Price Reduced44
$999,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,994 sqft
453 Smith Avenue, Islip, NY
David P. Sanders · Compass Greater NY LLC
Est. $5,943/mo$369/sqft · 7 days on Realty
4
Beds
3
Baths
2,510
Sqft
1965
Built
Welcome home to this charming Colonial set on .72 acres of park-like grounds South of Montauk Highway in the truly exceptional community of Islip. With its inviting front porch, mature landscaping and classic architectural details, this home offers a warm welcome and a beautiful setting to call home. Step inside to an entry foyer featuring hardwood floors, decorative moldings and a traditional staircase. The spacious Living Room and Formal Dining Room offer plenty of room for gatherings and entertaining. The Eat-in Kitchen features rich cherry wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, a center island and a sunny dining area. A cozy Den with wood-paneled walls and exposed wood ceiling beams adds character and offers a comfortable place to unwind. One of the home’s highlights is the sun-drenched sunroom where a wall of windows look out over the beautiful backyard with its mature plantings, colorful perennial gardens and a magnificent wisteria tree that steals the show when it blooms. On warm evenings, open the doors and have dinner out on the brick patio. When the weather turns cool, light the gas stove and enjoy the same view from your favorite chair. The second level has a primary suite with a private bathroom, along with three additional bedrooms and a full bathroom. Additional features include central air conditioning, hardwood flooring, gas heat and cooking, an unfinished basement, attic storage, newly painted exterior (2025) and an attached two car garage with a cedar closet. Enjoy easy access to all major parkways, the LIRR, shops, restaurants, hospitals, schools, parks, beaches, golf courses, marinas and the Fire Island Ferries. Built by its original owners and lovingly maintained over the years, this meticulous home is being offered for sale for the first time. Combining timeless charm, inviting living spaces and a desirable South Shore location, this is a home you will be proud to call your own.
Listing agent
Susan Lombardi
Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
(516) 456-6644
OneKey MLS · Listing KEY1070635
$185,000
Estimated monthly payment
$5,943/mo
Loan amount $740,000. Estimate only — your actual rate and payment depend on credit, location, and lender.
2025 roll
School ratings (A+ to F) from HJN community data.
Maud S Sherwood Elementary School
2-5 · Regular · Islip Union Free School District
366 students · 10.5:1 student–teacher
Islip Middle School
7-8 · Regular · Islip Union Free School District
601 students · 9.6:1 student–teacher
Islip High School
9-12 · Regular · Islip Union Free School District
890 students · 9.8:1 student–teacher
Bay Shore Prekindergarten Center
KG-KG · Regular · Bay Shore Union Free School District
27 students · 3.4:1 student–teacher
St Mary School
PK-8 · Regular
351 students · 13.2:1 student–teacher
Wing Elementary School
KG-1 · Regular · Islip Union Free School District
373 students · 11.1:1 student–teacher
John F. Kennedy Elementary School
3-5 · Regular · East Islip Union Free School District
416 students · 11.3:1 student–teacher
Brook Avenue Elementary School
KG-2 · Regular · Bay Shore Union Free School District
336 students · 7.7:1 student–teacher
OneKey MLSThis content last refreshed on 2026-11-16 07:19:57 UTC. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.
Price Reduced44
$999,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,994 sqft
453 Smith Avenue, Islip, NY
David P. Sanders · Compass Greater NY LLC
23$899,000
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,465 sqft
171 Smith Avenue, Islip, NY
Gale Scaglia · Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life
Price Reduced19$649,999
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,000 sqft
85 Ferndale Boulevard, Islip, NY
Judy Hendrickson · Douglas Elliman Real Estate
28$699,000
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,060 sqft
27 Rose Street, Islip, NY
Susan P. Simmons CBR · Howard Hanna Coach
25$699,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 912 sqft
11 W Hemlock Street, Islip, NY
Oneyda E. Gallardo CBR · Empire Home Realty of L I Inc
Price Reduced34$739,000
4 bd · 3 ba · 1,884 sqft
2 Taft Avenue, Islip, NY
Oscar M. Salazar Sorto · ARVY Realty





Within 2 miles of this home: 39+ restaurants and cafés, 8 grocery stores, 29 parks and green spaces, and 9 transit stops.
Place data from OpenStreetMap.
Wendy's
Main Street
Long Beach Cafe
J&R's Islip Steak House
Main Street
Starbucks
Main Street
Taco Bell
East Main Street
Mango Tango Asian Fusion
Asian restaurant
McDonald's
Main Street
Redefine Meals
East Main Street
Islip Meat Mkt
Stop & Shop
Montauk HwyRte. 27A
TonaLaw
Islip Avenue
Lidl
Islip Avenue
Aiello Bros. Pork Store
ShopRite
Sunrise Highway
Aldi
Sunrise Highway
A S Italian Fine Foods
Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge
Islip Beach
Islip Town Beach
Bayberry Beach Club
Orowoc Lake
Town Hall West Fields
Pardees Ponds
Lower Winganhauppauge Lake
Islip
Islip Avenue & West Spruce Street
Islip Avenue & Spruce Street
Islip Avenue & West Oak Street
Mechanicville Road & Park Avenue
Union Boulevard & 3rd Avenue
Union Boulevard & 4th Avenue
Bay Shore