Location

Nearby schools

School ratings (A+ to F) from HJN community data.

Pilgrim Lutheran School
PK-8 · Regular
68 students · 8.7:1 student–teacher
1.0 mi
Immanuel Lutheran School
PK-8 · Regular
319 students · 12.5:1 student–teacher
1.4 mi
Marcy Elementary School
KG-4 · Regular · Hamilton School District
488 students · 15.3:1 student–teacher
Marcy Elementary School school rating: A 1.5 mi
Fairview South
5-12 · Special Education · Elmbrook School District
9 students · 1.0:1 student–teacher
1.7 mi
Burleigh Elementary School
PK-5 · Regular · Elmbrook School District
927 students · 16.2:1 student–teacher
Burleigh Elementary School school rating: A+ 1.7 mi
St Agnes School
PK-8 · Regular
110 students · 7.8:1 student–teacher
1.7 mi
St Dominic Catholic School
PK-8 · Regular
328 students · 7.7:1 student–teacher
1.8 mi
Zion Evangelical Lutheran School
KG-8 · Regular
94 students · 13.2:1 student–teacher
1.9 mi

Nearby places

Within 2 miles of this home: 11 restaurants and cafés, 2 grocery stores, and 8 parks and green spaces.

Place data from OpenStreetMap.

Food & drink

Pistol Pete's
American restaurant · West Lisbon Road
0.6 mi
McDonald's
Silver Spring Drive
1.1 mi
Dunkin
Silver Spring Drive
1.2 mi
Jimmy John's
1.2 mi
Domino's
West Capitol Drive
1.4 mi
Schwabenhof
1.4 mi
Java Train
1.5 mi
Subway
W14108 Sliver Spring Drive
1.6 mi

Groceries

Karl's Country Market
Pilgrim Road
1.3 mi
Lilly Mart
Silver Spring Drive
1.6 mi

Parks & recreation

Three Meadows Park
0.4 mi
Lilly Heights Park
0.7 mi
Northeast Park
0.8 mi
Willowood Park
1.0 mi
Fairview Park
1.2 mi
Iyke's Pond
1.2 mi
The Hounds and Tap
Technology Drive
1.7 mi
Frontier Park
1.9 mi

The 53005 market

Homes for sale: 56
Median list price: $559,000

Similar homes nearby

See all in 53005

Sources for the nearby listings shown on this page

Metro MLS: Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified. The multiple listing data appearing on this website, or contained in reports produced therefrom, is owned and copyrighted by MetroMLS and is protected by all applicable Copyright © 2026 laws. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. Information being provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright © 2026 MetroMLS. All Rights Reserved.
Wisconsin Real Estate Exchange (WIREX): IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use, may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by the MLS.

Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.

No listing photos

4685 Pilgrim Rd, Brookfield WI 53005

3

Beds

2.5

Baths

2,700

Sqft

1954

Year built

Estimated value: $591,190

Range $531,287 – $651,093 · as of July 14, 2026

How this estimate has moved

ATTOM automated valuation model · 53 published estimates over 6.5 years · shaded band is the model's own published low-to-high range

$440,440 January 2020$591,190 July 2026

Highest reading $714,896 in August 2025; lowest $430,680 in April 2020. The vertical scale starts at the series' own low, not at zero — it is drawn to show movement, not absolute size.

Public records

3 beds
2.5 baths
2,700 sqft
84,942 sqft lot
Built 1954
Stories: 1
Use: RESIDENTIAL
APN BR C-1017-995

Estimate your monthly payment

Home price

Down payment (20%)

$118,238

Loan term

Interest rate (%)

Property tax (%/yr)

Home insurance ($/yr)

HOA ($/mo)

Estimated monthly payment

$3,789/mo

Principal & interest$3,131

Property tax$542

Home insurance$117

Loan amount $472,952. Estimate only — your actual rate and payment depend on credit, location, and lender.

Tax history

2025 roll

Land: $174,600
Structure: $353,600
Assessed total: $528,200
County market value: $594,800
Property tax billed: $6,089.65

Sale & deed history

January 6, 2026Arm's-length$575,000
October 1, 2021Arm's-length—
June 1, 2020Arm's-lengthCash$400,100
July 19, 2012Arm's-length$335,000
August 19, 2004Arm's-length$212,000