Realty.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Advertise
  • Referral
  1. Home
  2. OH
  3. Lancaster
  4. Bartlett Benner Realty

Bartlett Benner Realty

2751 W. Fair Ave

Lancaster, OH

Team Members

Donn Borah

Gary Bartlett

Tony Coakley

Janet Shonebarger

Keith Dwyer

James Vanover

Nicholas Bartlett

Amanda Cook

Keith Dwyer

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Listings & Recent Sales (32)

Active Rental Sold

For Sale (11)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 0 County Road 12
0 County Road 12 Corning, OH
-, 0 Baths
$79,660
Picture of 22959 Bigham Road
22959 Bigham Road Rockbridge, OH
Living Area: 640 Sqft.
2 Beds, 1 Bath
$499,900
Picture of 9605 Royalton Road SW
9605 Royalton Road SW Amanda, OH
Living Area: 1488 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$327,400
Picture of 13196 Middlefork Road
13196 Middlefork Road Amanda, OH
Living Area: 2500 Sqft.
4 Beds, 5 Baths
$1,490,000
Picture of 20022 Feathers Road
20022 Feathers Road Logan, OH
Living Area: 1288 Sqft.
2 Beds, 2 Baths
$499,900
Picture of 330 Park Street
330 Park Street Lancaster, OH
-, 0 Baths
$188,000
Picture of 45545 Sand Ridge Road
45545 Sand Ridge Road Racine, OH
Living Area: 1620 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$315,000
Picture of 2445 Columbus-Lancaster Road NW 409
2445 Columbus-Lancaster Road NW 409 Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 880 Sqft.
3 Beds, 2 Baths
$78,000
Picture of 15860 Stump Run
15860 Stump Run Laurelville, OH
-, 0 Baths
$87,900
Picture of 2445 Columbus-Lancaster Road NW LOT 87
2445 Columbus-Lancaster Road NW LOT 87 Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 840 Sqft.
2 Beds, 1 Bath
$59,900
Picture of 15 S Shafer Drive 510ST
15 S Shafer Drive 510ST Athens, OH
Living Area: 478 Sqft.
1 Bed, 1 Bath
$78,900

Rentals (5)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 80 Logan Thornville Road NE
80 Logan Thornville Road NE Bremen, OH
Living Area: 2185 Sqft.
-, 0 Baths
$399,000
Picture of 26 & 28 W Waterloo
26 & 28 W Waterloo Canal Winchester, OH
Living Area: 7000 Sqft.
-, 0 Baths
$67,620
Picture of 19 E Waterloo Street
19 E Waterloo Street Canal Winchester, OH
Living Area: 6674 Sqft.
-, 0 Baths
$2,000
Picture of 360 W Waterloo Street
360 W Waterloo Street Canal Winchester, OH
Living Area: 7020 Sqft.
-, 0 Baths
$2,500
Picture of 813 Eaton Hollow Road SW
813 Eaton Hollow Road SW Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1100 Sqft.
2 Beds, 2 Baths
$2,400

Sold (16)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of 60 E Waterloo Street
60 E Waterloo Street Canal Winchester, OH
Living Area: 3362 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $50,000 Listing
Picture of 430 Williamsburg Lane NW
430 Williamsburg Lane NW Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1088 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $1,600 Selling
Picture of 1318 Cedar Hill Road
1318 Cedar Hill Road Lancaster, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/18/2026 $199,000 Listing
Picture of 2975 Pleasant Drive NE
2975 Pleasant Drive NE Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1352 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $274,900 Listing
Picture of 7663 Richland Road NE
7663 Richland Road NE Rushville, OH
Living Area: 2532 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $599,999 Listing
Picture of 617 E Main Street A
617 E Main Street A Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 3284 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $1,400 Selling
Picture of 1430 Hamburg Road SW
1430 Hamburg Road SW Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1352 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $279,000 Listing
Picture of 8050 Marietta Road SE
8050 Marietta Road SE Bremen, OH
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $362,900 Listing
Picture of 1570 E Main Street Lot 49
1570 E Main Street Lot 49 Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1624 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $52,888 Selling
Picture of 601 E 5th Avenue
601 E 5th Avenue Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1022 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $1,000 Selling
Picture of 104 E Main Street
104 E Main Street Bremen, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/18/2026 $45,000 Selling
Picture of 10950 Graffis Road SE
10950 Graffis Road SE Bremen, OH
Living Area: 1800 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $448,900 Listing
Picture of 9760 Marietta Road SE
9760 Marietta Road SE Bremen, OH
Living Area: Sqft.
03/18/2026 $1,499,900 Selling
Picture of 923 N Pierce Avenue
923 N Pierce Avenue Lancaster, OH
Living Area: 1128 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $1,150 Listing
Picture of 411 S Merritt Road SW
411 S Merritt Road SW Pataskala, OH
Living Area: 1510 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $285,000 Listing
Picture of 9563 Webb Summit Road SE
9563 Webb Summit Road SE Bremen, OH
Living Area: 1200 Sqft.
03/18/2026 $302,900 Listing

Work together on Realty.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Corning, OH
Bremen, OH
Canal Winchester, OH
Rockbridge, OH
Amanda, OH
Logan, OH
Lancaster, OH
Racine, OH
Laurelville, OH
Athens, OH
Rushville, OH
Pataskala, OH

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Corning, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Corning, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Corning, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Corning, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Corning, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Corning, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Corning, OH
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Corning, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Corning, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Corning, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Canal Winchester, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Rockbridge, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Amanda, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Amanda, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Amanda, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Logan, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Logan, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Logan, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Logan, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Lancaster, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Business for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Lancaster, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Laurelville, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Laurelville, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Laurelville, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Laurelville, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Laurelville, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Laurelville, OH
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Laurelville, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Laurelville, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Laurelville, OH
Homes with 4 Car Garages for Sale in Laurelville, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Athens, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Athens, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Athens, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Athens, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Athens, OH
Historic Homes for Sale in Athens, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Athens, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Athens, OH
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Athens, OH
Affordable Homes for Sale in Athens, OH
Single Family Homes for Sale in Pataskala, OH
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Pataskala, OH
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Pataskala, OH
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Pataskala, OH
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Pataskala, OH
Luxury Homes for Sale in Pataskala, OH
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Pataskala, OH
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Pataskala, OH
New Construction Homes for Sale in Pataskala, OH
Homes with Pools for Sale in Pataskala, OH

  • Advertise
  • Affiliates
  • Property Records
  • Find an Agent
  • Careers
  • Blog

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Mortgage
  • Value
  • Commercial
  • Advertise
  • Referral

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing