Price Reduced23
$249,900
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,518 sqft
420 Phelps Drive, New Castle, IN
Michael McKown · F.C. Tucker/Crossroads · on 2 MLSs
No listing photos
3
Beds
1
Baths
1,496
Sqft
1925
Year built
Range $229,704 – $277,458 · as of August 30, 2026
ATTOM automated valuation model · 55 published estimates over 6.7 years
Highest reading $267,204 in May 2026; lowest $154,577 in February 2020. The vertical scale starts at the series' own low, not at zero — it is drawn to show movement, not absolute size.
$50,716
Estimated monthly payment
$1,754/mo
Loan amount $202,865. Estimate only — your actual rate and payment depend on credit, location, and lender.
2025 roll
Within 2 miles of this home: 35 restaurants and cafés, 3 grocery stores, and 3 parks and green spaces.
Place data from OpenStreetMap.
Lee's Famous Recipe Chicken
Sake Japanese Hibachi and Sushi
Japanese restaurant
Taco Bell
South Memorial Drive
Mancino's Pizza & Grinders
Papa John's
South Memorial Drive
The Grind
Temptations
Arby's
South Memorial Drive
Walmart Supercenter
South State Road 3
ALDI
South Memorial Drive
Kroger
South Memorial Drive
Trojan Woods Nature Preserve
Baker Park
Babe Ruth Park
Indiana Regional MLSMIBOR Broker Listing CooperativeSome properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.
Price Reduced23$249,900
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,518 sqft
420 Phelps Drive, New Castle, IN
Michael McKown · F.C. Tucker/Crossroads · on 2 MLSs
36$250,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,006 sqft
1127 Hickory Lane, New Castle, IN
Beth Carr · RE/MAX First Integrity · on 2 MLSs
Price Reduced28$179,900
4 bd · 3 ba · 1,843 sqft
1930-1932 Fairmont Avenue, New Castle, IN
Jason Loveless · F.C. Tucker/Crossroads · on 2 MLSs
17$189,900
4 bd · 2 ba · — sqft
2107 Plum Street, New Castle, IN
on 2 MLSs
Price Reduced30$215,000
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,359 sqft
1605 Cedar Drive, New Castle, IN
Norris Teeters Jr. · REMAX ONE
41$259,900
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,528 sqft
1996 W Railroad Street, New Castle, IN
Krista Gibson · RE/MAX First Integrity
School ratings (A+ to F) from HJN community data.
James Whitcomb Riley Elementary School
PK-6 · Regular · New Castle Community School Corporation
246 students · 14.5:1 student–teacher
New Castle High School
9-12 · Regular · New Castle Community School Corporation
828 students · 11.5:1 student–teacher
New Castle Area Vocational School
6-12 · Vocational Education · New Castle Community School Corporation
New Castle Middle School
6-8 · Regular · New Castle Community School Corporation
627 students · 11.4:1 student–teacher
Parker Elementary School
PK-5 · Regular · New Castle Community School Corporation
278 students · 12.5:1 student–teacher
Agape Learning Center
PK-KG · Early Childhood Program/Child Care Center
10 students · 10.0:1 student–teacher
Eastwood Elementary School
PK-6 · Regular · New Castle Community School Corporation
257 students · 9.8:1 student–teacher
Westwood Elementary School
KG-6 · Regular · New Castle Community School Corporation
256 students · 15.1:1 student–teacher