Sold comp
- MLS# 804052219626
- Date Listed11/19/2025
- Bedrooms 3
- Bathrooms 2 Full baths
- Lot Size 0.41 acres (17,860 sq. ft)
- Sewer Public Sewer
- Property Type Single Family
- County DANE
- Year Built 1986
- Water Public
- Square Feet 1,463 sq. ft
- Price Per Sq. Ft $307.59
Interior Features
- Appliances Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Water Softener
- Cooling Central Air
- Heating Natural Gas
Exterior / Lot Features
- Roof -
- Lot Size Acres 0.41
- Lot Size SQFT 17,859.60
- Lot Features -
Directions
Siggelkow to south on Valley to west on Rustic
Financial Considerations
- Tax Amount $6,294
- Terms Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA Loan
Nearby Schools
Source: School Digger
Conrad Elvehjem Primary School
Public • PK - 2 • Serves this home
1.49 mi
Distance
Public • 3 - 5 • Serves this home
1.16 mi
Distance
Public • 9 - 12 • Serves this home
1.49 mi
Distance
Conrad Elvehjem Primary School
Public • PK - 2 • Serves this home
1.49 mi
Distance
Public • 3 - 5 • Serves this home
1.16 mi
Distance
Public • 6 - 8
1.5 mi
Distance
Wisconsin Virtual Academy High (wiva)
Public • 9 - 12
0.54 mi
Distance
Destinations Career Academy Of Wisconsin High School
Public • 9 - 12
0.54 mi
Distance
Insight School Of Wisconsin High
Public • 9 - 12
0.54 mi
Distance
Public • 9 - 12 • Serves this home
1.49 mi
Distance
Sales & Tax History
Source: Public Records
| Street Address | Beds | Baths | Sold Date | List Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5202 Cook St | 3 | 3 | Oct 30, 2025 | $350,000 |
| 5509 VALLEY DR | 3 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $300,000 |
| 5301 Summer Trail Rd | 3 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $344,900 |
| 5313 Valley Dr | 3 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $349,900 |
| 5509 Main St | 3 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $284,900 |
| 5312 Autumn Ln | 4 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $299,000 |
| 5309 Cook St | 3 | 3 | Oct 30, 2025 | $380,000 |
| 5408 Forest Lawn Cir | 4 | 3 | Oct 30, 2025 | $399,900 |
| 5302 Church St | 3 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $349,900 |
| 5520 MILWAUKEE ST | 3 | 2 | Oct 30, 2025 | $350,000 |
Population & Environment
Source: Sperling's Best Places
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 13,410 | 9,856 | 563,361 | 335,858,263 |
| Population Density | 762 | 2,041 | 471 | 95 |
| People per Household | 2.5 | 2.6 | 2.3 | 2.6 |
| Median Age | 44 | 42.6 | 38.2 | 39.1 |
| Median Income | $93,682 | $92,572 | $77,623 | $66,222 |
| Average Income | $42,323 | $39,863 | $42,596 | $35,475 |
| Cost of Living Index | 99 | 98 | 88 | 100 |
| Zip | City | County | National | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January Avg. High Temp | 5°F | 5°F | 5°F | 22.6°F |
| July Avg. High Temp | 83.6°F | 83.6°F | 83.6°F | 86.2°F |
| Annual Precipitation | 36.55" | 36.55" | 36.55" | 38" |
33/100
Car-Dependent
Walk Score ®
35/100
Bikable
Bike Score ®
Overview
Most errands require a car. It is possible to get on a bus. Minimal bike infrastructure.Walkability averages in the surrounding area
The average walkability score in the surrounding area is Walk Score: 13/100, Transit Score: 6/100, Bike Score: 32/100.
Property Change History
Points of Interest near 5009 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI 53558
317 ft
Distance
0.21 mi
Distance
0.42 mi
Distance
0.43 mi
Distance
0.48 mi
Distance
0.49 mi
Distance
0.54 mi
Distance
0.56 mi
Distance
0.57 mi
Distance
0.33 mi
Distance
0.49 mi
Distance
0.55 mi
Distance
0.48 mi
Distance
0.49 mi
Distance
0.57 mi
Distance
0.48 mi
Distance
0.59 mi
Distance
0.52 mi
Distance
0.6 mi
Distance
0.53 mi
Distance
0.41 mi
Distance
0.53 mi
Distance
0.55 mi
Distance
0.27 mi
Distance
0.34 mi
Distance
0.42 mi
Distance
0.55 mi
Distance
Nearby Properties
-
$395,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,476 sqft
5802 Leanne Lane, McFarland, WI 53558
Welcome to this charming home nestled in a quaint and quiet neighborhood, just a short walk from local shops and conveniences. Step inside to find a beautifully updated interior featuring maple cabinets and a stunning 2023 kitchen remodel with new so...Listing by: Mike Roessler - Century 21 Affiliated Roessler -
$395,000 Active Under Contract3 bds • 2 ba • 1,476 sqft
5802 Leanne Lane, Mcfarland, WI 53558
Welcome to this charming home nestled in a quaint and quiet neighborhood, just a short walk from local shops and conveniences. Step inside to find a beautifully updated interior featuring maple cabinets and a stunning 2023 kitchen remodel with new so...Listing by: Mike Roessler - Century 21 Affiliated Roessler -
$450,000 Active Under Contract3 bds • 3 ba • 1,651 sqft
4823 Catalina Parkway, Mcfarland, WI 53558
Close to trails, parks & just minutes from Madison & the Beltline, this one checks all the boxes! Move in ready 3-bed, 2.5-bath home w/ a bright, open layout designed for everyday ease. Enjoy SS appliances, granite counters, main-level laundry/mudroo...Listing by: Tyler Van Elzen - Compass Real Estate Wisconsin -
$450,000 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,651 sqft
4823 Catalina Parkway, McFarland, WI 53558
Close to trails, parks & just minutes from Madison & the Beltline, this one checks all the boxes! Move in ready 3-bed, 2.5-bath home w/ a bright, open layout designed for everyday ease. Enjoy SS appliances, granite counters, main-level laundry/mudroo...Listing by: Tyler Van Elzen - Compass Real Estate Wisconsin -
$474,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,660 sqft
6401 Prairie Wood Drive, Mcfarland, WI 53558
Move-in Ready 11/18/25! This Emerald home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances. Own...Listing by: Nick DeMaria - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$449,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,613 sqft
6406 Prairie Wood Drive, McFarland, WI 53558
This Harlow home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances. Owner’s Suite has a private ba...Listing by: Adam Crook - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$449,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1,613 sqft
6406 Prairie Wood Drive, Mcfarland, WI 53558
This Harlow home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances. Owner?s Suite has a private ba...Listing by: Adam Crook - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$434,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,520 sqft
6507 Prairie Wood Drive, Mcfarland, WI 53558
This Jade home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances. Owner?s Suite has a private ba...Listing by: John Ramkey - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$434,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,520 sqft
6507 Prairie Wood Drive, McFarland, WI 53558
This Jade home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances. Owner’s Suite has a private ba...Listing by: John Ramkey - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$469,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,502 sqft
6506 Prairie Wood Drive, McFarland, WI 53558
This Beryl home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances, Owner’s Suite has a private b...Listing by: Kyle Wachter - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$469,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,502 sqft
6506 Prairie Wood Drive, Mcfarland, WI 53558
This Beryl home features a smart, open layout and checks off all your boxes. 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths with locally crafted cabinetry and painted trim and doors throughout. Gourmet kitchen w/ island and stainless appliances, Owner?s Suite has a private b...Listing by: Kyle Wachter - Stark Company, REALTORS -
$442,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,670 sqft
6567 Prairie Wood Drive, McFarland, WI 53558
Your own home for under $450K! (PLUS incentive!) Clean slate to furnish in this BETTER than new home!! Low to no maintenance! Enjoy living without having to deal with large yard, no older home repairs/replacements that are expensive! Get into home...Listing by: R3bel Real Estate Group - Century 21 Affiliated -
$442,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,670 sqft
6567 Prairie Wood Drive, Mcfarland, WI 53558
Your own home for under $450K! (PLUS incentive!) Clean slate to furnish in this BETTER than new home!! Low to no maintenance! Enjoy living without having to deal with large yard, no older home repairs/replacements that are expensive! Get into home...Listing by: R3bel Real Estate Group - Century 21 Affiliated -
$424,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,517 sqft
2701 Telemark Trail, Stoughton, WI 53589
Beautiful 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home in scenic Stoughton. A bright and open floor plan this 2-story home offers a perfect place to live. The living room has an electric fireplace, open to the kitchen with a large eat-in island. There is a dinette or...Listing by: Tara Pearson - Bunbury & Assoc, REALTORS -
$424,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1,517 sqft
2701 Telemark Trail, Stoughton, WI 53589
Beautiful 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home in scenic Stoughton. A bright and open floor plan this 2-story home offers a perfect place to live. The living room has an electric fireplace, open to the kitchen with a large eat-in island. There is a dinette or...Listing by: Tara Pearson - Bunbury & Assoc, REALTORS -
$450,000 Active1 bds • 2 ba • 1,400 sqft
6501 Bridge Road 114, Madison, WI 53713
Your dynamic lifestyle deserves a dynamic space! Welcome to BESA. This live/work community located in Monona offers the savvy small business owner the ability to have a dedicated office space separate from the living space above. Perfect for an artis...Listing by: Mark Gladue - Lauer Realty Group, Inc. -
$450,000 Active1 bds • 2 ba • 1,406 sqft
6501 Bridge Road 115, Madison, WI 53713
Your dynamic lifestyle deserves a dynamic space! Welcome to BESA. This live/work community located in Monona offers the savvy small business owner the ability to have a dedicated office space separate from the living space above. Perfect for an artis...Listing by: Mark Gladue - Lauer Realty Group, Inc. -
$450,000 Active2 bds • 2 ba • 1,401 sqft
6501 Bridge Road 108, Madison, WI 53713
Your dynamic lifestyle deserves a dynamic space! Welcome to BESA. This live/work community located in Monona offers the savvy small business owner the ability to have a dedicated office space separate from the living space above. Perfect for an artis...Listing by: Mark Gladue - Lauer Realty Group, Inc. -
$450,000 Active1 bds • 2 ba • 1,400 sqft
6501 Bridge Road 114, Madison, WI 53713
Your dynamic lifestyle deserves a dynamic space! Welcome to BESA. This live/work community located in Monona offers the savvy small business owner the ability to have a dedicated office space separate from the living space above. Perfect for an artis...Listing by: Mark Gladue - Lauer Realty Group, Inc. -
$450,000 Active1 bds • 2 ba • 1,406 sqft
6501 Bridge Road 115, Madison, WI 53713
Your dynamic lifestyle deserves a dynamic space! Welcome to BESA. This live/work community located in Monona offers the savvy small business owner the ability to have a dedicated office space separate from the living space above. Perfect for an artis...Listing by: Mark Gladue - Lauer Realty Group, Inc.
Similar Priced Comparison
-
$377,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1704 sqft
5412 Main Street
- Home larger by 241 sqft
- Lot smaller by 872 sqft
- Older by 19 years
Listing by: Mary Whitcomb - Compass Real Estate Wisconsin -
$377,000 Active Under Contract3 bds • 2 ba • 1704 sqft
5412 Main Street
- Home larger by 241 sqft
- Lot smaller by 872 sqft
- Older by 19 years
Listing by: Mary Whitcomb - Compass Real Estate Wisconsin -
$515,000 Active4 bds • 4 ba • 2593 sqft
4810 Dream Lane
- Home larger by 1,130 sqft
- Lot smaller by 9,148 sqft
- Newer by 18 years
Listing by: Elissa Zollin - EXP Realty, LLC -
$515,000 Active Under Contract4 bds • 4 ba • 2593 sqft
4810 Dream Lane
- Home larger by 1,130 sqft
- Lot smaller by 9,148 sqft
- Newer by 18 years
Listing by: Elissa Zollin - EXP Realty, LLC -
$399,900 Active Under Contract3 bds • 2 ba • 1725 sqft
5001 Meinders Road
- Home larger by 262 sqft
- Lot smaller by 8,712 sqft
- Newer by 38 years
Listing by: Amy Lewison Berner - Bunbury & Assoc, REALTORS -
$399,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1725 sqft
5001 Meinders Road
- Home larger by 262 sqft
- Lot smaller by 8,712 sqft
- Newer by 38 years
Listing by: Amy Lewison Berner - Bunbury & Assoc, REALTORS -
$524,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1600 sqft
3345 Swinburne Drive
- Home larger by 137 sqft
- Lot larger by 10,890 sqft
- Older by 23 years
Listing by: Seth Pfaehler - The McGrady Group, LLC -
$524,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1600 sqft
3345 Swinburne Drive
- Home larger by 137 sqft
- Lot larger by 10,890 sqft
- Older by 23 years
Listing by: Seth Pfaehler - The McGrady Group, LLC -
$550,000 Active4 bds • 4 ba • sqft
5119-5121 Farwell Street
- Home smaller by 1,463 sqft
- Lot smaller by 1,743 sqft
- Older by 10 years
Listing by: Andie White - Compass Real Estate Wisconsin -
$550,000 Active Under Contract4 bds • 4 ba • 2000 sqft
5119-5121 Farwell Street
- Home larger by 537 sqft
- Lot smaller by 1,743 sqft
- Older by 10 years
Listing by: Andie White - Compass Real Estate Wisconsin -
$549,900 Active3 bds • 4 ba • 2681 sqft
5316 Black Walnut Drive
- Home larger by 1,218 sqft
- Lot smaller by 872 sqft
- Newer by 9 years
Listing by: Jeff Schraml - Century 21 Affiliated -
$549,900 Active Under Contract3 bds • 4 ba • 2681 sqft
5316 Black Walnut Drive
- Home larger by 1,218 sqft
- Lot smaller by 872 sqft
- Newer by 9 years
Listing by: Jeff Schraml - Century 21 Affiliated -
$399,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1730 sqft
3573 Rankin Road
- Home larger by 267 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,485 sqft
- Older by 7 years
Listing by: William Simon - Concept Realty Service, Inc -
$399,900 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1730 sqft
3573 Rankin Road
- Home larger by 267 sqft
- Lot smaller by 3,485 sqft
- Older by 7 years
Listing by: William Simon - Concept Realty Service, Inc -
$395,000 Active3 bds • 2 ba • 1476 sqft
5802 Leanne Lane
- Home larger by 13 sqft
- Lot smaller by 6,970 sqft
- Older by 6 years
Listing by: Mike Roessler - Century 21 Affiliated Roessler -
$395,000 Active Under Contract3 bds • 2 ba • 1476 sqft
5802 Leanne Lane
- Home larger by 13 sqft
- Lot smaller by 6,970 sqft
- Older by 6 years
Listing by: Mike Roessler - Century 21 Affiliated Roessler -
$539,900 Active5 bds • 4 ba • sqft
5802 Sauk Lane
- Home smaller by 1,463 sqft
- Lot smaller by 4,661 sqft
- Newer by 1 years
Listing by: Becca Hamilton - RL Realty Group -
$539,900 Active5 bds • 4 ba • sqft
5802 Sauk Lane
- Home smaller by 1,463 sqft
- Lot smaller by 4,661 sqft
- Newer by 1 years
Listing by: Becca Hamilton - RL Realty Group -
$459,900 Active3 bds • 3 ba • 1693 sqft
6002 Running Deer Trail
- Home larger by 230 sqft
- Lot smaller by 7,406 sqft
- Newer by 13 years
Listing by: Landon Mrowiec - RE/MAX Preferred -
$459,900 Active Under Contract3 bds • 3 ba • 1693 sqft
6002 Running Deer Trail
- Home larger by 230 sqft
- Lot smaller by 7,406 sqft
- Newer by 13 years
Listing by: Landon Mrowiec - RE/MAX Preferred
Nearby Locations
Communities
- Secret Places Homes For Sale
- Hope Homes For Sale
- Terravessa Homes For Sale
- Tonyawatha Homes For Sale
- Lake Edge Homes For Sale
- Elvehjem Homes For Sale
- South Central Side Homes For Sale
- Grandview Commons Homes For Sale
- Eastmorland Homes For Sale
- McClellan Park Homes For Sale
- Grandview Commons North Homes For Sale
- Merri - Hill Homes For Sale
- Swan Creek of Nine Springs Homes For Sale
- Marquette Bungalows Historic District Homes For Sale
- East Side Homes For Sale
- Nordic Ridge Homes For Sale
- Near East Side Homes For Sale
- The Meadowlands Homes For Sale
- East Dayton Street Historic District Homes For Sale
- Hawthorne Homes For Sale
Nearby Zips
- 53558 Homes For Sale
- 53716 Homes For Sale
- 53714 Homes For Sale
- 53713 Homes For Sale
- 53718 Homes For Sale
- 53711 Homes For Sale
- 53575 Homes For Sale
- 53703 Homes For Sale
- 53589 Homes For Sale
- 53527 Homes For Sale
- 53726 Homes For Sale
- 53704 Homes For Sale
- 53705 Homes For Sale
- 53521 Homes For Sale
- 53719 Homes For Sale
- 53531 Homes For Sale
- 53598 Homes For Sale
- 53590 Homes For Sale
- 53717 Homes For Sale
- 53536 Homes For Sale
Nearby Cities
- Mcfarland, WI Homes for Sale
- Dunn, WI Homes for Sale
- Monona, WI Homes for Sale
- Stoughton, WI Homes for Sale
- Vilas, WI Homes for Sale
- Oregon, WI Homes for Sale
- Madison, WI Homes for Sale
- Fitchburg, WI Homes for Sale
- Rutland, WI Homes for Sale
- Cottage Grove, WI Homes for Sale
- Maple Bluff, WI Homes for Sale
- Brooklyn, WI Homes for Sale
- Union, WI Homes for Sale
- Dunkirk, WI Homes for Sale
- Sun Prairie, WI Homes for Sale
- Evansville, WI Homes for Sale
- Deerfield, WI Homes for Sale
- Middleton, WI Homes for Sale
- Waunakee, WI Homes for Sale
- Deforest, WI Homes for Sale
Similar Searches
- Mcfarland Land for Sale
- Mcfarland New Homes for Sale
- Mcfarland Single Story Homes for Sale
- Mcfarland Homes with Pools for Sale
- Mcfarland Cheap Homes for Sale
- Mcfarland Luxury Homes for Sale
- Mcfarland Condos for Sale
- Mcfarland Town Homes for Sale
- Mcfarland Commercial for Sale
- Mcfarland Open Houses for Sale
- Mcfarland Two Car Garage Homes for Sale
- Mcfarland Large Lots for Sale
- National Listings
- National Home Values
- Properties in WI
- Home Values in WI
- Other properties in DANE, WI
- Other properties in 53558, WI
- Home Values in Mcfarland, WI
Frequently Asked Questions for 5009 Rustic Way
Source: Realty.com
5009 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI 53558 is a Single Family 1,463 sq. ft. home listed for sale. Realty.com has 1 photos available of this 3 bed, 2 bath house, listed at $450,000. View sales and tax history, use our mortgage calculator and more on Realty.com
Our records indicate that 5009 Rustic Way was built in 1986.
The full address for this home is 5009 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI 53558.
Most errands require a car. It is possible to get on a bus. Minimal bike infrastructure.
The average walkability score in the surrounding area is Walk Score: 13/100, Transit Score: 6/100, Bike Score: 32/100.
There are 3 schools assigned to this home. Check out the schools near 5009 Rustic Way. Conrad Elvehjem Primary School (Grades: PK - 2), Waubesa Intermediate School (Grades: 3 - 5), Mcfarland High School (Grades: 9 - 12)
Listing provided courtesy of:
The Kruse Company, Realtors
(tel: 608-231-5151)
Listing agent:
Kelly Maly
(tel: 608-243-8234)
(#90019369255)
This content last refreshed on 2025-11-19 20:47:05. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.
Export listing data of 5009 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI 53558 : MLS# 804052219626