Realty.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Advertise
  • Referral
  1. Home
  2. WI
  3. Montello
  4. Cotter Realty Llc

Cotter Realty Llc

72 W Montello St

Montello, WI

Team Members

Nicole Cotter

Blake Vrechek

Gina Kloostra

Linda Cotter

Holly Rentmeester

Neil Evens

Pam Pahmeier

Kathleen Raddatz

Kaira Miller

Pam Pahmeier

Pamela Pahmeier

Anne Van Asten

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Listings & Recent Sales (88)

Active Rental Sold

For Sale (22)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 0.82 Ac Highway 22
0.82 Ac Highway 22 Montello, WI
-, 0 Baths
$95,000
Picture of 628 Cross Street
628 Cross Street Beloit, WI
-, 0 Baths
$375,000
Picture of Lot 15 Sandy Pines Court
Lot 15 Sandy Pines Court Redgranite, WI
-, 0 Baths
$11,700
Picture of Lot 22 Sandy Pines Court
Lot 22 Sandy Pines Court Redgranite, WI
-, 0 Baths
$13,310
Picture of LOT 73 Pine Drive
LOT 73 Pine Drive Montello, WI
-, 0 Baths
$24,500
Picture of 218 South City Station Drive
218 South City Station Drive Sun Prairie, WI
-, 0 Baths
$90,000
Picture of W3021 County Road C
W3021 County Road C Montello, WI
-, 0 Baths
$899,000
Picture of L1 County Road C
L1 County Road C Montello, WI
-, 0 Baths
$549,990
Picture of N6270 County Road B
N6270 County Road B Westfield, WI
Living Area: 2724 Sqft.
4 Beds, 3 Baths
$529,000
Picture of 630 Morningstar Drive
630 Morningstar Drive Portage, WI
Living Area: 2624 Sqft.
4 Beds, 3 Baths
$474,900
Picture of L14 Oak Road
L14 Oak Road Markesan, WI
-, 0 Baths
$30,000
Picture of L16 Oak Road
L16 Oak Road Markesan, WI
-, 0 Baths
$25,000
Picture of L17 Oak Road
L17 Oak Road Markesan, WI
-, 0 Baths
$25,000
Picture of L18 Oak Road
L18 Oak Road Markesan, WI
-, 0 Baths
$25,000
Picture of W1026 Laurie Lane
W1026 Laurie Lane Montello, WI
Living Area: 900 Sqft.
2 Beds, 1 Bath
$199,400
Picture of 110 West Montello Street
110 West Montello Street Montello, WI
Living Area: 1917 Sqft.
4 Beds, 1 Bath
$259,000
Picture of 110 W Montello Street
110 W Montello Street Montello, WI
Living Area: 1917 Sqft.
4 Beds, 1 Bath
$259,000
Picture of W1594 Golf View Drive
W1594 Golf View Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 1440 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$250,900
Picture of L1 State Hwy 22
L1 State Hwy 22 Montello, WI
-, 0 Baths
$149,900
Picture of W177 Laun Drive
W177 Laun Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 600 Sqft.
2 Beds, 1 Bath
$59,900
Picture of 217 Williams Street
217 Williams Street Cambria, WI
Living Area: 1765 Sqft.
4 Beds, 1 Bath
$229,900
Picture of N3574 21st Drive
N3574 21st Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 980 Sqft.
2 Beds, 1 Bath
$49,900

Sold (66)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of W3562 Glencoe Avenue
W3562 Glencoe Avenue Montello, WI
Living Area: 650 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $179,900 Listing
Picture of Lot 4&5 Sandy Pines Court
Lot 4&5 Sandy Pines Court Redgranite, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $22,770 Listing
Picture of 1760 County Road Z
1760 County Road Z Arkdale, WI
Living Area: 1230 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $139,900 Selling
Picture of N4514 Peacock Ln
N4514 Peacock Ln Montello, WI
Living Area: 2706 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $329,900 Selling
Picture of 273 Central Ave
273 Central Ave Montello, WI
Living Area: 1908 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $239,900 Listing
Picture of W3562 Glencoe Ave
W3562 Glencoe Ave Montello, WI
Living Area: 650 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $179,900 Listing
Picture of 3242 County Road G
3242 County Road G Oxford, WI
Living Area: 2260 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $132,900 Selling
Picture of N4774 11th Drive
N4774 11th Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 3264 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $374,774 Selling
Picture of 211 2nd Street
211 2nd Street Lake Delton, WI
Living Area: 1688 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $295,000 Selling
Picture of 121 West Water Street
121 West Water Street Montello, WI
Living Area: 1100 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $339,000 Listing
Picture of 225 East Water Street
225 East Water Street Montello, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $25,000 Listing
Picture of W3989 County Road C
W3989 County Road C Montello, WI
Living Area: 516 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $194,900 Selling
Picture of 321 Waugoo Avenue
321 Waugoo Avenue Oshkosh, WI
Living Area: 1728 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $210,000 Listing
Picture of N3544 Mark Avenue
N3544 Mark Avenue Montello, WI
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $179,900 Selling
Picture of W6085 County Road D
W6085 County Road D Montello, WI
Living Area: 1200 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $399,900 Selling
Picture of N3639 County Road F
N3639 County Road F Montello, WI
Living Area: 1460 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $299,999 Selling
Picture of Lots 7 & 8 Sandy Pines Court
Lots 7 & 8 Sandy Pines Court Redgranite, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $23,900 Selling
Picture of 259 Lake Avenue
259 Lake Avenue Montello, WI
Living Area: 1800 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $215,000 Selling
Picture of W4053 County Road C
W4053 County Road C Montello, WI
Living Area: 1680 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $349,900 Selling
Picture of N6655 Highway 22
N6655 Highway 22 Montello, WI
Living Area: 864 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $239,900 Selling
Picture of 309 Harvard Street
309 Harvard Street Princeton, WI
Living Area: 1585 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $30,000 Selling
Picture of 120 East Winnebago Street
120 East Winnebago Street Friesland, WI
Living Area: 1898 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $184,900 Selling
Picture of 615 South Market Street #9
615 South Market Street #9 Westfield, WI
Living Area: 1000 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $29,900 Selling
Picture of Lot 18 Sandy Pines Court
Lot 18 Sandy Pines Court Redgranite, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $12,815 Selling
Picture of 1008 Elk Boulevard
1008 Elk Boulevard Adams, WI
Living Area: 3178 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $498,500 Selling
Picture of L96 Golf Ridge Circle
L96 Golf Ridge Circle Montello, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $29,500 Selling
Picture of 505 West Conant Street
505 West Conant Street Portage, WI
Living Area: 2290 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $259,000 Selling
Picture of Lot 4 County Road F
Lot 4 County Road F Wautoma, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $35,500 Selling
Picture of N4899 Brentwood Way
N4899 Brentwood Way Montello, WI
Living Area: 1215 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $149,000 Listing
Picture of 634 Saddle Ridge
634 Saddle Ridge Portage, WI
Living Area: 2229 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $379,900 Selling
Picture of 277 Clay Street
277 Clay Street Montello, WI
Living Area: 1200 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $159,900 Listing
Picture of W4737 South Pearl Lake Road
W4737 South Pearl Lake Road Redgranite, WI
Living Area: 715 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $229,000 Listing
Picture of W7475 Aspen Trail
W7475 Aspen Trail Pardeeville, WI
Living Area: 2836 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $579,900 Listing
Picture of W4486 County Road K
W4486 County Road K Montello, WI
Living Area: 740 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $299,900 Listing
Picture of 241 Lawrence Street
241 Lawrence Street Westfield, WI
Living Area: 2400 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $489,000 Listing
Picture of W3724 County Road C #30
W3724 County Road C #30 Montello, WI
Living Area: 925 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $42,900 Selling
Picture of N5816 Soda Road
N5816 Soda Road Princeton, WI
Living Area: 1120 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $125,000 Selling
Picture of 518 Sunrise Lane
518 Sunrise Lane Markesan, WI
Living Area: 1788 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $234,900 Listing
Picture of N3431 West Tomahawk Trail
N3431 West Tomahawk Trail Montello, WI
Living Area: 900 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $214,000 Listing
Picture of W983 West North Shore Drive 12
W983 West North Shore Drive 12 Montello, WI
Living Area: 624 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $89,900 Listing
Picture of 0 Viking Trail
0 Viking Trail Wautoma, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $29,900 Listing
Picture of 109 West 2nd Street
109 West 2nd Street Friesland, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $15,500 Selling
Picture of 223 Doty Street
223 Doty Street Montello, WI
Living Area: 916 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $144,900 Listing
Picture of N2709 Lakeshore Drive
N2709 Lakeshore Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 900 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $199,900 Listing
Picture of W4286 Clearwater Drive
W4286 Clearwater Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 1725 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $335,000 Listing
Picture of N4404 Pine Drive
N4404 Pine Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 2711 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $619,900 Listing
Picture of 0 Alpine Trail
0 Alpine Trail Wautoma, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $24,900 Listing
Picture of 178 East Front Street 44
178 East Front Street 44 Marquette, WI
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $239,900 Selling
Picture of 215 East 7th Street
215 East 7th Street Westfield, WI
Living Area: 1040 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $131,500 Selling
Picture of W5211 Fern Avenue
W5211 Fern Avenue Montello, WI
Living Area: 1794 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $339,000 Listing
Picture of N5642 8th Drive
N5642 8th Drive Westfield, WI
Living Area: 936 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $270,000 Selling
Picture of 2693 Hazelnut Trail
2693 Hazelnut Trail Sun Prairie, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $90,000 Listing
Picture of N3436 West Tomahawk Trail
N3436 West Tomahawk Trail Montello, WI
Living Area: 1180 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $229,900 Listing
Picture of N3577 Catfish Trail
N3577 Catfish Trail Montello, WI
Living Area: 1280 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $79,500 Selling
Picture of N5523 County Road B Road
N5523 County Road B Road Montello, WI
Living Area: 920 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $249,000 Selling
Picture of N3531 Blue Gill Drive
N3531 Blue Gill Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 1025 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $55,000 Listing
Picture of 1775 Dover Drive
1775 Dover Drive Friendship, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $249,900 Selling
Picture of W1010 Laurie Lane
W1010 Laurie Lane Montello, WI
Living Area: 1364 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $224,900 Listing
Picture of N126 Brevard Drive
N126 Brevard Drive Montello, WI
Living Area: 2142 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $349,900 Listing
Picture of N3653 Highway 22
N3653 Highway 22 Montello, WI
Living Area: 930 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $89,900 Selling
Picture of N3540 Myra Lane
N3540 Myra Lane Montello, WI
Living Area: 952 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $129,000 Listing
Picture of W377S5229 Pretty Lake Road
W377S5229 Pretty Lake Road Dousman, WI
Living Area: 2208 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $679,900 Listing
Picture of 494 Tower Lane
494 Tower Lane Rio, WI
Living Area: 1344 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $289,900 Listing
Picture of W5267 Fern Avenue
W5267 Fern Avenue Montello, WI
Living Area: 1280 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $329,000 Listing
Picture of N8783 3rd Court
N8783 3rd Court Westfield, WI
Living Area: 816 Sqft.
02/06/2026 $225,000 Selling
Picture of N8321 4th Avenue
N8321 4th Avenue Westfield, WI
Living Area: Sqft.
02/06/2026 $39,900 Listing

Work together on Realty.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Montello, WI
Beloit, WI
Redgranite, WI
Sun Prairie, WI
Westfield, WI
Portage, WI
Markesan, WI
Cambria, WI
Arkdale, WI
Oxford, WI
Lake Delton, WI
Oshkosh, WI
Princeton, WI
Friesland, WI
Adams, WI
Wautoma, WI
Pardeeville, WI
Marquette, WI
Friendship, WI
Dousman, WI
Rio, WI

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Montello, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Montello, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Montello, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Montello, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Beloit, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
New Construction Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Beloit, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Beloit, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Redgranite, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Redgranite, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Redgranite, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
New Construction Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Sun Prairie, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Westfield, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Westfield, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Westfield, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Westfield, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Westfield, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Westfield, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Westfield, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Westfield, WI
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Westfield, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Westfield, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Portage, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Portage, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Portage, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Markesan, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Markesan, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Markesan, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Markesan, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Cambria, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
New Construction Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cambria, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Arkdale, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Arkdale, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Arkdale, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Oxford, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Oxford, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Oxford, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Oxford, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Oxford, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Oxford, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Oxford, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Oxford, WI
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Oxford, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Oxford, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Lake Delton, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Oshkosh, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Princeton, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Princeton, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Princeton, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Princeton, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Adams, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Adams, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Adams, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Adams, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Adams, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Adams, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Adams, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Adams, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Adams, WI
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Adams, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Wautoma, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Wautoma, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Wautoma, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Wautoma, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
New Construction Homes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Historic Homes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Townhomes for Sale in Pardeeville, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Friendship, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Friendship, WI
Affordable Homes for Sale in Friendship, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Friendship, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Friendship, WI
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Friendship, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Friendship, WI
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Friendship, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Friendship, WI
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Friendship, WI
Single Family Homes for Sale in Dousman, WI
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Dousman, WI
Luxury Homes for Sale in Dousman, WI
New Construction Homes for Sale in Dousman, WI
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Dousman, WI
Single Story Homes for Sale in Dousman, WI
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Dousman, WI
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Dousman, WI
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Dousman, WI
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Dousman, WI

  • Advertise
  • Affiliates
  • Property Records
  • Find an Agent
  • Careers
  • Blog

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Value
  • Commercial
  • Advertise
  • Referral

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing