Map location of 17 May Street, St Augustine, FL 32084
$375,000
Unlock Price Rating!

17 May Street, St Augustine, FL 32084

 Contact
3 Beds
2 Baths
1,516 Sq Ft

Presiding under a stately live oak canopy, this circa 1935 cottage lives larger than it looks from the sidewalk. Sitting squarely in the center of a 1/4+ acre lot, the front, back and side yards offer abundant outdoor entertaining areas along with driveways on both May St and E San Carlos Ave. Enclosed front porch is now a sun room with early morning light and a golden glow in late afternoon. A short foyer leads to a generous living room where a gas fireplace patiently waits for cool nights. Windows line 3 walls on the north end and this naturally illuminated alcove holds a large couch perfectly. With room for at least 2 seating areas, living room opens to dining room keeping everyone in the mix during dinner parties. Original 2 bedrooms are on the west side flanking an updated bathroom also easily accessible to common rooms. Wood floors and period moldings run throughout all of these rooms except the bath. Kitchen is tucked between dining room and a laundry/mud room with wall of storage closets and the back door which leads to patio and garden. Just steps from kitchen to the east courtyard, outdoor meals are easy whether you're cooking inside or out. Master bedroom and bath are at the back for maximum privacy. If you're hoping for room to garden, grill, store your boat, build a garage, install a pool, this yard will be a dream come true. With equal parts of sun and shade, there's nothing stopping you except your imagination and there's already a large storage shed to keep tools and bikes clean and dry. May St side has a long driveway that can hold 2-3 cars in tandem while the E San Carlos end has a parking pad for 2. If you're looking for beach or public boat ramp, they are just minutes to the east. Stroll south on famous Magnolia Ave to San Marco and you'll find a modern-day Main St dotted with great food from fine dining to pizza, wine bar, ice cream, flower shop, boutiques, bookstore, hair salon, furniture and decor with downtown just a few blocks further.

Listing By: Irene Arriola - One Sotheby's - Downtown flstaug Realty.com
  • MLS# 188069
  • Date Listed06/14/2019
  • Bedrooms 3
  • Bathrooms 2 Full baths
  • Lot Size 0.27 acres (11,761 sq. ft)
  • Subdivision Nelmar Terrace
  • Property Type Single Family
  • County St. Johns
  • Year Built 1935
  • Water Public
  • Square Feet 1,516 sq. ft
  • Price Per Sq. Ft $247.36

Interior Features

  • Flooring Tile, Vinyl, Wood
  • Cooling Central Air
  • Heating Central, Electric

Exterior / Lot Features

  • Roof Metal
  • Lot Size Acres 0.27
  • Lot Size SQFT 11,761.20
  • Lot Features -

Directions

From San Marco Ave go east on May St to Magnolia Ave. Go south on Magnolia and immediately west on E San Carlos. Proceed till you see sign on the right and pull into driveway.

Financial Considerations

  • Tax Amount $2,011
  • Terms Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA Loan

Nearby Schools

Source: School Digger

St. Augustine Public Montessori School (sapms)

Public • PK - 6 • Serves this home

0.17 mi

Distance

Florida School For The Deaf And Blind

Public • PK - 12

0.17 mi

Distance

Deaf Elementary School (fsdb)

Public • PK - 5

0.17 mi

Distance

Blind Pk-8 School (fsdb)

Public • PK - 8

0.17 mi

Distance

Ketterlinus Elementary School

Public • PK - 5

0.97 mi

Distance

Crookshank Elementary School

Public • PK - 5

1.92 mi

Distance

Mky- Head Start /dpp Pk School

Public • PK - 5

3.4 mi

Distance

The Webster School

Public • PK - 5

3.4 mi

Distance

Osceola Elementary School

Public • PK - 5

4.4 mi

Distance

Therapeutic Learning Center

Public • PK - PK

7.2 mi

Distance

Deaf Middle School (fsdb)

Public • 6 - 8

0.17 mi

Distance

Sebastian Middle School

Public • 6 - 8 • Serves this home

1.48 mi

Distance

St. Johns Technical High School

Public • 6 - 12

2.98 mi

Distance

R J Murray Middle School

Public • 6 - 8

4.14 mi

Distance

Blind High School (fsdb)

Public • 9 - 12

0.17 mi

Distance

Deaf High School (fsdb)

Public • 9 - 12

0.17 mi

Distance

St. Johns Community Campus

Public • 9 - 12 • Serves this home

1.18 mi

Distance

St. Augustine High School

Public • 9 - 12

2.81 mi

Distance

Victory Preparatory School

Private • KG - 12

1.42 mi

Distance

Veritas Classical Private School Inc

Private • KG - 10

2.19 mi

Distance

Ark Christian Academy

Private • 01 - 12

2.5 mi

Distance

St Gerard High School

Private • 09 - 12

2.96 mi

Distance

St. Joseph Academy

Private • 09 - 12

3.14 mi

Distance

Beacon Of Hope Christian School

Private • KG - 12

6.58 mi

Distance

Sales & Tax History

Source: Public Records

Date Event Price
10/04/2023 Sold $350,000.00
Street Address Beds Baths Sold Date List Price Valuation Date Valuation Price
65 MAGNOLIA Avenue | Listing 4 3 Nov 04, 2025 $595,000 Dec 26, 2023 $786,682
156 MEADOW Avenue | Listing 4 3 Nov 07, 2025 $699,000 Jun 25, 2024 $958,484
226 MURILLO Avenue | Listing 2 1 Oct 13, 2025 $218,200 Mar 21, 2024 $317,929
7 PARK Avenue 2 1 Nov 04, 2025 $318,000 Nov 10, 2025 -
38 E SAN CARLOS Avenue | Listing 4 3 Oct 07, 2025 $480,000 Aug 20, 2024 $732,544
33 BERNARD Street | Listing 2 1 Nov 04, 2025 $325,000 Feb 15, 2023 $462,200
435 MARALINDA Drive | Listing 4 4 Oct 27, 2025 $903,308 Mar 21, 2024 $856,878
60 ALMERIA Street | Listing 3 2 Nov 04, 2025 $600,000 Feb 23, 2024 $600,720
435 MARALINDA Drive | Listing 4 4 Oct 27, 2025 $903,308 Mar 21, 2024 $856,878
211 OUTRIGGER Way | Listing 5 4 Oct 08, 2025 $1,395,000 Feb 15, 2023 $1,257,000

Population & Environment

Source: Sperling's Best Places

Walkability in FL / 32084

Source: Walkscore

67/100

Somewhat Walkable

Walk Score ®

77/100

Very Bikeable

Bike Score ®

Overview

Some errands can be accomplished on foot. It is possible to get on a bus. Biking is convenient for most trips.

Walkability averages in the surrounding area

The average walkability score in the surrounding area is Walk Score: 20/100, Transit Score: 0/100, Bike Score: 44/100.

Property Change History

Points of Interest near 17 May Street, St Augustine, FL 32084

Frequently Asked Questions for 17 May Street

Source: Realty.com

17 May Street, St Augustine, FL 32084 is a Single Family 1,516 sq. ft. home listed for sale. Realty.com has 42 photos available of this 3 bed, 2 bath house, listed at $375,000. View sales and tax history, use our mortgage calculator and more on Realty.com

Realty.com has 42 photos of 17 May Street.

Our records indicate that 17 May Street was built in 1935.

The full address for this home is 17 May Street, St Augustine, FL 32084.

17 May Street has been listed on Realty.com since Fri June 14, 2019

Some errands can be accomplished on foot. It is possible to get on a bus. Biking is convenient for most trips.

The average walkability score in the surrounding area is Walk Score: 20/100, Transit Score: 0/100, Bike Score: 44/100.

There are 3 schools assigned to this home. Check out the schools near 17 May Street. St. Augustine Public Montessori School (sapms) (Grades: PK - 6), Sebastian Middle School (Grades: 6 - 8), St. Johns Community Campus (Grades: 9 - 12)

Listing provided courtesy of: One Sotheby's International Realty (tel: 904-829-2002)
Listing agent: Irene Arriola (tel: 904-669-0691) (#2825102530)

This content last refreshed on 2025-11-10 00:22:50. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.

Export listing data of 17 May Street, St Augustine, FL 32084 : MLS# 188069

Message
Tour
Chat