, OH
Living Area: 1960 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$369,900

Sold (41)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of 27072 Township Road 16J
27072 Township Road 16J McArthur, OH
Living Area: 2081 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $725,000 Listing
Picture of 6694 Brooks Miller Road
6694 Brooks Miller Road Circleville, OH
Living Area: 4545 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $649,900 Selling
Picture of 515 Clairbrook Avenue
515 Clairbrook Avenue Columbus, OH
Living Area: 1080 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $159,995 Listing
Picture of 133 N 2nd Street
133 N 2nd Street Zaleski, OH
Living Area: 1440 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $106,000 Listing
Picture of 01 Oh-159
01 Oh-159 Amanda, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/16/2026 $162,180 Listing
Picture of 64598 Frazee Lane
64598 Frazee Lane McArthur, OH
Living Area: 288 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $275,000 Selling
Picture of 24310 Shurtz Road
24310 Shurtz Road New Plymouth, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/16/2026 $49,900 Selling
Picture of 24312 Shurtz Road
24312 Shurtz Road New Plymouth, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/16/2026 $89,900 Selling
Picture of 6164 Heigle Road SW
6164 Heigle Road SW Amanda, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/16/2026 $349,900 Listing
Picture of 513 Ross Road SE
513 Ross Road SE Lancaster, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/16/2026 $40,000 Listing
Picture of 545 W Columbus Street
545 W Columbus Street Pickerington, OH
Living Area: 1254 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $250,000 Listing
Picture of 337 Timber Run Road
337 Timber Run Road Zanesville, OH
Living Area: 1925 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $340,000 Colisting
Picture of 578 N Market Street
578 N Market Street Logan, OH
Living Area: 1456 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $240,000 Selling
Picture of 4833 Gilhem Court
4833 Gilhem Court Columbus, OH
Living Area: 1558 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $293,000 Selling
Picture of 6754 Kristins Cove Lane
6754 Kristins Cove Lane Canal Winchester, OH
Living Area: 1444 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $274,900 Selling
Picture of 23862 Dunlap Road
23862 Dunlap Road Rockbridge, OH
Living Area: 1998 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $865,000 Listing
Picture of 73 N West Street
73 N West Street Thornville, OH
Living Area: 1344 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $249,999 Selling
Picture of 5933 Landings Pond Place 21
5933 Landings Pond Place 21 Grove City, OH
Living Area: 1138 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $269,900 Listing
Picture of 711 N High Street
711 N High Street Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1387 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $165,000 Selling
Picture of 1833 Autumn Drive
1833 Autumn Drive Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1612 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $334,900 Selling
Picture of 10673 US Highway 22 W
10673 US Highway 22 W Williamsport, OH
Living Area: 1294 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $270,000 Listing
Picture of 825 Edgehill Drive
825 Edgehill Drive Logan, OH
Living Area: 1232 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $354,900 Listing
Picture of 533 Douglas Drive
533 Douglas Drive Circleville, OH
Living Area: 1612 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $279,900 Selling
Picture of 12521 Jack Run Road
12521 Jack Run Road Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 2600 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $945,000 Selling
Picture of 441 E Locust Street
441 E Locust Street Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1560 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $170,000 Selling
Picture of 6920 Winchester Road NW
6920 Winchester Road NW Carroll, OH
Living Area: 2988 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $384,900 Selling
Picture of 530 W 6th Avenue
530 W 6th Avenue Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 936 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $165,000 Listing
Picture of 642 Lakeview Drive S
642 Lakeview Drive S Grove City, OH
Living Area: 1340 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $210,000 Selling
Picture of 12286 Goldenrod Lane
12286 Goldenrod Lane Amanda, OH
Living Area: 1808 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $310,000 Listing
Picture of 187 E Allen Street
187 E Allen Street Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1698 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $220,000 Selling
Picture of 816 N Pierce Avenue
816 N Pierce Avenue Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 896 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $70,000 Selling
Picture of 1232 Mary Francis Court
1232 Mary Francis Court Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1608 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $324,900 Listing
Picture of 2361 Calico Court
2361 Calico Court Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1270 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $319,900 Selling
Picture of 330 Yankeetown Street
330 Yankeetown Street Mount Sterling, OH
Living Area: 968 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $199,999 Listing
Picture of 2525 Hamburg Road SW
2525 Hamburg Road SW Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 3200 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $329,900 Listing
Picture of 830 N Broad Street
830 N Broad Street Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1858 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $250,000 Selling
Picture of 1332 N Columbus Street
1332 N Columbus Street Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 792 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $175,000 Selling
Picture of 1925 Holt Street
1925 Holt Street Thurston, OH
Living Area: 1708 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $280,000 Colisting
Picture of 542 Reese Avenue
542 Reese Avenue Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 672 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $50,000 Listing
Picture of 0 Trapp Lane
0 Trapp Lane Hopewell, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/16/2026 $195,000 Colisting
Picture of 23048 Chestnut Grove Road
23048 Chestnut Grove Road South Bloomingville, OH
Living Area: 2520 Sqft.
03/16/2026 $1,306,000 Selling

Work together on Realty.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Amanda, OH
Sugar Grove, OH
Logan, OH
Lancaster, OH
Stoutsville, OH
Roseville, OH
Lima, OH
South Bloomingville, OH
Circleville, OH
McArthur, OH
Columbus, OH
Zaleski, OH
New Plymouth, OH
Pickerington, OH
Zanesville, OH
Canal Winchester, OH
Rockbridge, OH
Thornville, OH
Grove City, OH
Williamsport, OH
Carroll, OH
Mount Sterling, OH
Thurston, OH
Hopewell, OH

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Amanda, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Amanda, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Sugar Grove, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Logan, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Logan, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Logan, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Lancaster, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Business for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
Single Story Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Roseville, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Roseville, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Roseville, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Roseville, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Lima, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Lima, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lima, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Lima, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Lima, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Lima, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lima, OH
Commercial Real Estate for Sale in Lima, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lima, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Lima, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Circleville, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Circleville, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Circleville, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Circleville, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in McArthur, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in McArthur, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in McArthur, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in McArthur, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Columbus, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Columbus, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Columbus, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Columbus, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Pickerington, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Pickerington, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Pickerington, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Pickerington, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Pickerington, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Pickerington, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Pickerington, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Pickerington, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Pickerington, OH
Open Houses in Pickerington, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Single Story Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Zanesville, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Zanesville, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Thornville, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Thornville, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Thornville, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Thornville, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Grove City, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Grove City, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Grove City, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Grove City, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Grove City, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Grove City, OH
Open Houses in Grove City, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Grove City, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Grove City, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Grove City, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Mount Sterling, OH

  • Advertise
  • Affiliates
  • Property Records
  • Find an Agent
  • Careers
  • Blog

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Value
  • Commercial
  • Advertise
  • Referral

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing