The property at 2537 W Gary Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012, built in 1992, is a 2,128 square foot Single Family and has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. It is situated on a lot that is 10,062 square feet and was last tax assessed in 2023 for a valuation of $241,752
The estimate for this property has experienced a 4.46% increase in the past 6 months reaching a value of $300,930.
- OK
- Broken Arrow
- 2537 W Gary St
- Parcel Number82170-84-21-73370
- CountyTULSA
- Stories1
Property Tax History
Source: Public Records
| Year | Assessment |
|---|---|
| 2023 | $25,410 +5.00% |
| 2022 | $24,200 +29.41% |
| 2018 | $18,700 |
| 2017 | $18,700 |
| 2015 | $18,700 +13.33% |
| 2013 | $16,500 |
Valuation History
Source: Public Records
| Month | Valuation | Single Family Homes Sold | Median Sales Price/Sqft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 2025 | $300,930 | - | - |
| Nov 2025 | $306,497 | - | - |
| Oct 2025 | $300,783 | - | - |
| Sep 2025 | $297,436 | - | - |
| Aug 2025 | $298,662 | - | - |
| Jul 2025 | $296,729 | - | - |
| Jun 2025 | $288,150 | - | - |
| May 2025 | $288,088 | - | - |
| Apr 2025 | $277,689 | - | - |
| Mar 2025 | $274,649 | - | - |
| Feb 2025 | $262,232 | - | - |
| Jan 2025 | $262,074 | - | - |
| Dec 2024 | $246,562 | - | - |
| Nov 2024 | $243,550 | - | - |
| Oct 2024 | $237,544 | - | - |
| Sep 2024 | $225,457 | - | - |
| Aug 2024 | $223,600 | - | - |
| Jul 2024 | $217,528 | - | - |
| Jun 2024 | $219,521 | - | - |
| May 2024 | $211,847 | - | - |
| Apr 2024 | $210,487 | - | - |
| Mar 2024 | $210,828 | - | - |
| Feb 2024 | $208,966 | - | - |
| Jan 2024 | $234,599 | - | - |
| Dec 2023 | $303,934 | - | - |
| Nov 2023 | $250,792 | - | - |
| Oct 2023 | $259,324 | - | - |
| Sep 2023 | $247,209 | - | - |
| Aug 2023 | $319,761 | - | - |
| Jul 2023 | $321,560 | - | - |
| Jun 2023 | $309,933 | - | - |
| May 2023 | $310,069 | - | - |
| Apr 2023 | $306,840 | - | - |
| Mar 2023 | $301,093 | - | - |
| Feb 2023 | $260,000 | - | - |
| Jan 2023 | $275,500 | - | - |
*Market History, including Median Sales Price per square foot, and Single Family Homes Sold is based on historical data of Zip Code: 74012 - OK
Population & Environment
Source: Sperling's Best Places
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 66,742 | 119,215 | 661,692 | 335,858,263 |
| Population Density | 2,683 | 1,875 | 1,160 | 95 |
| People per Household | 2.7 | 2.7 | 2.5 | 2.6 |
| Median Age | 37.5 | 38 | 37.3 | 39.1 |
| Median Income | $70,272 | $73,772 | $58,079 | $66,222 |
| Average Income | $32,301 | $33,636 | $33,110 | $35,475 |
| Cost of Living Index | 97 | 98 | 87 | 100 |
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January Avg. High Temp | 23.5°F | 23.5°F | 26.3°F | 22.6°F |
| July Avg. High Temp | 92.9°F | 92.9°F | 93.8°F | 86.2°F |
| Annual Precipitation | 40.46" | 40.46" | 42.42" | 38" |
Click Zestimate price to view details on Zillow. Zestimate data is provided "as is" via the Zestimate API. © Zillow, Inc., 2006-2022. Use is subject to Terms of Use.
Nearby Properties
-
$250,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,640 sqft
3209 S FIR Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Welcome to this adorable and well-maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home nestled in the highly desired Wolf Creek neighborhood. From the moment you step inside, you’ll feel the warmth and comfort this home offers with its inviting layout, natural ligh...Listing by: Jaybee Hawkins - eXp Realty, LLC -
$315,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,374 sqft
2508 W Kent Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
This exceptional 3/2.5/2 home is almost too good to be true & move-in ready! Lovingly-maintained & this list proves it: BRAND NEW thermal vinyl windows (with transferrable lifetime warranty); roof 2019; sprinkler system (front & back) 2024; newer Sta...Listing by: Juli Edwards - Keller Williams Premier -
New$225,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,333 sqft
2705 W Laredo Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Charming Home in Broken Arrow Schools! This cozy home offers comfort, style, and updates throughout! Enjoy relaxing by the wood-burning fireplace or cooking in the adorable kitchen featuring granite countertops, updates appliances, and modern tile b...Listing by: Erica Kiefer - Cochran & Co Realtors -
$495,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,916 sqft
2901 S Gardenia Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
SELLER TO PAY $10,000 buyer closing costs with acceptable offer by 12/24/2025! Assumable FHA loan with 3.125% interest rate! Welcome to this stunning home on a one-third acre corner lot in the highly sought-after Rushbrooke North neighborhood of Brok...Listing by: Amy Cavallin - Keller Williams Advantage -
$390,000 Active Under Contract4 bds • 3 ba • 2,172 sqft
3610 S Fir Court, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Feels like new construction! Single story home in The Village at Southern Trails that sits in a Cul-de sac. Home features 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, Office, 2 car garage, and an open concept Living/Kitchen combo. Large dining Nook, Kitchen with large...Listing by: Jessica Scott - Keller Williams Advantage & CG Realty Group LLC -
$265,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,526 sqft
2712 S Fir Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Welcome to this stunning, completely renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home located in a quiet, established neighborhood within the highly sought-after Broken Arrow School District. Step inside to discover a bright, open-concept living space featuring vaul...Listing by: Carol Pankey-Davis - Keller Williams Advantage -
$225,000 Active3 bds • 1 ba • 1,050 sqft
2508 S Walnut Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
You gave us feedback and we listened! New tile on fireplace new mirror in bathroom and more cam lights in bathroom. Charming and fully renovated 3 bedroom 1 bath home with an open floor plan, offering a beautifully updated living space. This move in...Listing by: Claire Fey - Keller Williams Advantage -
New$315,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,671 sqft
2904 W Canton Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
PRICED TO SELL!! Welcome home to this lovingly updated home in the desirable Wolf Creek neighborhood. You'll be minutes from the Creek Turnpike, Elam Park, the Shops at Aspen Creek and the new Hackberry Market as well as a short drive to Broken Arr...Listing by: Pam Willson - Cochran & Co Realtors -
$448,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,428 sqft
3729 S Elder Boulevard, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Fabulous home in popular Southern Trails! Three bedroom plus office with 2 1/2 bath. Spacious split plan with hardwoods in living area. Formal dining and breakfast nook, it's everything you've been looking for. Professionally landscaped with sprinkle...Listing by: Peter Tamura - Coldwell Banker Select -
$169,000 Active Under Contract2 bds • 2 ba • 1,184 sqft
2441 W Quantico Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath home in the heart of Broken Arrow! The bright living area features a cozy fireplace and vaulted ceilings that create an open, airy feel. The updated kitchen shines with newer appliances and granite coun...Listing by: Jaybee Hawkins - eXp Realty, LLC & Hickerson Realty -
$287,000 Active Under Contract4 bds • 2 ba • 2,200 sqft
2323 W Atlanta Court, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY 12/7/25 2PM-4PM! Welcome to this beautifully maintained home in the highly desired Brentwood subdivision of Broken Arrow! Perfectly located close to shopping, dining, and all the conveniences of town. Nestled on nearly one-third of...Listing by: Jessica Wilbourn - Coldwell Banker Select -
$221,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,382 sqft
2613 S Sycamore Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Discover this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch tucked at the end of a peaceful cul-de-sac in one of Broken Arrow's friendliest neighborhoods. Recently renovated and designed for effortless living, this 1,382 sqft (CH) home welcomes you wit...Listing by: Kevin Abbott - Keller Williams Premier -
$519,900 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,814 sqft
3922 S Dogwood Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
2732 Plan || New STRAIGHT style exterior || TRANSITIONAL interior finishes. EXECUTIVE QUALITY. READY NOW! With over 2,500+ on-time closings and counting, our turnkey experience guarantees exceptional quality at an unbeatable value. Our commitment to...Listing by: Alex Trinidad - Executive Homes Realty, LLC -
$299,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 2,358 sqft
2416 S Elder Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
20k PRICE DECREASE! Completely Remodeled Home in the Heart of Broken Arrow. This beautifully updated home is move-in ready, featuring fresh paint inside and out, a fully remodeled interior, and brand-new stainless steel appliances, including a refrig...Listing by: Tony Georr - eXp Realty, LLC (BO) -
$494,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,486 sqft
2722 W Roanoke Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Executive Homes’ 2414 Plan || Award-winning ORIGINAL style exterior || TRANSITIONAL interior finishes. EXECUTIVE QUALITY. READY NOW! With over 2,500+ on-time closings and counting, Executive’s turnkey experience guarantees exceptional quality at an u...Listing by: Alex Trinidad - Executive Homes Realty, LLC -
New$199,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,547 sqft
2240 W Quantico Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Listing by: Dawn Faust - Flat Fee Discount Realty -
$275,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,892 sqft
4000 S Chestnut Avenue, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in a prime Broken Arrow location. Step into the welcoming foyer and enjoy fresh paint throughout and brand-new hardwood floors. The open living room with fireplace flows to the kitchen with...Listing by: Jaybee Hawkins - eXp Realty, LLC -
$599,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 2,158 sqft
3406 W Quantico Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Ultra Luxury Living in this Exclusive Gated Community! Gorgeous Water View! Like-New, One Level Custom Home. Stunning high-end features and finishes, move-in condition. The spacious living features soaring ceilings with beautiful beam work and floor-...Listing by: Trish Allison - Coldwell Banker Select -
$423,500 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1,925 sqft
3610 W Laredo Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Discover refined living in this brand-new, one-level villa nestled in an exclusive gated community that offers the perfect blend of elegance, comfort, and convenience. This thoughtfully designed home features 2 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, plus flex r...Listing by: Gayle Roberts-Pisklo - Chinowth & Cohen -
$433,500 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1,925 sqft
3709 W Laredo Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Discover refined living in this new construction one level Villa. This plan does feature a full staircase for over the garage floored area with expansion or finish out option available. The gated community offering the perfect blend of comfort and co...Listing by: Gayle Roberts-Pisklo - Chinowth & Cohen
Nearby Locations
Communities
- Indian Springs Estates Homes For Sale
- Twin Creeks Homes For Sale
- Battle Creek Homes For Sale
- Burning Tree Housing Addition Homes For Sale
- Stone Creek Farms Homes For Sale
- Chimney Hills Estates Homes For Sale
- Chimney Hills Homes For Sale
- Forest Park S Homes For Sale
- Burning Tree W Homes For Sale
- Woodland Homes For Sale
- Briarglen Homes For Sale
- Highfield Homes For Sale
- Tower Heights Homes For Sale
- Lynn Lane Homes For Sale
- Boman Acres Homes For Sale
- Rose Dew Homes For Sale
- Hoover Homes For Sale
- South Peoria Homes For Sale
- North Tulsa Homes For Sale
- Heller Park Homes For Sale
Nearby Zips
- 74011 Homes For Sale
- 74012 Homes For Sale
- 74133 Homes For Sale
- 74008 Homes For Sale
- 74134 Homes For Sale
- 74146 Homes For Sale
- 74145 Homes For Sale
- 74137 Homes For Sale
- 74014 Homes For Sale
- 74129 Homes For Sale
- 74108 Homes For Sale
- 74136 Homes For Sale
- 74128 Homes For Sale
- 74135 Homes For Sale
- 74429 Homes For Sale
- 74112 Homes For Sale
- 74037 Homes For Sale
- 74105 Homes For Sale
- 74114 Homes For Sale
- 74015 Homes For Sale
Nearby Cities
- Broken Arrow, OK Homes for Sale
- Bixby, OK Homes for Sale
- Tulsa, OK Homes for Sale
- Jenks, OK Homes for Sale
- Glenpool, OK Homes for Sale
- Owasso, OK Homes for Sale
- Sapulpa, OK Homes for Sale
- Sand Springs, OK Homes for Sale
- Claremore, OK Homes for Sale
- Okmulgee, OK Homes for Sale
- Muskogee, OK Homes for Sale
- Tahlequah, OK Homes for Sale
Similar Searches
- Broken Arrow Land for Sale
- Broken Arrow New Homes for Sale
- Broken Arrow Single Story Homes for Sale
- Broken Arrow Homes with Pools for Sale
- Broken Arrow Cheap Homes for Sale
- Broken Arrow Luxury Homes for Sale
- Broken Arrow Condos for Sale
- Broken Arrow Town Homes for Sale
- Broken Arrow Commercial for Sale
- Broken Arrow Open Houses for Sale
- Broken Arrow Two Car Garage Homes for Sale
- Broken Arrow Large Lots for Sale