The property at 5401 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220, built in 1934, is a 2,192 square foot Single Family and has 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. It is situated on a lot that is 8,494 square feet and was last tax assessed in 2024 for a valuation of $810,300
The estimate for this property has experienced a 4.38% increase in the past 6 months reaching a value of $903,156.
- IN
- Indianapolis
- 5401 N New Jersey St
- Parcel Number49-06-12-226-143.000-801
- CountyMARION
- Stories2
Property Tax History
Source: Public Records
| Year | Assessment |
|---|---|
| 2022 | $656,000 -8.84% |
| 2021 | $719,600 +11.60% |
| 2020 | $644,800 +6.63% |
| 2019 | $604,700 -1.63% |
| 2018 | $614,700 +11.93% |
| 2017 | $549,200 -19.29% |
| 2016 | $680,500 +4.24% |
| 2015 | $652,800 +0.18% |
| 2014 | $651,600 +3.28% |
| 2012 | $630,900 |
Valuation History
Source: Public Records
| Month | Valuation | Single Family Homes Sold | Median Sales Price/Sqft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 | $903,156 | - | - |
| Oct 2025 | $915,620 | - | - |
| Sep 2025 | $912,659 | - | - |
| Aug 2025 | $913,432 | - | - |
| Jul 2025 | $880,780 | - | - |
| Jun 2025 | $881,266 | - | - |
| May 2025 | $881,444 | - | - |
| Apr 2025 | $865,233 | - | - |
| Mar 2025 | $852,391 | - | - |
| Feb 2025 | $869,977 | - | - |
| Jan 2025 | $837,833 | - | - |
| Dec 2024 | $813,739 | - | - |
| Nov 2024 | $818,730 | - | - |
| Oct 2024 | $781,524 | - | - |
| Sep 2024 | $785,296 | - | - |
| Aug 2024 | $789,975 | - | - |
| Jul 2024 | $751,463 | - | - |
| Jun 2024 | $756,156 | - | - |
| May 2024 | $748,280 | - | - |
| Apr 2024 | $754,508 | - | - |
| Mar 2024 | $755,728 | - | - |
| Feb 2024 | $746,426 | - | - |
| Jan 2024 | $763,524 | - | - |
| Dec 2023 | $740,753 | - | - |
| Nov 2023 | $778,626 | - | - |
| Oct 2023 | $743,230 | - | - |
| Sep 2023 | $801,876 | - | - |
| Aug 2023 | $793,807 | - | - |
| Jul 2023 | $797,482 | - | - |
| Jun 2023 | $798,041 | - | - |
| May 2023 | $806,793 | - | - |
| Apr 2023 | $842,229 | - | - |
| Mar 2023 | $876,247 | - | - |
*Market History, including Median Sales Price per square foot, and Single Family Homes Sold is based on historical data of Zip Code: 46220 - IN
Population & Environment
Source: Sperling's Best Places
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 35,938 | 878,825 | 967,013 | 335,858,263 |
| Population Density | 3,028 | 2,432 | 2,440 | 95 |
| People per Household | 2.1 | 2.4 | 2.4 | 2.6 |
| Median Age | 39.6 | 37.1 | 37.2 | 39.1 |
| Median Income | $77,804 | $50,097 | $50,415 | $66,222 |
| Average Income | $50,815 | $29,114 | $29,251 | $35,475 |
| Cost of Living Index | 77 | 82 | 82 | 100 |
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January Avg. High Temp | 17°F | 18°F | 18°F | 22.6°F |
| July Avg. High Temp | 84.5°F | 84°F | 84°F | 86.2°F |
| Annual Precipitation | 42.85" | 40.24" | 40.24" | 38" |
Click Zestimate price to view details on Zillow. Zestimate data is provided "as is" via the Zestimate API. © Zillow, Inc., 2006-2022. Use is subject to Terms of Use.
Nearby Properties
-
$1,579,000 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 4,133 sqft
5320 Central Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Step into one of Meridian Kessler's most exceptional properties - a truly one-of-a-kind, custom-built home reimagined from the ground up by the architectural visionary at Trade Design Studio and custom home builder JB Partners. Blending historic Tu...Listing by: Kyle Peckinpaugh - F.C. Tucker Company -
$615,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,869 sqft
5543 N Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220
This beautiful multi-level home awaits you on coveted Pennsylvania Street in Meridian Kessler neighborhood. New roof installed Nov. 2025. This nontraditional home features an open living room, dining room, and updated kitchen on the main floor. Upsta...Listing by: Andrea Casper - F.C. Tucker Company -
$1,950 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1,064 sqft
5446 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Wonderful fully furnished home is ready for move in. The kitchen provides a culinary space designed for both functionality and aesthetic appeal, featuring elegant stone countertops that offer plentiful workspace and shaker cabinets complemented by a...Listing by: Laura Bonner - RE/MAX At The Crossing -
$191,000 Active1 bds • 1 ba • 659 sqft
5347 N College Avenue 214, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Location, Location, Location! This beautifully renovated 1 bed, 1 bath condo in the heart of Broad Ripple is within walking distance of shops, restaurants, entertainment, Fresh Market, the Red Line, the Monon Trail, and more! Located in a charming hi...Listing by: Jacob Ellis - Blue Sky Realty Group -
$194,900 Active1 bds • 1 ba • 770 sqft
5347 N College Avenue 202, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Walkable convenience and charm, a prime location in a destination neighborhood, and unbeatable value - College Courts Unit 202 has it all. Bright and inviting, with original hardwoods, arched doorways, and high ceilings throughout; brand-new kitchen...Listing by: Mary Stanley - CENTURY 21 Scheetz -
$1,000 Active1 bds • 1 ba • 600 sqft
5303 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Beautifully updated rental in a great location. Just to the south of all that Broad Ripple has to offer. Great walkability to the many restaurants, shops and grocery store nearby. Red Line bus transit conveniently located just steps away.Listing by: Glenn Bill - eXp Realty, LLC -
$389,900 Active2 bds • 1 ba • 1,078 sqft
5515 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Nestled in SoBro, this freshly painted inside and out single-family residence with a new roof offers an inviting home that is ready to move in. Imagine relaxing in the sunroom, a bright space to enjoy a morning beverage or a quiet read. The living r...Listing by: Christopher Chabenne - Kosene & Kosene Residential -
$425,000 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1,404 sqft
5527 Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Charming, Fully Updated Bungalow in the Heartbeat of SoBro Welcome to your dream bungalow in one of Indy's most walkable neighborhoods. Nestled along tree-lined streets, this 2-bed, 2-bath gem has been completely transformed with new electrical, p...Listing by: Laura Waters - Highgarden Real Estate -
$886,500 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 3,244 sqft
22 W 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Storybook charm meets modern function in this updated Meridian-Kessler classic. From its iconic 1930s brick facade to its sleek 4-car garage with glass doors and a custom dog wash, this home blends warmth and utility in all the right ways. Inside, or...Listing by: Brian Wayman - CENTURY 21 Scheetz -
$525,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,581 sqft
5680 N Delaware Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220
This Meridian-Kessler charmer, ideally situated on one of the neighborhood's most sought-after blocks, is an absolute must-see. The recently added front patio sets an idyllic scene for enjoying the vibrant community. Step inside to a home thoughtfull...Listing by: Matt McLaughlin - F.C. Tucker Company -
$560,000 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 2,965 sqft
406 E 51st Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Christmas Came Early in Meridian-Kessler // This home is full of space, character, and potential wrapped up with a bow and waiting for someone ready to make it shine. Nestled in one of Indy's most beloved neighborhoods, this two story home with an at...Listing by: Lesli Gibson - Maywright Property Co. -
$639,900 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 4,133 sqft
5144 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
NEW PRICE!! This house is the perfect blend of classic features & quality updates. It starts with the all-brick exterior & large covered front porch complete with a tiled floor & bead board ceiling. There's a nice 2-car garage & privacy fence in bac...Listing by: Adam Corya - Carpenter, REALTORS® -
$599,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,966 sqft
206 E 51st Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
This charming 3-bedroom all-brick home blends timeless character with thoughtful updates. Step in from the covered front porch to find rich hardwood floors that flow throughout the main level. The spacious family room centers around a cozy wood-burni...Listing by: Justin Steill - Berkshire Hathaway Home -
$615,000 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 3,141 sqft
5678 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
This stunning 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath townhouse offers bright, open living in Meridian-Kessler! With three finished levels, this spacious 2-story home features a full basement and is loaded with high-end finishes throughout. Enjoy luxury vinyl plank floo...Listing by: Mike Feldman - Compass Indiana, LLC -
$269,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,140 sqft
916 E 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Take a look at this 3 bedroom 2 bathroom in the stellar SoBro location. This home has been recently renovated making it move in ready! 2 full bathrooms with tub and shower combos, updated flooring, spacious kitchen, and more. Spend your evenings taki...Listing by: Barry Hines - Realty Wealth Advisors -
$1,145 Active2 bds • 1 ba • 2,028 sqft
5338 Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Experience the charm of this cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom duplex in Indianapolis. With inviting living space, this home combines comfort and style, perfect for relaxation and enjoyment. The open layout offers a warm atmosphere, natural light, and a kit...Listing by: Maxwell Richter - Wilmoth Group -
$1,850 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,550 sqft
5033 N Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
A great opportunity to live in one of Indianapolis' finest neighborhoods. Close to resturants, a bank, hardwood store and more. Inside you will find an competely remolded interior with hardwood floors, kitchen open to the dinning room, nice outdoor...Listing by: John Creamer - CENTURY 21 Scheetz -
$525,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,316 sqft
5506 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Beautifully updated Cape Cod in the heart of Butler-Tarkington, just steps from the charm of 56th & Illinois. Meticulously maintained and extensively improved to blend historic character with modern upgrades, including a full kitchen renovation in 20...Listing by: Roger Lundy - Keller Williams Indpls Metro N -
$965,000 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 3,341 sqft
5017 N Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Just steps from the coveted 49th Street retail corridor, this exquisite 1927 home blends the grace of classic architecture with the sophistication of modern design. Every inch has been reimagined with artistry and intention - from the custom millwork...Listing by: Kristian Gaynor - F.C. Tucker Company -
$1,450 Active2 bds • 1 ba • 1,508 sqft
77 W Westfield Boulevard, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Nestled at 77 W Westfield BLVD, INDIANAPOLIS, IN, this single-family residence offers an inviting home, ready for you to move in and make it your own. The kitchen presents a space where culinary aspirations come to life, enhanced by stylish shaker c...Listing by: Evona Watson - Triple E Realty, LLC
Nearby Locations
Communities
- Augusta / New Augusta Homes For Sale
- Shelborne Green Homes For Sale
- Grandview Homes For Sale
- Broadmoor Homes For Sale
- Foxwood Homes For Sale
- Meridian Homes For Sale
- Meridian Meadows Homes For Sale
- Wellington Homes For Sale
- Nora Homes For Sale
- Cornerstone Place Homes For Sale
- Butler-Tarkington Homes For Sale
- Wolfington Homes For Sale
- Lafayette Square Homes For Sale
- Bellwood Homes For Sale
- Uptown Homes For Sale
- Dawnbury-Keystone Homes For Sale
- Hamilton Wood Homes For Sale
- Clifton Homes For Sale
- Armstrong Park Homes For Sale
- Crown Hill Homes For Sale
Nearby Zips
- 46260 Homes For Sale
- 46268 Homes For Sale
- 46228 Homes For Sale
- 46032 Homes For Sale
- 46240 Homes For Sale
- 46208 Homes For Sale
- 46254 Homes For Sale
- 46280 Homes For Sale
- 46278 Homes For Sale
- 46205 Homes For Sale
- 46220 Homes For Sale
- 46222 Homes For Sale
- 46077 Homes For Sale
- 46224 Homes For Sale
- 46202 Homes For Sale
- 46250 Homes For Sale
- 46288 Homes For Sale
- 46218 Homes For Sale
- 46033 Homes For Sale
- 46074 Homes For Sale
Nearby Cities
- Carmel, IN Homes for Sale
- Speedway, IN Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis, IN Homes for Sale
- Westfield, IN Homes for Sale
- Zionsville, IN Homes for Sale
- Brownsburg, IN Homes for Sale
- Lawrence, IN Homes for Sale
- Beech Grove, IN Homes for Sale
- Avon, IN Homes for Sale
- Noblesville, IN Homes for Sale
- Fishers, IN Homes for Sale
- Plainfield, IN Homes for Sale
- Lebanon, IN Homes for Sale
- Greenwood, IN Homes for Sale
- Danville, IN Homes for Sale
- Franklin, IN Homes for Sale
- Greenfield, IN Homes for Sale
- Frankfort, IN Homes for Sale
- Martinsville, IN Homes for Sale
- Anderson, IN Homes for Sale
Similar Searches
- Indianapolis Land for Sale
- Indianapolis New Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Single Story Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Homes with Pools for Sale
- Indianapolis Cheap Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Luxury Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Condos for Sale
- Indianapolis Town Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Commercial for Sale
- Indianapolis Open Houses for Sale
- Indianapolis Two Car Garage Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Large Lots for Sale