Listings in 10963 - Sullivan County, New York

Page 1 of 1

242 Old Mountain Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 16, 2026
Price: $599,900
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

3 Shoddy Hollow Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 19, 2026
Price: $559,000
Living Area: 1,906 Sq. Ft.

185 Grange Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 13, 2026
Price: $1,500,000
Living Area: 6,766 Sq. Ft.

24 Forest Hills Lane
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Oct, 23, 2025
Price: $749,000
Living Area: 2,900 Sq. Ft.

39 Orchard Street
Otisville, NY | Pending
Listed: Mar, 27, 2026
Price: $459,990
Living Area: 1,244 Sq. Ft.

1635 State Route 211
Otisville, NY | Pending
Listed: Apr, 18, 2026
Price: $369,000
Living Area: 1,107 Sq. Ft.

4 Dodd Lane
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Jun, 05, 2026
Price: $2,400
Living Area: 1,152 Sq. Ft.

234 Shoddy Hollow Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 23, 2026
Price: $634,900
Living Area: 2,078 Sq. Ft.

82 State Street
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Jun, 04, 2026
Price: $1,875
Living Area: 2,680 Sq. Ft.

33 Walker Street
Middletown, NY | Active
Listed: Jun, 10, 2026
Price: $398,000
Living Area: 1,584 Sq. Ft.

4 Mt Hope Avenue
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: May, 14, 2026
Price: $359,900
Living Area: 1,566 Sq. Ft.

6 Field Road
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 18, 2026
Price: $368,000
Living Area: 1,648 Sq. Ft.

83 High Hope Drive
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Sep, 17, 2025
Price: $829,500
Living Area: 3,413 Sq. Ft.

80 Main Street
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 02, 2026
Price: $2,200
Living Area: 1,188 Sq. Ft.

315 Upper Road LOWER
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 18, 2026
Price: $1,550
Living Area: 750 Sq. Ft.

99 Whitlock Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Jun, 10, 2026
Price: $749,000
Living Area: 2,826 Sq. Ft.

200 Shoddy Hollow Road
Otisville, NY | Pending
Listed: Feb, 04, 2026
Price: $609,900
Living Area: 1,768 Sq. Ft.

19 Lewis Street
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Sep, 29, 2025
Price: $250,000
Living Area: 814 Sq. Ft.

18 Seybolt Avenue
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Dec, 01, 2025
Price: $229,900
Living Area: 1,224 Sq. Ft.

22 Seybolt Avenue
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: May, 07, 2026
Price: $299,000
Living Area: 864 Sq. Ft.

3 Old Country Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Dec, 11, 2025
Price: $970,000
Living Area: 1,440 Sq. Ft.

17 Lewis Street
Otisville, NY | Pending
Listed: Apr, 24, 2026
Price: $299,000
Living Area: 1,060 Sq. Ft.

105 Main Street
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 27, 2026
Price: $225,000
Living Area: 788 Sq. Ft.

9 Emboden Avenue
Otisville, NY | Pending
Listed: Apr, 06, 2025
Price: $360,000
Living Area: 1,272 Sq. Ft.

180 Shoddy Hollow Road
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 22, 2025
Price: $449,000
Living Area: 1,824 Sq. Ft.

113 Whitlock Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 04, 2026
Price: $723,900
Living Area: 3,000 Sq. Ft.

218 Shoddy Hollow Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Feb, 04, 2026
Price: $634,900
Living Area: 2,078 Sq. Ft.

130 Whitlock Road
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: May, 31, 2026
Price: $2,300
Living Area: 1,024 Sq. Ft.

28 Forest Hills Lane
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Jul, 09, 2025
Price: $775,000
Living Area: 2,900 Sq. Ft.

9 Kelly Hill Road 2
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 23, 2026
Price: $1,700
Living Area: 1,000 Sq. Ft.

7 Sagamore Drive
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Jan, 15, 2026
Price: $474,999
Living Area: 2,200 Sq. Ft.

8 Dot Calm Drive
Otisville, NY | Pending
Listed: Apr, 08, 2026
Price: $599,900
Living Area: 2,256 Sq. Ft.

180 Grange Road
Otisville, NY | Closed
Listed: Feb, 23, 2026
Price: $474,888
Living Area: 1,885 Sq. Ft.

523 Old Mountain Road
Middletown, NY | Pending
Listed: Apr, 30, 2026
Price: $2,500,000
Living Area: 3,662 Sq. Ft.

59 Schobl Street
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 24, 2026
Price: $449,900
Living Area: 1,632 Sq. Ft.

31 State Street
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: Jan, 05, 2026
Price: $349,000
Living Area: 1,394 Sq. Ft.

18 Penny Lane
Otisville, NY | Active
Listed: May, 25, 2026
Price: $3,500
Living Area: 2,400 Sq. Ft.

Page 1 of 1