New25
$249,900
2 bd · 1 ba · 936 sqft
504 Sheldon Road, Farmington, NY
Karen L. King · Finger Lakes Premier Prop. · on 3 MLSs
Est. $2,040/moGet pre-qualified$171/sqft · 74 days on Realty
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,757
Sqft
1845
Built
Country Living! This 1757 SF, 3 bed, 2 bath farmhouse sits on almost 5 acres with trails throughout, a small pond and is packed with wildlife and various songbirds. Despite being 1 of just 2 houses on low-traffic Cornwall Rd, this fully remodeled and wonderfully appointed home has public water and high-speed internet/cable. The first-floor owner suite is centrally located near the kitchen, laundry, living room and great room, and the kitchen (appliances included!) is adjacent to the living room with a cozy woodstove on one side and sliding glass doors to the elevated deck on the other to enjoy in both summer and winter! The tear-off roof is roughly 10 years old, and all the windows have been replaced with high efficiency vinyl. The attached 2 car garage has a professional epoxy floor, and the electrified shed and tractor barn make for loads of storage. You want a little spread with no neighbors? Come see! Offers due Monday, 6/8 at noon.
Listing record
Choose a source to show its complete, unblended listing record.
Showing NYSShare
NYSShare · Listing R1685443
Courtesy of Howard Hanna
Listing agent
Robert W. Sloan
(585) 750-7665
New York State Alliance · Listing R1685443
Courtesy of Howard Hanna
Listing agent
Robert W. Sloan
(585) 750-7665
New York State Alliance of MLSs · Listing R1685443
Courtesy of Howard Hanna
Listing agent
Robert W. Sloan
(585) 750-7665
Range $308,961 – $501,039 · as of August 30, 2026
ATTOM automated valuation model · 54 published estimates over 6.7 years · shaded band is the model's own published low-to-high range
Highest reading $405,000 in August 2026; lowest $169,895 in March 2020. The vertical scale starts at the series' own low, not at zero — it is drawn to show movement, not absolute size.
$59,980
Estimated monthly payment
$2,040/mo
Loan amount $239,920. Estimate only — your actual rate and payment depend on credit, location, and lender.
2025 roll
New York State AllianceNew York State Alliance of MLSsThis content last refreshed on 2026-10-28 08:57:01 UTC. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.
School ratings (A+ to F) from HJN community data.
Palmyra-Macedon Primary School
KG-2 · Regular · Palmyra-Macedon Central School District
431 students · 11.8:1 student–teacher
Palmyra-Macedon Middle School
6-8 · Regular · Palmyra-Macedon Central School District
354 students · 9.3:1 student–teacher
Palmyra-Macedon High School
9-12 · Regular · Palmyra-Macedon Central School District
513 students · 9.9:1 student–teacher
East Palmyra Christian School
PK-12 · Special Program Emphasis
95 students · 9.0:1 student–teacher
Newark Middle School
6-8 · Regular · Newark Central School District
395 students · 8.6:1 student–teacher
Newark Senior High School
9-12 · Regular · Newark Central School District
586 students · 9.8:1 student–teacher
New25$249,900
2 bd · 1 ba · 936 sqft
504 Sheldon Road, Farmington, NY
Karen L. King · Finger Lakes Premier Prop. · on 3 MLSs
26$300,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,456 sqft
1999 Daansen Road, Palmyra, NY
Naomi Godshall · Hunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus · on 3 MLSs
42$274,900
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,167 sqft
1766 Maple Avenue, Palmyra, NY
Marlene Britton · Keller Williams Realty Gateway · on 3 MLSs
Price Reduced49$324,899
4 bd · 3 ba · 3,350 sqft
138 Church Street, Palmyra, NY
Angelica L Bruno · Keuka Lake & Land Realty · on 3 MLSs
Within 2 miles of this home: 5 restaurants and cafés, 3 parks and green spaces, and 5 transit stops.
Place data from OpenStreetMap.
DQ Grill & Chill
East Main Street
Dunkin
East Main Street
Akropolis
Canal Street
Mark's Pizzeria
East Main Street
Muddy Waters Cafe
Prospect Park
Swift's Landing Park
Union Club Park
Palmyra Library
Main & William
Main & Cuyler
Palmyra Village Hall
Towpath Manor Apartments