Realty.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Advertise
  • Referral
  1. Home
  2. NY
  3. Cooperstown
  4. John Mitchell Real Estate, Llc

John Mitchell Real Estate, Llc

216 Main St

Cooperstown, NY

Team Members

Jane Mccoy

David Laduke

Kristen Bellois

Amy Kukenberger

Hillary Bass Laduke

David Wood

Laura Coleman

James Nering

Madeline Woerner

Deborah Watkins-parker

Michael Winslow

Joseph Vallette

William Gibson

Eric Carr

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Sold (113)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of 134 Sunnycrest Road
134 Sunnycrest Road Milford, NY
Living Area: 840 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $249,900 Listing
Picture of 131 Lincoln Circle
131 Lincoln Circle Milford, NY
Living Area: 1077 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $394,900 Selling
Picture of 0 Todd Road
0 Todd Road Hartwick, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $29,900 Listing
Picture of 5008 State Highway 28
5008 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY
Living Area: 1392 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $299,000 Colisting
Picture of 498 State highway 165
498 State highway 165 Roseboom, NY
Living Area: 2190 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $159,000 Listing
Picture of 51 Broad Street
51 Broad Street Morris, NY
Living Area: 1717 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $149,000 Listing
Picture of 26 Eagle Street
26 Eagle Street Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 2032 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $499,000 Colisting
Picture of 23 Susquehanna Ave Avenue
23 Susquehanna Ave Avenue Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1320 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $269,900 Selling
Picture of 3737 County Highway 35
3737 County Highway 35 Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1544 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $169,900 Listing
Picture of 44 N Lakeview Drive
44 N Lakeview Drive Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1802 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $599,900 Selling
Picture of 178 Millstone Road
178 Millstone Road Warren, NY
Living Area: 1625 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $289,000 Listing
Picture of 215 County Highway 26
215 County Highway 26 Otsego, NY
Living Area: 1680 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $295,000 Selling
Picture of 591 County Highway 14
591 County Highway 14 New Lisbon, NY
Living Area: 960 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $249,900 Listing
Picture of 128 Tunnicliff Road
128 Tunnicliff Road Richfield, NY
Living Area: 480 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $99,900 Selling
Picture of 118 Wheat Road
118 Wheat Road New Lisbon, NY
Living Area: 2376 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $174,900 Selling
Picture of 1323 County Highway 33
1323 County Highway 33 , NY
Living Area: 2656 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $524,000 Listing
Picture of 373 Rezen Road
373 Rezen Road Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 725 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $124,900 Listing
Picture of 13 Brook Street
13 Brook Street Milford, NY
Living Area: 1400 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $127,500 Selling
Picture of 524 County Highway 42
524 County Highway 42 Maryland, NY
Living Area: 1400 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $249,000 Listing
Picture of 38 Monticello
38 Monticello , NY
Living Area: 1388 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $148,000 Selling
Picture of 215 Main Street
215 Main Street , NY
Living Area: 6600 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $389,000 Selling
Picture of 225 County Highway 11C
225 County Highway 11C , NY
Living Area: 2375 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $269,000 Selling
Picture of 131 Crow Hill Road
131 Crow Hill Road Laurens, NY
Living Area: 1100 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $109,900 Selling
Picture of 3167 County Highway 33
3167 County Highway 33 , NY
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $43,900 Selling
Picture of 1706 Co Hwy 34
1706 Co Hwy 34 Westford, NY
Living Area: 3235 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $99,000 Selling
Picture of 824 East Street
824 East Street , NY
Living Area: 2431 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $308,000 Selling
Picture of 219 Main
219 Main Richfield, NY
Living Area: 2626 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $29,900 Selling
Picture of 174 County Highway 52
174 County Highway 52 Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 3120 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $698,000 Listing
Picture of 130 Chestnut Street
130 Chestnut Street , NY
Living Area: 4264 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $150,000 Selling
Picture of 45 Delaware Street
45 Delaware Street , NY
Living Area: 1900 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $125,000 Listing
Picture of 5417 State Highway 28
5417 State Highway 28 , NY
Living Area: 1200 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $85,000 Selling
Picture of 3732 County Highway 33
3732 County Highway 33 , NY
Living Area: 2952 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $79,900 Selling
Picture of 7334 State Highway 28
7334 State Highway 28 Exeter, NY
Living Area: 2088 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $39,000 Selling
Picture of 20 Wells Avenue
20 Wells Avenue Hartwick, NY
Living Area: 1166 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $99,000 Selling
Picture of 18 Church St.
18 Church St. , NY
Living Area: 1344 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $89,000 Selling
Picture of 32 Main Street
32 Main Street , NY
Living Area: 1152 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $45,000 Selling
Picture of 36 Susquehanna Avenue
36 Susquehanna Avenue , NY
Living Area: 2356 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $287,000 Selling
Picture of 91 Beaver Street
91 Beaver Street , NY
Living Area: 1195 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $129,000 Selling
Picture of 0 State Hwy 28
0 State Hwy 28 , NY
Living Area: 1213 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $199,900 Selling
Picture of 52 Walnut Street
52 Walnut Street , NY
Living Area: 1950 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $169,000 Selling
Picture of 13 Irving Place
13 Irving Place , NY
Living Area: 4500 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $219,000 Selling
Picture of 7331 State Highway 28 North
7331 State Highway 28 North , NY
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $79,000 Selling
Picture of 74 Montgomery Street
74 Montgomery Street , NY
Living Area: 1400 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $83,500 Colisting
Picture of 1912 State Highway 166
1912 State Highway 166 , NY
Living Area: 381 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $39,900 Selling
Picture of 688 Main Street
688 Main Street Franklin, NY
Living Area: 1780 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $159,000 Listing
Picture of 63 Grove
63 Grove , NY
Living Area: 804 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $129,000 Selling
Picture of 2 Frenleigh Drive
2 Frenleigh Drive Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 3146 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $675,000 Selling
Picture of 3544 County Highway 11
3544 County Highway 11 Hartwick, NY
Living Area: 940 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $74,900 Selling
Picture of 16 Country Club Road
16 Country Club Road , NY
Living Area: 1536 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $97,000 Selling
Picture of 64 Main Street
64 Main Street , NY
Living Area: 2000 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $475,500 Selling
Picture of 10 Maple Street
10 Maple Street , NY
Living Area: 1658 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $175,000 Selling
Picture of 21 Pine Boulevard
21 Pine Boulevard Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1580 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $2,100 Listing
Picture of 5418 STATE HIGHWAY 28
5418 STATE HIGHWAY 28 , NY
Living Area: 5000 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $550,000 Selling
Picture of 2 Maple Street
2 Maple Street , NY
Living Area: 3510 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $249,000 Selling
Picture of 2285 County Highway 16
2285 County Highway 16 Burlington, NY
Living Area: 1610 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $125,000 Selling
Picture of 0 State Highway 166
0 State Highway 166 , NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $50,000 Selling
Picture of 327 County Highway 36A
327 County Highway 36A Westford, NY
Living Area: 1296 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $195,000 Selling
Picture of 9 Morgan Avenue
9 Morgan Avenue , NY
Living Area: 1556 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $164,000 Selling
Picture of 4070 State Highway 28
4070 State Highway 28 Hartwick, NY
Living Area: 1200 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $106,900 Selling
Picture of 158 Lippitt Development Road
158 Lippitt Development Road , NY
Living Area: 804 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $245,000 Colisting
Picture of 29 Brook Street
29 Brook Street , NY
Living Area: 1000 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $129,500 Selling
Picture of 7 Morgan Avenue
7 Morgan Avenue , NY
Living Area: 1300 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $175,000 Listing
Picture of 0 Thayer Road
0 Thayer Road Otsego, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $79,900 Listing
Picture of 1835 Clinton Road
1835 Clinton Road Minden, NY
Living Area: 2372 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $279,000 Colisting
Picture of 4963 State Highway 28
4963 State Highway 28 Hartwick, NY
Living Area: 1138 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $149,000 Listing
Picture of 306 Burners Road
306 Burners Road Laurens, NY
Living Area: 1700 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $289,700 Selling
Picture of 351 Bissell Road
351 Bissell Road Otsego, NY
Living Area: 1848 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $1,500 Selling
Picture of 10517 Turnpike Road
10517 Turnpike Road Kortright, NY
Living Area: 2184 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $105,000 Selling
Picture of 77 Chestnut Street
77 Chestnut Street , NY
Living Area: 2728 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $325,000 Selling
Picture of 6 Beech Street
6 Beech Street , NY
Living Area: 1800 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $215,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Dick Morton Road
0 Dick Morton Road Middlefield, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $150,000 Listing
Picture of 103 St Hwy 165
103 St Hwy 165 Roseboom, NY
Living Area: 2444 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $200,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Main Street
0 Main Street Milford, NY
Living Area: 2700 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $499,000 Listing
Picture of 7571 State Highway 80
7571 State Highway 80 Springfield, NY
Living Area: 1600 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $129,900 Selling
Picture of 53 Miller Street
53 Miller Street , NY
Living Area: 1296 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $119,900 Selling
Picture of 4959 State Highway 28
4959 State Highway 28 Hartwick, NY
Living Area: 2000 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $179,900 Listing
Picture of 0 Keating Road
0 Keating Road Otsego, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $40,000 Selling
Picture of 843 Co Hwy 34
843 Co Hwy 34 , NY
Living Area: 2400 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $89,000 Selling
Picture of 116 Prevost Place
116 Prevost Place , NY
Living Area: 2206 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $400,000 Listing
Picture of 1129 County Highway 33
1129 County Highway 33 Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 3014 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $146,900 Selling
Picture of 1121 County Highway 36
1121 County Highway 36 Westford, NY
Living Area: 1359 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $29,900 Selling
Picture of 1 Lakefront Terrace
1 Lakefront Terrace , NY
Living Area: 1860 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $339,000 Selling
Picture of 20 Beech Street
20 Beech Street Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1466 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $1,600 Selling
Picture of 741 Bissell Road
741 Bissell Road Otsego, NY
Living Area: 2000 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $229,900 Selling
Picture of 568 Ottaway Road
568 Ottaway Road Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1648 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $99,000 Listing
Picture of 0 Allison Road
0 Allison Road Otsego, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $39,000 Selling
Picture of 290 Bob Wilson Road
290 Bob Wilson Road Milford, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $49,900 Selling
Picture of 6738 State Highway 80
6738 State Highway 80 Otsego, NY
Living Area: 720 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $350,000 Listing
Picture of 149 Cronin Road
149 Cronin Road Westford, NY
Living Area: 2120 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $200,000 Listing
Picture of 401 Roscoe Jones Road
401 Roscoe Jones Road Middlefield, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $35,000 Listing
Picture of 4 Walnut Street
4 Walnut Street , NY
Living Area: 2058 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $289,000 Selling
Picture of 2136 County Highway 33
2136 County Highway 33 Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 2452 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $149,000 Listing
Picture of 152 Kukenberger Meadow Lane
152 Kukenberger Meadow Lane Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 3340 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $319,000 Listing
Picture of 6606 State Highway 28
6606 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $174,900 Selling
Picture of 0 Lakeview Drive
0 Lakeview Drive Exeter, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $44,500 Selling
Picture of 634 Beaver Meadow Road
634 Beaver Meadow Road Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 2208 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $315,000 Listing
Picture of 0 State Highway 80
0 State Highway 80 Otsego, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $44,900 Listing
Picture of 27 lake Street
27 lake Street Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 1100 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $1,050 Selling
Picture of 102 Prevost Place
102 Prevost Place Middlefield, NY
Living Area: 2600 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $399,900 Selling
Picture of 3258 County Highway 33
3258 County Highway 33 , NY
Living Area: 2112 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $275,000 Selling
Picture of 40 Lancaster Street
40 Lancaster Street , NY
Living Area: 1643 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $149,000 Selling
Picture of 81 Main Street
81 Main Street Milford, NY
Living Area: 2910 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $239,900 Selling
Picture of 829 Co Hwy 26
829 Co Hwy 26 Otsego, NY
Living Area: 3724 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $186,300 Selling
Picture of 104 Doc Ahlers Road
104 Doc Ahlers Road , NY
Living Area: 1188 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $80,000 Selling
Picture of 25 West Street
25 West Street , NY
Living Area: 1728 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $99,000 Selling
Picture of 0 Bissell Rd.
0 Bissell Rd. Otsego, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $29,000 Selling
Picture of 466 Petkewec Road
466 Petkewec Road Otsego, NY
Living Area: 1264 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $189,000 Listing
Picture of 3084 Co Hwy 35
3084 Co Hwy 35 Middlefield, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
02/01/2026 $16,500 Selling
Picture of 11 Bloom Street
11 Bloom Street , NY
Living Area: 1550 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $124,000 Selling
Picture of 15 Frederick Street
15 Frederick Street , NY
Living Area: 921 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $79,000 Selling
Picture of 53 Susquehanna Ave
53 Susquehanna Ave , NY
Living Area: 1702 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $249,000 Selling
Picture of 4889 State Highway 28
4889 State Highway 28 Hartwick, NY
Living Area: 1138 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $39,900 Selling
Picture of 409 Oneil Road
409 Oneil Road , NY
Living Area: 1080 Sqft.
02/01/2026 $54,900 Listing

Work together on Realty.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Milford, NY
Hartwick, NY
Otsego, NY
Roseboom, NY
Morris, NY
Middlefield, NY
Warren, NY
New Lisbon, NY
Richfield, NY
, NY
Maryland, NY
Laurens, NY
Westford, NY
Exeter, NY
Franklin, NY
Burlington, NY
Minden, NY
Kortright, NY
Springfield, NY

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Milford, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Milford, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Milford, NY
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Milford, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Otsego, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Otsego, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Otsego, NY
Homes with Pools for Sale in Otsego, NY
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Otsego, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Otsego, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Middlefield, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Maryland, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Maryland, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Maryland, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Maryland, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Minden, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Minden, NY
Multi-Family Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Minden, NY
5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Minden, NY

  • Advertise
  • Affiliates
  • Property Records
  • Find an Agent
  • Careers
  • Blog

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Value
  • Commercial
  • Advertise
  • Referral

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing