The property at 5698 State Route 23, Cincinnatus, NY 13040, built in 1865, is a 2,136 square foot Single Family and has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. It is situated on a lot that is 110,207 square feet and was last tax assessed in 2024 for a valuation of $125,926
The estimate for this property has experienced a 20.74% increase in the past 6 months reaching a value of $162,212.
- NY
- Cincinnatus
- 5698 State Route 23
- Parcel Number112000 122.00-03-23.200
- CountyCORTLAND
- Stories3
Property Tax History
Source: Public Records
| Year | Assessment |
|---|---|
| 2023 | $102,000 |
| 2022 | $102,000 +10.87% |
| 2021 | $92,000 |
| 2020 | $92,000 +24.16% |
| 2019 | $74,100 |
| 2018 | $74,100 |
| 2017 | $74,100 -19.46% |
| 2016 | $92,000 +24.16% |
| 2015 | $74,100 |
| 2014 | $74,100 |
| 2013 | $74,100 |
Valuation History
Source: Public Records
| Month | Valuation | Single Family Homes Sold | Median Sales Price/Sqft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 | $162,212 | - | - |
| Oct 2025 | $160,687 | - | - |
| Sep 2025 | $163,415 | - | - |
| Aug 2025 | $160,954 | - | - |
| Jul 2025 | $152,877 | - | - |
| Jun 2025 | $149,100 | - | - |
| May 2025 | $140,053 | - | - |
| Apr 2025 | $134,347 | - | - |
| Mar 2025 | $129,388 | - | - |
| Feb 2025 | $122,884 | - | - |
| Jan 2025 | $117,867 | - | - |
| Dec 2024 | $119,104 | - | - |
| Nov 2024 | $122,314 | - | - |
| Sep 2024 | $180,100 | - | - |
| Aug 2024 | $152,510 | - | - |
| Jul 2024 | $152,135 | - | - |
| Jun 2024 | $147,791 | - | - |
| May 2024 | $143,396 | - | - |
| Mar 2024 | $146,619 | - | - |
| Feb 2024 | $165,111 | - | - |
| Jan 2024 | $164,676 | - | - |
| Dec 2023 | $161,431 | - | - |
| Nov 2023 | $109,164 | - | - |
| Oct 2023 | $116,534 | - | - |
| Sep 2023 | $112,453 | - | - |
| Aug 2023 | $135,660 | - | - |
| Jul 2023 | $133,620 | - | - |
| Jun 2023 | $133,620 | - | - |
| May 2023 | $107,100 | - | - |
| Apr 2023 | $107,100 | - | - |
| Mar 2023 | $103,960 | - | - |
| Feb 2023 | $146,400 | - | - |
| Jan 2023 | $142,700 | - | - |
*Market History, including Median Sales Price per square foot, and Single Family Homes Sold is based on historical data of Zip Code: 13040 - NY
Population & Environment
Source: Sperling's Best Places
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 3,011 | 1,050 | 50,141 | 335,858,263 |
| Population Density | 31 | 41 | 101 | 95 |
| People per Household | 2.6 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.6 |
| Median Age | 42.7 | 42.5 | 37 | 39.1 |
| Median Income | $55,574 | $54,286 | $58,802 | $66,222 |
| Average Income | $25,938 | $25,093 | $29,833 | $35,475 |
| Cost of Living Index | 97 | 94 | 90 | 100 |
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January Avg. High Temp | 15.15°F | 15.15°F | 15.2°F | 22.6°F |
| July Avg. High Temp | 80.26°F | 80.26°F | 81°F | 86.2°F |
| Annual Precipitation | 43.01" | 43.01" | 39.32" | 38" |
Nearby Properties
-
$199,000 Active0 bds • 0 ba • 5,000 sqft
2686 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Looking for your next commercial project? Welcome to this amazing barn, with so many unique uses for this space. At least 5000+ sq. feet of amazing space. Last use was Stonehedges gift barn! 2-3 floors of useable space. Options are warehouse, mechan...Listing by: Pamela Williams - Yaman Real Estate -
$25,000 Active0 bds • 0 ba • 1,638 sqft
3282 State Route 26, Taylor, NY 13040
***Motivated seller—looking for offers!*** Build your dream home on this 1-acre lot in peaceful Cincinnatus. With a newer well (4–5 years), this property is a blank canvas surrounded by nature. Making this the perfect time to make it yours. Imagine w...Listing by: Nicole McRae - Yaman Real Estate -
$159,900 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
Dutch Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Discover your perfect escape with this stunning 75-acre parcel nestled along Dutch Hill Road in Cincinnatus, NY. Surrounded by nature, this property features a stream, a mix of mature woods, and sweeping views of the picturesque rolling hills. Conven...Listing by: Pamela Cullip - Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty -
$69,995 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
1.1 Dutch Hill Rd. Spur 1, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Rolling stands of hardwood forest border Gee Brook State Forest, named for its beautiful sparkling creek and 865 acres of state forest land for hunting, hiking trails, paddling, fishing and other recreational activities. Also, minutes to Papish Pond...Listing by: -
$59,995 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
1.5 Jones Road 5, German, NY 13801
Tucked away in New York's scenic Southern Tier, this beautiful, wooded acreage offers direct access to the 6,353-acre Five Streams State Forest along two borders-perfect for outdoor enthusiasts who enjoy hiking, hunting, fishing, mountain biking, hor...Listing by: -
$75,995 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
1.5 County Road 29 5, New Berlin, NY 13411
Set in New York's Southern Tier, this 12-acre property offers a perfect balance of open meadows and hickory forest, with an ideal building site nestled among the trees. Enjoy sweeping views of the surrounding countryside along a paved Chenango County...Listing by: -
$89,000 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
4296 Stramba Road, Freetown, NY 13040
White tail habitat! This spacious 42-acre site offers an ideal option for a seasonal getaway or an excellent hunting experience. With frontage on two roads, rolling topography, and a mostly wooded setting, this location will provide years of outdoor...Listing by: Allen T. Olmsted - Canaan Realty -
$179,900 Active Under Contract3 bds • 1 ba • 1,440 sqft
4339 May Road, Solon, NY 13040
Welcome to this 3 bedroom, 1 bath ranch home nestled on 8.13 acres of country living. Large eat in kitchen, you can enjoy the back views while doing dishes. Laundry on the first floor, 3 bedrooms, one currently is a craft/workshop. Owners worked with...Listing by: Pamela Williams - Yaman Real Estate -
$125,000 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
Stramba Road, Freetown, NY 13040
Looking to live off the grid? or a perfect spot for your camper this is for you. Welcome to 20.01 acres of pure bliss! This property is completely off the grid and is located on both sides of the private road and has amazing views and sits on a beaut...Listing by: Pamela Williams - Yaman Real Estate -
$25,000 Active2 bds • 1 ba • 980 sqft
1931 Carter Slocum Road, Cortland, NY 13803
*****All Investors! All Future Homeowners! ***** High Curb Appeal And Quiet Neighborhood Describes This Dwelling, Which Is Waiting For You To Give It A Makeover. Located Near Maple Hill Golf Resort And Other Business's. Closet Space With A Big...Listing by: Amjad Mughal - M J J Realty -
$139,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,248 sqft
2771 Center Road, Freetown, NY 13101
Set on 2.08 secluded acres, this 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath double-wide home offers plenty of space and privacy in a quiet, tucked-away location. The property features handicap-accessible elements, a newly painted exterior, and a freshly updated entryway...Listing by: Kiara Lyon - Hage Real Estate -
$459,900 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 2,872 sqft
4555 Elwood Road, Taylor, NY 13040
Step into a rare and extraordinary retreat where history, design, and nature come together. This architect-designed barn conversion, originally built in the early 1800s, preserves the charm of its original construction with hand-hewn beams and solid...Listing by: Jenna Davi - Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty -
$459,900 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 2,872 sqft
4555 Elwood Road, Taylor, NY 13040
Step into a rare and extraordinary retreat where history, design, and nature come together. This architect-designed barn conversion, built in 1900, preserves the charm of its original construction with hand-hewn beams and solid locally sourced pine f...Listing by: Jenna Davi - Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty -
$459,900 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 2,872 sqft
4555 Elwood Road, Taylor, NY 13040
Step into a rare and extraordinary retreat where history, design, and nature come together. This architect-designed barn conversion, built in 1900, preserves the charm of its original construction with hand-hewn beams and solid locally sourced pine f...Listing by: Jenna Davi - Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty -
$1,000,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,571 sqft
4099 Piety Ridge Road, Marathon, NY 13803
Discover this beautiful country estate featuring a spacious, updated 3-bedroom home, A large family room with a full-height stone fireplace creates a warm and inviting centerpiece for gatherings. The country kitchen and sunny breakfast room make ever...Listing by: Allen T. Olmsted - Canaan Realty -
$1,000,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,571 sqft
4099 Piety Ridge Road, Marathon, NY 13803
Discover this beautiful country estate featuring a spacious, updated 3-bedroom home, A large family room with a full-height stone fireplace creates a warm and inviting centerpiece for gatherings. The country kitchen and sunny breakfast room make eve...Listing by: Allen T. Olmsted - Canaan Realty -
$23,900 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
L7.415 County Road 7, Mc Donough, NY 13801
Endless Possibilities! This 3.1 prime, open acreage combines accessibility, natural beauty and functionality-a rare find for anyone dreaming of a rural lifestyle or getaway, making this beautiful land ideal for building a dream home, establishing a g...Listing by: Jennifer Noble - Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties -
$129,900 Active3 bds • 1 ba • 1,020 sqft
1019 County Road 7, Pharsalia, NY 13801
Perfect hunting cabin or retreat or even your new fulltime home in the country. This property has an older mobile home with a stick built addition that you can stay in until you finish the 2 story home that has been framed and ready to be finished....Listing by: Jack R. Thyfault - Northeast Realty Chenango County LLC -
$144,900 Active Under Contract3 bds • 1 ba • 1,536 sqft
1691 State Highway 220, Mc Donough, NY 13801
1500 Square Foot home - 3 bedrooms, new bathroom, living room with fireplace, freshly painted, new bamboo flooring and ceramic tiles, rec room in basement, office also in basement and walk out. Front deck, side deck and a nice size lot. Shed on pro...Listing by: Karen E. Cammarata, ABR, RSPS GRI - Howard Hanna -
$129,900 Active0 bds • 0 ba • sqft
168 George Peasley Road, Mc Donough, NY 13758
Discover your own Chenango County getaway on this beautiful 25+ acre parcel, perfectly set up for the outdoorsman who lives for whitetail season. Tucked away on a quiet dead-end road and within minutes of thousands of acres of state land, this proper...Listing by: Anthony Wolcott - Find Advisors
Nearby Locations
Communities
- Haynes Homes For Sale
- South Valley Homes For Sale
- Joshua Homes For Sale
- Lyndon Homes For Sale
- Valley Homes For Sale
- North Valley Homes For Sale
- Brighton Homes For Sale
- Southside Homes For Sale
- Strathmore Homes For Sale
- Convention District Homes For Sale
- Cathedral Square Homes For Sale
- Eastwood Homes For Sale
- Near Westside Homes For Sale
- North Manlius Homes For Sale
- Franklin Square Homes For Sale
- Westside Homes For Sale
- Northside Homes For Sale
- Washington Square Homes For Sale
- Halfway Homes For Sale
- Cold Springs Homes For Sale
Nearby Zips
- 13830 Homes For Sale
- 13045 Homes For Sale
- 13815 Homes For Sale
- 13077 Homes For Sale
- 13733 Homes For Sale
- 13104 Homes For Sale
- 13346 Homes For Sale
- 13078 Homes For Sale
- 13066 Homes For Sale
- 13838 Homes For Sale
- 13118 Homes For Sale
- 13205 Homes For Sale
- 13037 Homes For Sale
- 13214 Homes For Sale
- 13224 Homes For Sale
- 13207 Homes For Sale
- 13210 Homes For Sale
- 13215 Homes For Sale
- 13032 Homes For Sale
- 13217 Homes For Sale
Nearby Cities
- Cortland, NY Homes for Sale
- Manlius, NY Homes for Sale
- Onondaga, NY Homes for Sale
- De Witt, NY Homes for Sale
- Sullivan, NY Homes for Sale
- Syracuse, NY Homes for Sale
- Oneida, NY Homes for Sale
- Geddes, NY Homes for Sale
- Salina, NY Homes for Sale
- Camillus, NY Homes for Sale
- Cicero, NY Homes for Sale
- Clay, NY Homes for Sale
- Kirkland, NY Homes for Sale
- Van Buren, NY Homes for Sale
- Auburn, NY Homes for Sale
- Lysander, NY Homes for Sale
- New Hartford, NY Homes for Sale
- Oneonta, NY Homes for Sale
- Whitestown, NY Homes for Sale
- Utica, NY Homes for Sale
Similar Searches
- Cincinnatus Land for Sale
- Cincinnatus New Homes for Sale
- Cincinnatus Single Story Homes for Sale
- Cincinnatus Homes with Pools for Sale
- Cincinnatus Cheap Homes for Sale
- Cincinnatus Luxury Homes for Sale
- Cincinnatus Condos for Sale
- Cincinnatus Town Homes for Sale
- Cincinnatus Commercial for Sale
- Cincinnatus Open Houses for Sale
- Cincinnatus Two Car Garage Homes for Sale
- Cincinnatus Large Lots for Sale