Listings in 11964 - Suffolk County, New York

Page 1 of 1

25 W Neck Road 4
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 17, 2025
Price: $2,500,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

141A N Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Nov, 01, 2025
Price: $4,250,000
Living Area: 5,500 Sq. Ft.

100 S Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: May, 19, 2025
Price: $4,445,000
Living Area: 5,622 Sq. Ft.

1 Strawberry Lane
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Oct, 11, 2025
Price: $695,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

16 Shelterlands Path
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 07, 2026
Price: $1,175,000
Living Area: 1,950 Sq. Ft.

12 Dogwood Lane
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Dec, 01, 2025
Price: $14,400
Living Area: 2,669 Sq. Ft.

47L S Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Dec, 19, 2025
Price: $50,000
Living Area: 3,800 Sq. Ft.

1 Gazon Road
Shelter Island, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 18, 2025
Price: $1,250,000
Living Area: 2,618 Sq. Ft.

13 Tarkettle Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Oct, 06, 2025
Price: $2,999,000
Living Area: 1,373 Sq. Ft.

8 Hilo Drive
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Feb, 16, 2026
Price: $3,850,000
Living Area: 3,985 Sq. Ft.

9 Johnston Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 15, 2026
Price: $20,000
Living Area: 1,850 Sq. Ft.

14 Freds Lane
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 31, 2026
Price: $2,485,000
Living Area: 3,413 Sq. Ft.

15 Montclair Avenue
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Jul, 07, 2022
Price: $75,000
Living Area: 4,600 Sq. Ft.

42 N Menantic Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Dec, 02, 2025
Price: $7,500
Living Area: 2,825 Sq. Ft.

4 Ivy Place
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Oct, 22, 2025
Price: $63,000
Living Area: 1,487 Sq. Ft.

156 Ram Island Drive
Shelter Island, NY | Closed
Listed: Sep, 07, 2024
Price: $2,750,000
Living Area: 3,420 Sq. Ft.

27 Country Club Drive
Shelter Island, NY | Closed
Listed: Apr, 03, 2025
Price: $1,850,000
Living Area: 3,170 Sq. Ft.

59 Peconic Avenue
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 01, 2026
Price: $8,700
Living Area: 2,018 Sq. Ft.

13 Winthrop Road 24
Shelter Island Heights, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 24, 2026
Price: $499,000
Living Area: 39,964 Sq. Ft.

73 N Midway Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Oct, 30, 2025
Price: $1,845,000
Living Area: 2,296 Sq. Ft.

52 S Midway Rd
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Jul, 11, 2025
Price: $3,395,000
Living Area: 2,200 Sq. Ft.

9 Locust Woods Drive
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 07, 2026
Price: $3,499,000
Living Area: 3,856 Sq. Ft.

12 Terry Dr.
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 27, 2026
Price: $2,950,000
Living Area: 4,200 Sq. Ft.

15A / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 29, 2025
Price: $9,955,000
Living Area: 3,944 Sq. Ft.

20 Crescent Way
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Oct, 09, 2025
Price: $1,375,000
Living Area: 1,575 Sq. Ft.

21 North Ferry Road B, G
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Feb, 18, 2025
Price: $13,500
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

26 S Menantic Road
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Aug, 25, 2025
Price: $1,695,000
Living Area: 1,702 Sq. Ft.

10 Strawberry Lane
Shelter Island, NY | Pending
Listed: Aug, 18, 2025
Price: $1,195,000
Living Area: 1,340 Sq. Ft.

21 Thompson Road
Shelter Island, NY | Closed
Listed: Aug, 29, 2025
Price: $5,875,000
Living Area: 1,504 Sq. Ft.

4 Glynn Drive
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Mar, 23, 2026
Price: $30,000
Living Area: 2,604 Sq. Ft.

3a/3b Pandion Rd 3a/3b
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Jan, 14, 2025
Price: $6,999,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

100 Peconic
Shelter Island, NY | Active
Listed: Apr, 28, 2025
Price: $4,000,000
Living Area: 1,626 Sq. Ft.

26 Ole Buck Run
Shelter Island, NY | Active Under Contract
Listed: Mar, 28, 2025
Price: $1,035,000
Living Area: 0 Sq. Ft.

Page 1 of 1