Loads of character in this 4 bedroom Butler / Tarkington home including original wood work & hardwood floors under the carpet, exposed beams and built ins. Updated kitchen with oak cabinets, center island and all appliances stay. Spacious family room w/gas fireplace, leading into a large dining room. Separate living room. Partially finished basement. Desirable 2 car garage w/bump out. Enjoy the outdoor living from the large covered front porch or the multi tiered rear deck. Private and fully fenced rear yard. Updated vinyl windows.Water heater (2023). Home needs updating, bring your imagination and turn this home into a gorgeous gem.
- IN
- Indianapolis
- 46208
- 4224 Cornelius Avenue
- MLS# 21955184
- Date Listed11/30/2023
- Bedrooms 4
- Bathrooms 1 Full baths, 1 Half baths
- Lot Size 0.2 acres (8,799 sq. ft)
- Subdivision A V Browns Fairmount
- Property Type Single Family
- County Marion
- Year Built 1901
- Water Public
- Square Feet 2,244 sq. ft
- Price Per Sq. Ft $138.15
Interior Features
- Appliances Freezer, Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Free- Standing Freezer, Washer
- Flooring Hardwood
- Cooling Central Air
- Heating Forced Air
Exterior / Lot Features
- Roof -
- Lot Size Acres 0.20
- Lot Size SQFT 8,799.00
- Lot Features -
Directions
Heading North on Meridian from 38th, head west (left) on 40th, turn right (north) on Cornelius Ave, home will be on your left side.
Financial Considerations
Sales & Tax History
Source: Public Records
| Year | Taxes | Land | Additions | Total Assessments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | $2,290.84 20.46% | $21,200 | $172,900 | $194,100 |
| 2021 | $1,822.22 9.36% | $21,200 | $172,900 | $194,100 |
| 2020 | $1,651.60 8.85% | $21,200 | $138,200 | $159,400 |
| 2019 | $1,505.50 7.34% | $21,200 | $123,500 | $144,700 |
| 2018 | $1,395.00 | $21,200 | $109,300 | $130,500 |
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 01/22/2024 | Pending | $310,000.00 |
| 12/18/2023 | Active | $310,000.00 4.62% |
| 11/30/2023 | Active | $325,000.00 |
| Street Address | Beds | Baths | Sold Date | List Price | Valuation Date | Valuation Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1430 W 31st Street | Listing | 4 | 2 | Nov 19, 2025 | $199,900 | Mar 21, 2024 | $26,140 |
| 1280 W 29th Street | 3 | 2 | Nov 19, 2025 | $117,000 | Dec 16, 2025 | - |
| 1176 Udell Street | Listing | 4 | 2 | Nov 19, 2025 | $65,000 | Mar 21, 2024 | $85,440 |
| 4224 Cornelius Avenue | 4 | 2 | Nov 19, 2025 | $310,000 | Dec 16, 2025 | - |
| 4005 Guilford Avenue | Listing | 3 | 3 | Nov 19, 2025 | $389,900 | Nov 20, 2023 | $419,110 |
| 3221 N Kenwood Avenue | Listing | 4 | 3 | Nov 24, 2025 | $219,900 | Mar 21, 2024 | $205,568 |
| 4802 Guilford Avenue | Listing | 3 | 2 | Nov 19, 2025 | $350,000 | Feb 23, 2024 | $264,223 |
| 4906 N Kenwood Avenue | Listing | 2 | 2 | Nov 19, 2025 | $320,000 | Feb 15, 2023 | $293,700 |
| 2927 Boulevard Place | Listing | 4 | 3 | Nov 19, 2025 | $260,000 | Mar 21, 2024 | $129,264 |
| 1306 Congress Avenue | 3 | 1 | Oct 22, 2025 | $125,900 | Dec 16, 2025 | - |
Population & Environment
Source: Sperling's Best Places
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 23,539 | 878,825 | 967,013 | 335,858,263 |
| Population Density | 3,417 | 2,432 | 2,440 | 95 |
| People per Household | 2.2 | 2.4 | 2.4 | 2.6 |
| Median Age | 34.1 | 37.1 | 37.2 | 39.1 |
| Median Income | $44,034 | $50,097 | $50,415 | $66,222 |
| Average Income | $32,209 | $29,114 | $29,251 | $35,475 |
| Cost of Living Index | 74 | 82 | 82 | 100 |
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January Avg. High Temp | 18.5°F | 18°F | 18°F | 22.6°F |
| July Avg. High Temp | 85.6°F | 84°F | 84°F | 86.2°F |
| Annual Precipitation | 40.95" | 40.24" | 40.24" | 38" |
40/100
Car-Dependent
Walk Score ®
34/100
Some Transit
Transit Score ®
44/100
Bikable
Bike Score ®
Overview
Most errands require a car. A few nearby public transportation options. Minimal bike infrastructure.Transit Summary
5 nearby routes: 5 bus, 0 rail, 0 other
Walkability averages in the surrounding area
The average walkability score in the surrounding area is Walk Score: 40/100, Transit Score: 32/100, Bike Score: 50/100.
Property Change History
Points of Interest near 4224 Cornelius Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208
581 ft
Distance
634 ft
Distance
686 ft
Distance
739 ft
Distance
0.31 mi
Distance
0.34 mi
Distance
0.28 mi
Distance
0.31 mi
Distance
0.34 mi
Distance
0.36 mi
Distance
0.39 mi
Distance
0.41 mi
Distance
317 ft
Distance
581 ft
Distance
0.4 mi
Distance
528 ft
Distance
686 ft
Distance
686 ft
Distance
1003 ft
Distance
0.33 mi
Distance
0.33 mi
Distance
0.3 mi
Distance
0.34 mi
Distance
Nearby Properties
-
$265,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 1,999 sqft
4061 Byram Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Welcome to this charming and cozy 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home nestled in the highly desirable Butler-Tarkington neighborhood! Offering the perfect blend of space and comfort, this home features a thoughtful layout with warm, inviting living areas an...Listing by: Malinda Ennis - Keller Williams Indy Metro NE -
$349,900 Active5 bds • 1 ba • 2,054 sqft
104 E 38th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Current leases gross $3K/month. Endless potential meets prime location with this rare 5-bedroom ranch in the heart of Indianapolis. Currently utilized as a daycare, this property offers flexibility unlike anything else on the market-residential, comm...Listing by: Eric Forney - Keller Williams Indy Metro S -
$320,000 Active5 bds • 2 ba • 2,296 sqft
617 E 37th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Located at 617 E 37th ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN, WINDOWS, WINDOWS, WINDOWS....GORGEOUS HARDWOOD FLOORS, BUILT INS.... this single-family residence in Marion County presents an exciting opportunity to own a piece of classic American architecture. Built in...Listing by: Delores Kennedy - B & K Realty, Inc -
$300,000 Active5 bds • 4 ba • 2,296 sqft
940 W 34th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
***SELLER OFFERING CONCESSIONS FOR BUY DOWN OF INTEREST RATE*** Beautifully renovated former duplex, now a spacious 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath single-family home in the heart of Indianapolis! This thoughtfully reimagined property offers flexibility, room to...Listing by: Vicki Reed - Keller Williams Indy Metro NE -
$334,900 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 2,491 sqft
1141 W 35th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Welcome to this beautiful 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offering over 2,400 square feet of versatile living space. Step inside to an open-concept main floor that seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas, creating an ideal space for entert...Listing by: Candice Childs - Scott Estates -
$329,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,352 sqft
3601 Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
How many fully updated 2,000 square foot homes with 4 beds and 2.5 bathrooms become available within 10 minutes from: Butler University, Broad Ripple, Mass Ave, and a 1 minute walk from the Monon trail?! The answer is obviously very few, but you alr...Listing by: Laura Booram - @properties -
$324,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 2,247 sqft
4422 Edinburgh Point, Indianapolis, IN 46228
Serene Living in Holcomb Estates - Now Available! Discover this impeccably maintained condominium nestled in the sought-after Holcomb Estates community. Featuring 2 spacious bedrooms plus a versatile den complete with a working wet bar, this home of...Listing by: Sunny Shuai - F.C. Tucker Company -
$299,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,544 sqft
3307 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Centrally Located and Fully Renovated, this 3-Bedroom, 3-Full Bath Home Offers Exceptional Space and a Seamless Layout Designed for Modern Living. Undergoing a comprehensive renovation in 2018, the home features completely updated electrical, plumbin...Listing by: Steve Lew - Steve Lew Real Estate Group, LLC -
$278,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,995 sqft
3216 Broadway Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
SELLER OFFERING $2,500 TOWARD BUYER'S CLOSING COSTS, RATE BUYDOWN, OR PREPAID ITEMS, AND PROVIDING A 1-YEAR HOME WARRANTY AT CLOSING. Discover the perfect blend of timeless character and modern comfort in this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath bungalow in t...Listing by: Jennifer Rumbaoa - Circle Real Estate -
$284,900 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,402 sqft
3031 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Welcome to 3031 North New Jersey Street, a beautifully renovated home in the heart of Indianapolis offering 4 spacious bedrooms, 3 stylish bathrooms, and a bright open-concept floor plan perfect for modern living. The chef's kitchen boasts a walk-in...Listing by: Hayley Wild - Compass Indiana, LLC -
$337,999 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,008 sqft
2943 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Experience a stunning transformation in this beautifully renovated modern home. Designed for worry-free living, this residence boasts 10' ceilings that enhance the spaciousness and charm of the main living area. The living room seamlessly transitions...Listing by: Bryce Higgins - eXp Realty, LLC -
$280,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,552 sqft
2936 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Welcome to this beautifully renovated gem nestled in the heart of the South Historic Meridian District.Listing by: Joshua Vida - Paradigm Realty Solutions -
$309,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,913 sqft
3033 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Fully updated and move-in ready, this stunning home at 3033 N College Avenue features three spacious bedrooms plus a loft, offering the perfect blend of style and functionality. Enjoy a gorgeous modern kitchen with sleek finishes and stainless steel...Listing by: Hayley Wild - Compass Indiana, LLC -
$270,000 Active5 bds • 2 ba • 2,132 sqft
1621 E 46th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
The single-family residence at 1621 E 46th ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN, offers an inviting home, ready for you to move in and begin creating memories. With five bedrooms, this home provides ample space for rest and rejuvenation, allowing each resident to p...Listing by: Mujo Hajiric - eXp Realty, LLC -
$299,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 2,280 sqft
534 W 26th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
This stunning, fully renovated home delivers the feel of modern new construction right in the heart of the city. Thoughtfully redesigned with new electrical, new plumbing, new HVAC, new wood, vinyl + concrete-fiber siding, new insulation, new drywall...Listing by: Guadalupe Ortiz - CENTURY 21 Scheetz -
$325,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,959 sqft
2936 Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Come check out this completely remodeled beautiful home located in Central Indy 8 minutes from Bottleworks District. This 3 Bedroom 3 Full Bath give a modern contemporary feel with recessed lighting starting with the extra-large porch expanding throu...Listing by: Deanna Whitlow - Forever Change LLC -
$300,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 2,000 sqft
2658 Burton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Welcome to 2658 Burton Ave, a charming single-family residence nestled in the heart of Indianapolis. This inviting home spans 2,000 square feet, offering ample space for comfort and convenience. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by an open and ai...Listing by: Brittany Perry - Compass Indiana, LLC -
$350,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 1,944 sqft
2732 Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Gorgeous 4 bed/ 2.5 bath home available! I mean look at that spire! Just off of Fall Creek and minutes from Downtown Indy. This home is beautifully updated and maintained and completely turn key! The large kitchen has granite countertops and all stai...Listing by: Paige Corbett - Compass Indiana, LLC -
$330,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 1,920 sqft
1263 W 26th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Located at 1263 W 26th ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN, this newly constructed single-family residence was built in November 2025. The kitchen is a culinary dream, defined by its elegant stone countertops and stylish shaker cabinets, all accented by sophistica...Listing by: Brenda Vance - Keller Williams Indpls Metro N -
$334,900 Active2 bds • 3 ba • 1,956 sqft
2319 N Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Be amazed by this beautiful 3 level historic home plus basement, built in 1900 and perfectly located in the highly sought-after Fall Creek Place. This gem blends historic character like beautiful hardwood floors and decorative woodwork with modern up...Listing by: Sherri Walstrom - Carpenter, REALTORS®
Similar Priced Comparison
-
$380,000 Active5 bds • 3 ba • 2227 sqft
4302 Cornelius Avenue
- Home smaller by 17 sqft
- Lot smaller by 2,047 sqft
- Newer by 26 years
Listing by: Steve Lew - Steve Lew Real Estate Group, LLC -
$259,500 Active3 bds • 1 ba • 1980 sqft
315 W 43rd Street
- Home smaller by 264 sqft
- Lot smaller by 2,788 sqft
- Newer by 42 years
Listing by: Loree Myers - Highgarden Real Estate -
$315,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1406 sqft
4205 Boulevard Place
- Home smaller by 838 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,615 sqft
- Newer by 19 years
Listing by: David C Brenton - DAVID BRENTON'S TEAM -
$335,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1805 sqft
244 W 43rd Street
- Home smaller by 439 sqft
- Lot smaller by 2,918 sqft
- Newer by 29 years
Listing by: Jacob Ellis - Blue Sky Realty Group -
$350,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1708 sqft
4260 Sunset Avenue
- Home smaller by 536 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,615 sqft
- Newer by 19 years
Listing by: Will Lonnemann - F.C. Tucker Company -
$265,000 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1115 sqft
4225 Graceland Avenue
- Home smaller by 1,129 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,615 sqft
- Newer by 34 years
Listing by: David Mann - Resolute Realty -
$365,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1618 sqft
530 W 41st Street
- Home smaller by 626 sqft
- Lot smaller by 6,185 sqft
- Newer by 124 years
Listing by: Emily Burford - @properties -
$375,000 Activebds • 0 ba • sqft
4113 Graceland Avenue
- Home smaller by 2,244 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,615 sqft
- Newer by 22 years
Listing by: Jeff Titsworth - Lake Homes Realty of Indiana -
$384,000 Activebds • 0 ba • sqft
4044 Boulevard Place
- Home smaller by 2,244 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,790 sqft
- Newer by 19 years
Listing by: Kenneth Hall - eXp Realty, LLC -
$265,000 Active4 bds • 3 ba • 1999 sqft
4061 Byram Avenue
- Home smaller by 245 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,790 sqft
- Newer by 19 years
Listing by: Malinda Ennis - Keller Williams Indy Metro NE -
$249,900 Activebds • 0 ba • sqft
3942 Cornelius Avenue
- Home smaller by 2,244 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,006 sqft
- Newer by 19 years
Listing by: Trent Kiester - @properties -
$318,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1650 sqft
4625 Rookwood Avenue
- Home smaller by 594 sqft
- Lot smaller by 2,788 sqft
- Newer by 14 years
Listing by: Jeremy Duling - White Stag Realty, LLC -
$349,900 Active5 bds • 1 ba • 2054 sqft
104 E 38th Street
- Home smaller by 190 sqft
- Lot larger by 4,179 sqft
- Newer by 9 years
Listing by: Eric Forney - Keller Williams Indy Metro S -
$317,500 Activebds • 0 ba • sqft
3547 N Illinois Street
- Home smaller by 2,244 sqft
- Lot smaller by 2,309 sqft
- Newer by 19 years
Listing by: Tyler Willis - @properties -
$235,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1508 sqft
3516 N Kenwood Avenue
- Home smaller by 736 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,528 sqft
- Newer by 118 years
Listing by: Michael Botkin - CENTURY 21 Scheetz -
$297,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1700 sqft
3455 N Illinois Street
- Home smaller by 544 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,746 sqft
- Newer by 124 years
Listing by: Fadi Aboudi - F.C. Tucker Company -
$325,000 Active5 bds • 4 ba • 3078 sqft
3970 Broadway Street
- Home larger by 834 sqft
- Lot smaller by 4,225 sqft
- Newer by 24 years
Listing by: Kyle Hoffman - @properties -
$319,900 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1621 sqft
5144 Patterson Street
- Home smaller by 623 sqft
- Lot larger by 5,955 sqft
- Newer by 67 years
Listing by: Tod Trafelet - Eco-Realty Partners, LLC -
$352,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1402 sqft
5308 Boulevard Place
- Home smaller by 842 sqft
- Lot smaller by 2,091 sqft
- Newer by 38 years
Listing by: Kimberly Walsh - Keller Williams Indy Metro NE -
$310,000 Activebds • 0 ba • sqft
4449 N College Avenue
- Home smaller by 2,244 sqft
- Lot smaller by 784 sqft
- Newer by 36 years
Listing by: Matt McLaughlin - F.C. Tucker Company
Nearby Locations
Communities
- Glendale Homes For Sale
- Riverside Homes For Sale
- Clifton Homes For Sale
- United Northwest Homes For Sale
- Armstrong Park Homes For Sale
- Rainbow Ridge Homes For Sale
- Wolfington Homes For Sale
- Mount Jackson Homes For Sale
- Lynhurst Homes For Sale
- Crown Hill Homes For Sale
- Kingpark Homes For Sale
- Mapelton Homes For Sale
- Butler-Tarkington Homes For Sale
- Belmont Homes For Sale
- Speedway Homes For Sale
- Broadmoor Homes For Sale
- Downtown Homes For Sale
- Mapleton Homes For Sale
- Old Northside Homes For Sale
- Fairview Station Homes For Sale
Nearby Zips
- 46222 Homes For Sale
- 46208 Homes For Sale
- 46202 Homes For Sale
- 46228 Homes For Sale
- 46224 Homes For Sale
- 46288 Homes For Sale
- 46225 Homes For Sale
- 46205 Homes For Sale
- 46254 Homes For Sale
- 46214 Homes For Sale
- 46201 Homes For Sale
- 46260 Homes For Sale
- 46218 Homes For Sale
- 46241 Homes For Sale
- 46268 Homes For Sale
- 46221 Homes For Sale
- 46220 Homes For Sale
- 46203 Homes For Sale
- 46234 Homes For Sale
- 46217 Homes For Sale
Nearby Cities
- Speedway, IN Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis, IN Homes for Sale
- Beech Grove, IN Homes for Sale
- Carmel, IN Homes for Sale
- Brownsburg, IN Homes for Sale
- Avon, IN Homes for Sale
- Miller, IN Homes for Sale
- Brown, IN Homes for Sale
- Plainfield, IN Homes for Sale
- Greenwood, IN Homes for Sale
- Lawrence, IN Homes for Sale
- Zionsville, IN Homes for Sale
- Whitestown, IN Homes for Sale
- Westfield, IN Homes for Sale
- Cumberland, IN Homes for Sale
- New Whiteland, IN Homes for Sale
- Bargersville, IN Homes for Sale
- Mooresville, IN Homes for Sale
- Pittsboro, IN Homes for Sale
- Whiteland, IN Homes for Sale
Similar Searches
- Indianapolis Land for Sale
- Indianapolis New Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Single Story Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Homes with Pools for Sale
- Indianapolis Cheap Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Luxury Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Condos for Sale
- Indianapolis Town Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Commercial for Sale
- Indianapolis Open Houses for Sale
- Indianapolis Two Car Garage Homes for Sale
- Indianapolis Large Lots for Sale
- National Listings
- National Home Values
- Properties in IN
- Home Values in IN
- Other properties in Marion, IN
- Other properties in 46208, IN
- Home Values in Indianapolis, IN
Frequently Asked Questions for 4224 Cornelius Avenue
Source: Realty.com
4224 Cornelius Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208 is a Single Family 2,244 sq. ft. home listed for sale. Realty.com has 40 photos available of this 4 bed, 2 bath house, listed at $310,000. View sales and tax history, use our mortgage calculator and more on Realty.com
Realty.com has 40 photos of 4224 Cornelius Avenue.
Our records indicate that 4224 Cornelius Avenue was built in 1901.
The full address for this home is 4224 Cornelius Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208.
4224 Cornelius Avenue has been listed on Realty.com since Thu November 30, 2023
Most errands require a car. A few nearby public transportation options. Minimal bike infrastructure.
The average walkability score in the surrounding area is Walk Score: 40/100, Transit Score: 32/100, Bike Score: 50/100.
Listing provided courtesy of:
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
(tel: 317-846-6300)
Listing agent:
Derek Gutting
(tel: 317-679-6767)
(#16455)
This content last refreshed on 2025-12-16 00:08:02. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.
Export listing data of 4224 Cornelius Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208 : MLS# 21955184